1 25 9 https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/55f863aecd9825394241a8ec13126933.pdf d9ba413eee5a8d0e79508b0ce75215ff PDF Text Text Nmllj SJarrgfnum, Nan f nrk L . O U N S B U R Y , PgS»ftJENT ICE-PRESIDENT "NDERXTS*i^l8ECRETARY RGAREJ UNSPAUGH, TREASURER N O R T H T A R R Y T O W N , N. Y., January 6th, 1932. jolm J. Lofaro, Esq.., Secretary, Zoning Board of Appeals, 59 Chestnut Street, North Tarrytown, New York Dear Mr. Lofaro: The Board of Direotors of the Philipse Manor Improvement Association has again instructed me to write to you for information upon what seems to be a most peculiar situation. On November 13th I wrote inquiring about the status of the case against Red Gables. I received your reply of November 16th stating that you had written Village Attorney Siniiott and the Board of Trustees and would communicate with me further upon hearing from either or both. We have had no further word from you, but we have heard as follows from Trustee George W. Hutchinson, who called upon me about December 6th and volunteered these reasons for the inactivity of his associates. 1. A general feeling that the legal case is weak, because a permit had been issued, even though this was subsequently revoked. 2. Mr. Hutchinson had been informed that even should the Railroad Building and Loan Association meet with defeat in an initial legal action, it would plan to carry the case to the highest possible court. 3. A belief that this would involve the Village in a costly litigation. 4. A feeling that the Village would not be favorable to the idea of expending the necessary funds. Will you please advise us in this matter. Did not the Zoning Board of Appeals decide after a public hearing, that the Zoning Ordinance was being violated and direct that such violation be stopped? If this is correct, how can the Board of Trustees permit a continuation of such a violation? Is that not a matter for the Supreme Court? �^ v LPH R - l ;L.D»- e' 9". f , h % i i.i �®\\* m t Hannr Jmprowmettt Aaannatum Sfarilj ®arrytotti«# 3$Vttt fork Pu DIRECTORS: R- LOUNSBURY, PRESIDENT PlEUD L- MORSE, VICE-PRESIDENT FRANK D. TURNER GARET HOWARD L. BERKEY L> WUNDERL1CH, SECRETARY D U N S P A U G H . TREASURER WILLIAM C. SCHMIDT N O R T H T A R R Y T O W N . N. Y., ~ 2 - The integrity of the Zoning Ordinance is of the utmost importance to every property owner in our Village and we will appreciate your>pecri^ reply explaining to us just how the Zoning Ordinance is to be enforc/ Very trul Philipse Manor Improvement Association by J« Irving Greene, Secretary 74 Merlin Avenue North Tarrytown, N. Y. ��HI MONTHLY REPORT OF BUILDING INSPECTOR FOR ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y. "2 permits granted Permits d e n i e d From ?>°n-e- Pec..20 t h 1 M I t o-J°?.?...?.?-?l: as - 193-? - follows Appl:i c a t i o n of --.-...Yincent.Oeccplini_. ?n®^.9?I_.?:&&itA03.. Building located at ..I25..Beekmn.Ave, Permit granted-denied- o n - - ^ - * 7 1 h Application of .M?..,.^B*ell? 193? Permit No-?-?- ......s5.c.^...s^L.E^?.h. - Building located at .58..01toten__St Permit granted-denied on----9®-°-?-?-^-?. Application of - 193.5 Permit No-?-?-?- - Building located at - Permit granted-denied on 193 Permit No- 193 Permit No- 193 Permit No- 193 Permit No- Application of Building located at Permit granted-denied on - Application of Building located at Permit granted-denied on Application of Building Located at Permit granted-denied on....— �•'- Application of - ""-:":"-":"-—-:""V"-";"""""' Building located at Permit granted-denied on Application of -- --r- ---193 Permit No- ------^-—,—----r—'---::::^—•:—-----—' Building located at —- Permit grant ed-denied on - -193---.---Perm.ii No_ Application Of. /•»-—•;:;--™^vrv:v^:f^- — ^ v ^ - » 9 - Building located at - ---.——- ; - ..—-i^U. ---- -----—--- - Permit'granted^deni^dOTi-"--------^ .-*•-£......;,..-.;:: Application of , ...........................^.^ ........^.r.;. Building located .a,t.::-—-—A-——»*--—----.- -.- - - - - —----- Permit grant ed^d-enied on---^--^---------------^ Apipll'cati6n'''6f'V™:J.'..Il...'.:.'..-..'....^...„..ll Building located at —r^:ir-.^-----—--• Permit .•wrv-?-.^.-' * • • ' granted^eniedion---^ ,.. Application of .i z. ....t... ...-•- L... •.* •*> r B u i l d i n g l o c a t e d a t ----^ - 193--, : ^ermlt No^ Permit- granted-deni-eijt-oifc w */;----i. '#*-j. >i-.Vi> Dated: North Tarrytown, N . Y. , J&n-dth- --.. : 3i &':•:> Fi 19552- Z'~*<"^rf^<Mf™< lding Inspected of the —i*" Villa w — . - * J J. Se 0 ^..North Tarrytowai,. .&. Y. - V» -> - '•^ �8^ 3mm&Xf 14* l§SStt fh* *fo&Xi#»# Manor ym$mmmmn* Association Borth f A^r%#mf ff» 1« gentle****! Attention of 8*»« #,» trwtog &p#e»e* Secretary Amftwe^tog yew totfekr $£ January f • 1®B$S# we are glad to anew** tb« questions you raise irege^dtog the operating of the sonissg J&w* &&& th# partictiXar e«e* ef Red Oatolee, We t*e*e not written to ye& egftto etoe* em l«tt«r of Hovembor 1$# 1631, for the reason ttol this Board hee not received, to the interval* any report from the Village Counsel, although eueh report ha* been revested In writing ©n Oafeofeer 26, 1951 and again on So^smbor 10^ 1931* llor ha* the $e**& e£ Smite*** ©r mtjf jaembar of it* <*<»awuniaated with the Board of Appeals in any w*y9 with reepeefc .%t* t&i«,eae«u The Board *f Appeals i s the onlyto<**ywithin th© Village author*. ised toy to* to determine what are emd what are not violations of the Zoning £aw, lt« decisions ore subjeot to wfwiew* and te modification or revsrsal oaly Iqr *&* Supria* Cowt» We thvxvtw* feel that there nmat be aome misunderstanding as to J%«t what Trustae Baiehinson Intended t© e#a*«y to you* ire ere oonfident that the Beard of $*n*t*e* would not, even it member* of the Beerd of Appeal* * who not onlj heard the oral testimony* but strsdied the stenographic transcript of i t ***** fully* lief w e reaching i t e deeisios* At to the speeifle statements saade fcy Trustee mtohinson, the first i$ rather surprising, to *$** ef the fact that the Village Cotansel* at a matting of the Board est Truatee»# at which aoei ' of w^wm/m**** i*fa#' Mhpi**f «4iJiM^ ' "" S esmld not aa&e an waawfvl aet lawful, and that thia sofuld not e p ^SWPwewr WflpWw ' iW piiwpp w w w e ^Wfen^ W ^ ^ P ^ m*&9wH* W^r ^Pjp^SI*Wj^^r*W*Jj flefee^^^"^ae™<^p^^ ^^iw ^w-^w l^pie? eW^i-'w *r*seT T "**""^ eP^** T T '"" , T Jrr^"'™" ^^^ jae^^^w^wwiM^i ^F •w^ji ^^>^i^p app^^pmMp^ev^pwvEa '"• """ J "T"•'" • —* j p ^ai^ewe^aw^we^ ^p*^^p m be «et up in defenee of an unlawful aetf evon it the permit were not wabae<iuently revolted, Stt thia pertieular ea«of net only wa* the yirait promptly re* ^F^w**aw'Wwfl^ flire'p'^T e^^eww ^ ^ w ^^ww^p^p^^^iw ^^HI^WP^^W''^BF ^pe*e^^ ^^ W&R& ^^^w^^ppp^^^p^iei^j^p: j/r^9^^^^^^jBi ^ ^ F ^ ^ ar w ^ ^ ^ quired by Seotlen It «t tha Ordlnenee! ware ewer filed with the Bolldinf Xnapeeter * Seetion It providee thet no eenetruotion or alteration* exoesding to e?»t flOO* ahall be started tmtll ^ ^toAb MLMHk ^ ^ ^ jP^P^^ leait^ajfet wP^a^^wa^ *Mb« ^a^a?A jjMepew^^^p 'W-A^MSav ^^^^"9^ %Mfa-^MWK ^^^w^w^* ^f^k • - ^ ^ J B ^r,^wsW*^V^W|Hr ife^eeft ^^w^wa^ aBl^a^k T^^P^H^ Mktf^vttH^ ^^^^4rla ^e^aMttMdMIHt'Jb^ft ^^wrmr^ ™ » T ^ ^ e sUMF ^^tf J^fte^sv • ^ , �%.• - y$4 tf> '<•-• 111: #\ '1 , ; �•«,..« w r 51 fttfcttit*' Hutohifceon** 8^oondp third and fourth |x>iBta *# aassn&t b#&£*w :**/»+**** t h o policy .«£ ow Village awement^ b©o^s«s on i t s face i t la an op«» imitation tottj^rom to violate a&f Ifew -eritihln tho Village* withmit .ftw of penalty# toy tli« alxaple d©Tle© of thr«at«tting to avail himself of hi* natural ri^it to defend himaslf and h i t «M$ta in the Courts that ar© provided for that gmrposfu . ftatft i* of Gwxrnm wvXtv tha 'Zoni&g x*w mi aaewulating pamlfcy at f t t a $*$r fartfa&3Lw*io abate a violation* and the Village i« entitled tott*>#&#*4to ooXXaot this sraa % a aaparata action, l&d*p<md®nt of Xmju&otion pr^#o©dl»g8» fka immmt a* penalty at $h# trafc* «f $2$ f t * day i f far aocuaaaatad i& thia aaa* in apt to te g^aatar than aoy *$$*&$« tMKPtXwad to gfWMtti&g thin $»** «v#n i f '*p$#a&6&# Withoat any knowledge of sm^r dalibw&tiona on thS» subject by tba Board of Trustaefl* w# f©*l certain that th#ra araafc b© ©«»&a laiata&o as to ib* intandad purport of Truateo &it©hln«on*fi atata&ft&t to yotl« $&a Boars! of Tlttataaa* iiidtvldttitXXy and a» a body, ara kaenly a&tvt to th© important proiaotiofc to property vaXuoa whioh hae fetaa provided by tb* zoning Law* Wo fa«X cartaln that the Board of truataas will ba tag** to tm~ bold the Zoning Law and prevant 'its violatiosa, at Xeaat tot will not aaasme' tha ©oatrary uatil oosspallad by dlraot wi&mxm or unreasonable dalay t# do at* $ft tilt pfertloolar - aaaa of Raft 0abla«ft about whioh yow ioqul^o * *# bavo followad our uau&i prooadura* XoBnadiataXy* af tar raaah* Ifcg our daoiaion. oa Sapfctatoar 24 t wa aubmittad to tha ViXXaga OoitttSfti a copy of our daaiaioa, iagatha* with a tranaoript of tha taatimooy *a& th* ftXXawifcg raaolutioat *Ra*©X*ad that * violation of tha zoning &*• eatiate l a th* **tt of tha prasaiaaa known *« Had OabXfta aad tikt 4siluiOT&ty gifaiit#d in station IX af t3aa Setiixig ftfditUknot to taka iaawdiata lagal atapa ta aa?mra a paw»»*at i»}t»iiati«ii for tba imrpoaa of $>*©vonfcing a ootttimatioaa. of thia violaUou ©p if ha la ^ vm%l* t» m& rm*m to do ao to eonfw with thia Board aft t0 th« aaloetion of othar $mtm&+* Aa to tha anferoaaaut of tha Soain^ Saw* Saotioii n pro^ldaft aa foiiewai *Tha Buildiog lnapootor# tha Board of AppaaiaM and . tha Board of Tmiataaa of the viUaga* or aithar^ : , ^ffw8^<iaKai ••^•'w^,ap' ^wp?*f^r' • ,^aNHi^wa»'- arwF. wF^4^^p^#^^PWTBF^^ ^a^w^w jipa*-a^TW'^^.^piw''*Tiawaw(a, ^WPP- . "~ \a OMiiaaiiaa bsr iBJanatloii auft f<M? otbar wottitabla �£V �•<#S*» 0' m **••' :«$*!&wilting %h.® &&W& of $#t&«$«Mf «*&&lktg theia a eogy ©f fimik i.#tt#* &n& atMag them to ocKKimnicat^ directly wil& yasi Tourtt very trtay ? ; ZQtfXm BOARD OP APPFJVLS Secretary �.»' v •;• i ':( • \ '* * 1 » /• - V *I * l . ^ ' « , - , -':• ; • Hall V.* 4 * ' '}' ' ^ -K* . •-Hi Iff *,*K. *>e- .<//•>?• �ftMKtp''M* MM TOfch©HOBo^abX© Board #ff Trueteea fi&t*S© of Korth Ta^z^tcwa^ K» T» th^ FhlUps© Manor toprov*m*nt Association and of otu* reply wa a&»«& sot s a i l t© youx* ^t^ntiOB th« «mbarraejii#£ position that v# h^T* no Information aii ttt what action i s bsi&g ta&ett .$» this* aaeo* A§ f ofc mmim i m ^ ^^u©»t«d this information r©peAt*<lly to avoid this adbafraesiR&rit* for tho Board of Truatt** aa wall aa for owealvaa* To date wo fcava not had ftii^ woipd-f|N»a 3rott'# tat o w opinioa m tmoffioica Truatsaa |M>»itio& with r#3ap* apt to b* aarioutly In oM*# to avoid any fiirthey migtt3aa»rataQdiBe w i l l y«m Secretary of tho P h i l i p s Jtomo^ fcapswament Aftsoaiation* ZOKIW BOARD W APPEALS s^oyotai^t - �V s. M •'.• • S '•• ' : ,, '.?/,, m �57 8wnm*f M§ .&9W* My d©nr Kr# Sinnotfci SNP p3?»»0a«>« 1ft £*$$«*$*& At the mat ragalar meeting of tfc# Zoning Bo&rd of Appeals t© b* held at tfa© Cw* a»8Wt«fjr* �& M< Sffi m � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_ZONING_1932-01-06 Subject The topic of the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1932 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Village of Sleepy Hollow All Rights Reserved. Type The nature or genre of the resource Text https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/a23240351784a6a7d3bd5cb27181a288.pdf a77f1293fcbbecba2d1616a9b6a0b8f4 PDF Text Text At a Regular Meeting of The Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of N0rth Tarrytown, N. Y. held at the Corporation Rooms, in the said Village, on the 20th day of January, 1932. Present; Gerald B. Gould, Chairman John K. Mullon David Page, Jr. John J. Lofaro, Secretary Mr. Gould called the meeting to order at 8:10 o'clock P.M. The minutes of the regular meeting held on December 16th, 1931.were read and approved. The Building Inspector^ report, dated January 8th, 1932 was read and ordered to be placed on file. A letter from the Philipse Manor Improvement Association, dated January 6th, 1932,. and the reply thereto, dated January 14th, 1932, and the letter to the Honorable Board of Trustees, dated January 14th, 1932, were read. The Secretary informed the Board of the receipt of certified copies of the minutes of the Board of Trustees relating to the change from Residence to Business of that particular property on the northwest corner of Broadway and Depeyster Street. Mr. Gould informed the Board that he held a telephonic conversation with Mr. Sinnott who informed him that he (Mr. Sinnott) could not very well attend the meetings of this Board on Wednesday evenings due to other engagements on said days and that any Tuesday or Thursday evening would be most convenient. �Sf �Mr. Mullon moved that the Board adjourn this meeting to Tuesday evening, January 26th, at which time Mr. Sinnott would attend. Mr. Page duly seconded said motion and the meeting was adjourned. Chairman \ �i»v 4, ',? -;4 «? K « is? ��&$$£ ,d2 ypmm&% . , i ' **&t #A afools'o 0 i | 7 t * ^M9X , ^ 0 8 manual, ^ l i a s v © ^WOf TgI#*#©*lX® � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_ZONING_1932-01-20 Subject The topic of the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1932 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Village of Sleepy Hollow All Rights Reserved. Type The nature or genre of the resource Text https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/d876bf47a692b2cc5c9231a7785e865e.pdf dd6143f15716c9ac6210bef1941cc03b PDF Text Text At an adjourned meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y. held at the Corporation Rooms in said Village on the 26th day of January, 1932. Present: Gerald B. Gould, Chairman William C. Schmidt John K. Mullon David Page, Jr. John J. Lofaro, Secretary John J. Sinnott, Corporation Counsel Mr. Gould called the meeting to order at 7:35 P.M. He stated that this was an adjourned meeting called for the purpose of hearing Mr. Sinnott1s views on the question regarding the enforcement of the Zoning violation existing on premises known as "Red Gables." Mr. Gould then called upon Mr. Sinnott. Mr. Sinnott stated that nothing was done toy him as counsel in the way of bringing a law suit to restrain the owners from using the premises as an apartment house. He said that he was directed toy the Board of Trustees not to toring such a suit. Mr. Sinnott stated that he thought the litigation for the purposes of obtaining equitable relief would toe an expensive proceeding and needed the sanction of the Board of Trustees "before such expenses were incurred. He said that the Board of Trustees felt that inasmuch as the changes or alterations were on the interior of the building, no one suffered any damage. Mr. Sinnott said that Mayor Gross told him that he (Mayor Gross) had a conference with one Mr. Williams of the law firm of Crandall, Grant and Williams, attorneys for the owners of "Red Gables" and that the said Mr. Williams told Mayor Gross that the owners were about to dispose of the said property to a purchaser v/ho would convert the building to a one-fiamily residence; that shortly after and following the Mayors statement to him, Mr. Sinnott wrote to the attorneys of the owners of said premises concerning the said conference and the same was confirm- �, ". : ! i it: tl- I i �ed by s. Mr. Grant of the above mentioned firm who, in addition to Mr. Williams* remark, said that the owners had no intention of continuing the use of the building as an apartment house although they had a right to do so and dispose of the said building to their best advantage. Mr. Sinnott said that he Mad more than one discussion with the Board of Trustees on this same subject and felt that since he is employed by the Board of Trustees, and under their direction, he must comply with their orders. He said that since the matter was referred to him, no communications were ever submitted to him by the Board of Trustees. He further said that a few days after this Board referred to him the matter of the violation, he took it up with the Board of Trustees and that his recollection in the matter was that the Board of Trustees passed a resolution directing him not to do anything regarding same. Mr. Gould pointed out to Mr. Sinnott that his- report disclosed a very peculiar situation, which in practical effect seemed to be quite contrary to the intention of the law. The Board of Appeals differs from all other village departments, in that it is the only one which, under the law, does not serve at the pleasure of the Board of Trustees. Furthermore, its decisions are definitely only reviewable by the Supreme Court. These facts, in conjunction with the definitemention in the law of the right of any village officer to bring certiorari proceedings for the review of the decisions of the Board of Appeals makes it perfectly clear the intention of the law is that the decisions of this Board shall be absolutely free from interference of a political nature. The law also provides that it shall be enforced by the Building Inspector, or by the Board of Appeals, or, as a last resort, by the Board of Trustees, and that the members of the Board of Appeals felt that a definite duty was. placed upon them by the law, and that this responsibility would not be relieved by assuming that the Board of Trustees had the exclusive power to enforce the provisions of the ordinance. Mr. Gould pointed out that the situation described by Mr. Sinnott was quite contrary to the understanding of the members of the Board of Appeals as to the powers and duties of the various officers involved. His explanation indicated that the Board of Trustees, none of whom had attended the public hearing in the case, of "Red Gables" had twice definitely instructed him as Village Counsel, not to bring any action in this case and that their decision was apparently based at least �r • !. < list I i»M » 3 �upon a partial review, supposedly of the merits of the case, with which noasof the Board of Trustees were familiar. The Board of Appeals had assumed that the proper procedure was to turn over matters requiring legal action to the Village Counsel as the only legal counsel provided for under the law, on the assumption that he would take such steps as were needed to enforce the decisions of this Board, but the situation had taken quite a different turn, for the practical effect of the decision of the Board of Trustees in instructing him not to take action in this case was equivalent to assuming the power of review and reversal of the actions of the Board of Appeals. Mr. Gould therefore requested Mr. Sinnott to carefully consider the question of proper procedure for the enforcement of the Zoning Law, not only in the case of "Red Gables", but for all future cases, to confer with the Board of Trustees for the purpose of agreeing upon a proper method of procedure which would lead to adequate enforcement of the law without friction or misunderstanding between the two Boards, and to report back to the Board of Appeals at an early date. Thereafter an informal discussion by the members of the Board ensued, after which Mr. Sinnott promised this Board that he would take up the question with the Board of Trustees and report to this Board at his earliest convenience. On motion of Mr. Schmidt and duly seconded, the meeting was adjourned at 8:30 P. M. �i A* �Extract of Minutes of BOARD OP TRUSTEES Executive Session - Sept. 25, 1931. Corporation Counsel Sinnott stated that he had "been directed by the Zoning Board of Appeals to proceed immediately .with injunction proceedings to restrain the use of "Red Gables" as an apartment house. Mr. Sinnott stated that the case would have to go to the Supreme Court and would result in an expensive lawsuit. Mr. Sinnott stated that all the Zoning Board of Appeals could do was to render an opinion. He stated that the Board of Trustees was the body which should act if any action was to be taken. Moved by Carney and seconded by Mahoney that this matter be left in Counsels hands. �^'V i •:> �V ft V > ^ • A* * * .vv * "* i •* ' t „ " '- < - ' S M C ' " *, . w - - j -J - &',« V C'*''v * �$&iX t ai- <vz&m$m &m$M $j$Jtao$ erf%t l o g u i d e s ? ^Xd^^on a8X*?||®<x ©iff ?*4t#tt#6¥ ,$jAJto»f9 %&bmM£fg no MeiC ©cf XXIw *Xa#f$A l o * :ocf tfase aalqoQ MJJOO , a bXA1©£ ctJblxrrxloa , 0 m&iXXXW noXXxrM , 3 nrioli tjonnta .L rrrfoL � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_ZONING_1932-01-26 Subject The topic of the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1932 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Village of Sleepy Hollow All Rights Reserved. Type The nature or genre of the resource Text https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/9152e6049f67ecd30959c7562f09be99.pdf 777a0f4f64494c5767da7588e9295498 PDF Text Text At a regular meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of North Tarrytown held at the Corporation Rooms in said Village on the 18th day of February, 1932. Present: Gerald B. Gould, Chairman John K. Mullon William C. Schmidt David Page, Jr. John J. Lofaro, Secretary Mr. Gould called the meeting to order at 8:10 P. M. The minutes of the adjourned meeting of January 26, 1932, were read and approved. In connection therewith, Chairman Gould suggested that inasmuch as no report was received from Corporation Counsel regarding the matter of "Red Gables" and the enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance generally, he would write Mr. Sinnott to ascertain from him the results of his conference with the Board of Trustees pursuant to Mr. Sinnottfs promise at the last meeting of the Board. There being no further business to transact, the meeting adjourned at 8:45 P.M. to meet again on April 21st next. �^ �tt W^mmx? 1§» *93t Dear ifis>» SfeftsoUt 1 wa* se&gr $&$ $m **** sat ffflg*§&* at $&* aftfttl&g of tfc* 3e*y& of Xm****9 l#M *«•% fti#*» f * tm& «cp«eted tbat by $&i8& - ffisHi j^nst ti$*I& w i w^Mi 1& ?wpapp% $# mt OIK t l * i «wwwJ» i V^*^^.*1 ^^^ff ^^^PWW* T^PWWP^M-.^J^PP^*^^^** fAMI % ^Wfw. ^ ^ WFTPJP^^^*^^^*™^ T(JWPJ|PPWW^W^*W* • • • p s ^ ' W w *P***P"-i ^ p B ^ w P V ^ p ^ ^ ^ i p P W i ^ * ' ^ P ( r ^W^P> ~^W^wp^^^ »^W ^^^w^^^^-^^pr wpTppj#>»ppp^pwjp^wA •#*?• w w w l * P P w ^ v iiaii^Maanr in. -VMMI& '«fe «eMHaoH^k ^ t t M s atttlJtf &%fi&<Mtirl3F haw «rri«^ *i •(»• mm** vaimUf&lt* i&Vx V* BowrA ^ / will W «l*d *o M i l spwial aw*la« ortt«Beejrt. of App«al» « « f W m m ^ » i»*Hi9ft *o f«ap^#3r dtMttM H«U» «**** with •>ij' vv^-t -::^ . ' ^ ' App««lC .^>. P^^^>^^.^^#..^, • r'' �-!'' w -•• ,-. ...* ;*•• -/: ' * -••*-. ': ••.•^^F:;;' . -. j - ^ : : �1 PLAN INFORMATION BULLETIN N O . 6 Issued by the Regional Plan Association, Inc., 4 0 0 Madison Ave., New York N. Y. FEBRUARY T}pse Bulletins* published from time to time, are intended • rily for tne information of news editors, editorial writers, P ' i fS 0f the Association, and others particularly interested fe i Regional Plan and planning. They permit of the amplifi"*. 0j Regional Plan proposals beyond what is practical in C waver releases; an occasional resume of the history of some " rific development, and a discussion of planning situations, iects and suggestions in which the attitude of the Regional f t officially is reflected. r 15, 1932 BULLETINS ARE RELEASED TO THE PRESS IN ADVANCE of the private distribution made on the date indicated above. They are distinct from news releases and the text or facts contained may be used in any way desired upon receipt. They are numbered serially for convenience in filing and should be valuable as a reference on planning progress. Subscription price one dollar a year. EDifARD McKERNON, Editor. "THE BUILDING OF THE CITY" JL review of Plan Volume II, the recently published concluding number of a series of two Plan volumes and eight Survey volumes presenting the studies, conclusions and proposals of the Regional Plan of New York and Its Environs. By HENRY JAMES It is appropriate that a review or summary account of the second and final report from the Regional Plan should appear in this Bulletin. "The Building of the City" as it is called, which was recently given to the public, concludes the series of ten monumental volumes of fact-finding and recommendation that are among the fruits of more than nine years of work by the Sage Foundation's Regional Plan Committee. It marks the completion of a bold and splendid enterprise. When one examines this book and incidentally glances back at its predecessors one's first conviction is that what has been done amounts to much more than the completion of a mere analysis of the structure of the metropolitan region, with the addition of a series of particular proposals concerning its future. For even if one were to dispute nearly every allegation of fact and were disposed to quarrel with all the recommendations, yet it would remain palpable and undeniable that this has been a work of very large significance and that it is full of encouragement. There are several reasons for this conviction. For one thing, this hae been the first workmanlike attempt to consider at one and the same time the detail and tne totality of the structure of a modern metropolis. The interest of the undertaking is thus more than local. For New York is a sample, and one of the most interesting examples of a class. It is in the metropolitan communities that the great city-ward trend, which is urbanizing western civilization, raises many of its most distressing and perplexing questions. Ihese centers are sure to grow and multiply, for we n <>w have a world economy that pushes more and more people toward the towns, and an engineering science which can make it possible for any one of them to swell to almost limitless size. In the last century the growth of great city centers has proceeded almost without guidance, and right here the greatest of them has spread itself so far beyond the geographical boundaries of any single municipality—spreading in fact over 22 counties and into the territory of three states—that even an initial study of its larger aspects had come to look like a greater task than any single governmental bureau could undertake. What was needed was the initiative and generosity of an agency that did not depend on the taxpayers for its resources. The Sage Foundation, whose funds are dedicated to "the improvement of social and living conditions" recognized that here lay an opportunity to render a great public service. The work thus devotedly undertaken has, even before its completion, stimulated similar efforts in Philadelphia, Los Angeles, Boston, and other cities, not only in North America, but in foreign countries. Another reason for speaking of this as a work of large significance, quite irrespective of any particular findings or recommendations, is that it has supplied for local use such a collection of analyzed and analyzable information about the physical, economic, and social structure of the New ^ o r k Region as was not previously available. To be sure, each borough, or town, or county engineer's office has files full of data about streets, transportation lines, sewers and so on, and there are numerous business and social agencies which have special knowledge that is of general interest. But these things are scattered, usually out of sight, and sometimes concealed from public view. By the efforts of the Regional Plan Committee something like a comprehensive survey of such information has been made and the relations of the parts to each other have been studied and expounded. For the next twenty years nobody, whether in public office or in �1 '—I * fa *i< 11 'EL ",(ffl jnvnii* « *s,, Eric Gugler, Architect FOR THE LOWER TIP OF MANHATTAN An enlarged and redesigned Battery Park, dominated by a central monument, is proposed as part of the Plan. some private station, who rolls up his sleeves and plunges his arms into the detailed work of trying to order and organize the community's welfare will fail to find guidance and instruction in these volumes. Then, too, they present such a record and picture of what exists here that future students of city planning and municipal organization in New York, and elsewhere too, will be able to understand better than they could otherwise what, in approximately the year 1920, was the state of the New York metropolitan region. * * * As long ago as 1914, Mr. Graham Wallas said, "The science of city planning is rapidly developing into the master science of the material conditions of modern life." What he meant by this will be abundantly clear to anyone who scans the present volume and who reflects that the welfare of the community and the well-being of its inhabitants can never escape the influence of physical environment. Such artificial conditions and surroundings as we New Yorkers dwell in are fundamentally unlike any to which the race as a whole has ever had to adapt itself in the past. To this important underlying fact must undoubtedly be attributed no small measure both of our social unrest and of the nervous strain which is frequently felt in our private lives. In short, modern city dwellers are forced more or less consciously to wrestle with prob- lems of adjustment. These may be approached in two ways: We can alter our personal habits and our social structure away from what they have been heretofore; or we can deliberately shape the city environment— which, is after all a man-made artifact—into something that requires of us a less strenuous effort of accommodation. In the end we must to some extent do both— i.e., adapt ourselves to city ways and our form of government to metropolitan requirements, and make the metropolis a more congenial and governable place of abode. The city planners who set to work to relieve America's growing pains fifteen to twenty years ago frequently had in the background of their minds the conception that it was their mission to shape the environment into something congenial to all mans nature. But anyone familiar with their work knows that they usually brought to the task too narrow a training. They were narrowly engineers who thought in terms of highroads, transportation and public utilities; or they were lop-sidedly architects, concerned for a city-beautiful; or they were primarily social reformers and were unprepared to grapple effectively with the physical elements of the case. And, until the Regional Plan Committee's ambitious undertaking was underwritten by the Sage Foundation, nobody, no matter how broad his training and how 8ta^.8' manlike his imagination, was in a position to assemble �Page Cheater B. Price, A STRIKING N E W MUNICIPAL BUILDING PROPOSED FOR N E W YORK'S CIVIC CENTER The old City Hall is shown as the only building remaining in City Hall Park. The present Municipal Building and other features of the Civic Center are shown just beyond the proposed building. Architect Three �Page Four . ililiililiiliiO LAM * a t J . l M A M . t i j l f* * & < • A*AA«»AAt>aL*.i>JLAAiJ i h ^ M t & ^ ^ ^ ^ r ^ FranctH S. Swales, Architect DEVELOPMENT OF WATERFRONTS IS AN OUTSTANDING FEATURE OF T H E PLAN Above is a suKKcstion freight yardB on the warehouses, office together for utilizinpr the air rights over the 60th Street West Side of Manhattan. A railroad tcrminnl, and residence buildings would be included, with a beautiful waterfront drive. the data of all sorts that are essential to city planning in a great metropolis. Even the staff of the Regional Plan Committee, with its diversified personnel, has had to learn as its long labors advanced. Accordingly it is not surprising that the last chapter of these labors, as presented in this volume, turns out to be in good part reflective and philosophical. The book does indeed present a certain number of specific proposals that round out other proposals made in the preceding volume. But the first half of it is taken up with a discussion of what are really questions of principle, method, and procedure. The best way to convey a fair impression briefly will be to mention a few of the questions which are discussed in this part of the book. Centralization versus Decentralization, with some reference to the cityward trend and the back-to-thefarm agitation. There are slum-spots in small towns as well as in London and New York, and worse sanitary conditions on farms than in the city. On the other hand there are admirable, almost ideal, neighborhoods in large cities as well as in small communities. The city planner can not alter personal tastes, nor divert the great economic forces which drive men to and fro between farms and factory towns. The conclusion is that it is academic for him to dwell on tastes and trends. What he can do is to provide a suitable balance of physical elements in every community, whether large or small. Houses and Neighborhoods. The reader will probably find himself reflecting, after examining this phase of the discussion, that badly planned neighborhoods are even more to blame for the slum than are bad tenement houses. To be sure, plumbing, light and ventilation must be provided for the inside of the building, but there are slum areas which have taken over whole blocks of houses that were first built for the well to do, and New York City's Lower East Side today illustrates the impossibility of improving the quality of a run-down district except by planning and providing breathing spaces, recreation grounds, and other facilities that cannot be covered by the tenement house law. Fitting Streets to B u i l d i n g s . N o end of thought has been devoted by both town planners and real estate men to what might be called doctrine about adapting buildings to frontage on different kinds of streets; but I believe that this is the first city planning report to contain anything like a good discussion of the converse problem of adapting the street system to a building pattern that has already become strongly established. In the heavily built portions of a city like New York it is really from this side that the planner must approach the problem of circulation. T e r m i n a l Facilities. Greater coordination of the various elements in the distributing systems for freight and passengers is seen as the biggest need in solving New York's terminal problems. For freight,—large terminal warehouses at the railroads, store door delivery, improved ferry services, union inland terminals and greater use of container systems are recommended. Stress is laid, throughout the discussion of these problems, on making the maximum use of existing facilities, which should be supplemented,—rather than superseded, by new improvements. Skyscrapers. It turns out that the authors of the Regional Plan hold no brief against the skyscraper as such. They do point out the serious and perhaps disastrous consequences of crowding together too many skyscrapers of the present prevailing types, and resolve the question into that of controlling or guiding the relation between building bulks and a suitably balancing quantum of street space and open space. At this moment of acute depression in the real estate world what the volume says on this subject ought to be particularly interesting to architects and investors. Zoning. Since New York adopted the first American zoning ordinance during the World War, experience has taught us much. As to this subject "The Building of the City" brings us up to date. Double-deck Streets and Sidewalks. It appears that the Regional Plan prefers cheaper and less fever- �Page Five Drawinti by A. J. Frappicr II. Craiti Severance, Inc., Architect. Rendering hu Huuh L. Fcrristt Drawing bu A. J. Frappier HOW T H E LIMITATION ON BUILDING BULK IN CENTRAL AREAS PROPOSED BY T H E REGIONAL PLAN COMPARES WITH P R E S E N T STANDARDS In the center is shown one ol' the finest examples of present-day skyscraper architecture—the Bank of Manhattan Building on Wall Street. The part ol' the building below the tower is built up to the maximum b.ilk permitted by the present zoning ordinances. The Regional Plan proposals would permit buildings of this size or even a little larger, in central areas, but they would require a much greater uiTii of plot. At the left is a drawing of a building having the greatest bulk which would be permitted on a plot the same size as that of the Bank of Manhattan, and on the right is a drawing of a building of the same height and approximately the same bulk as the Bank of Manhattan, but on a plot nearly twice as large, which would be required for this bulk under the proposals of the Regional Plan. ish, although less spectacular, remedies for street congestion. It does not believe that New York requires either double-deck streets or double-deck sidewalks in any but a very few spots. But it does urge that there are many at which traffic crossings ought to be arranged on separate grades. Civic Art. Here we find a better discussion of the extent to which aesthetic considerations may reasonably count in the planning of a city than has, so far as I know, been presented in any such report. Capital Cities and Others. There is an interesting chapter which points out the difference between the planning procedure and the objectives that suit a city like New York, and those that can be pursued in a capital city like Washington, Paris, or Berlin. Relations of the Center and the Suburb. It has been said that there are two places in which a great c % changes its physical form rapidly and in which l here is accordingly the best opportunity to plan or to replan. These two are the very center and the outer fringe. The importance of the outer fringe from the planner's point of view is rightly emphasized. This list is by no means exhaustive, but is enough to be suggestive. The discussion of all these questions makes it clear that the Regional Plan Committee not only recognizes that it is impossible, in a democracy, to impose a plan as Napoleon III and Haussmann imposed their plans on Paris, but believes whole-heartedly that a city is altogether a vital organization and that its growth will be healthiest if it is guided by educational processes and by submitting to popular discussion such plans as they themselves have been making for New York. The /happiest community will in the end be the one which fits its shell to popular requirements and which continually reshapes it to express the aspirations of its inhabitants. "The greatest opportunity and most urgent need in any urban community in a democracy is that of �A BIRD'S-EYE V| (a) The Tri-Borough Bridge, to connect Queens with! nection between the bridge and Manhattan at 110th strel River between 108th and 109th streets; (d) the utilizj the existing Hell Gate! educating and organizing public opinion toward an intelligent understanding of what is 'well-building' and of t h e need of foresight in planning t h e city to achieve it. W h e n building is guided in h a r m o n y with t r u e objectives and a well conceived city plan, concrete opportunities will present themselves for securing dignity and beauty coincident with true economy. * * * O u r visions are visions of h o p e and not of prophecy as to what t h e future holds. Change will still be governed by t h e uneven t e m p e r and intelligence of t h e average m a n and woman. W h a t they desire strongly will come to pass." T h e second p a r t of t h e volume explains a n u m b e r of m o r e or less definitely worked out and graphically illustrated proposals. These are to be regarded both as illustrating principles and policies t h a t have previously been discussed, and as practicable solutions of significant problems in t h e future development of t h e New York Region. T h e y supplement a n d are harmonious with other definite projects which h a d been explained in t h e preceding volume, " T h e Graphic Regional P l a n . " A full list of these proposals will b e found to touch all parts of t h e Region. Not only t h e outer environs in New Jersey and Long Island and t h e Jersey shores t h a t are touched by t h e tide-waters of New York Bay, b u t t h e five boroughs of Ne\| City are considered. To e n u m e r a t e all these proposals, or to st^ arguments for any one of t h e m fully would possible i n t h e space h e r e available. But a fa tures from t h e v o l u m e u n d e r consideration arel duced herewith, a n d a few of t h e more im( projects should b e m e n t i o n e d . T h e r e is a c h a p t e r o n the future of Central! a subject over w h i c h t h e r e h a s been and willj b e bitter wrangles. T h e r e is a n o t h e r chapter & t h e possible t r e a t m e n t of the Harlem River T h e comparative simplicity of t h i s project an magnificent results t h a t m i g h t b e realized by c it out are quite inspiring to consider. The for t h e enlargement and improvement of Batten has, like t h e H a r l e m River project, already bed cussed in t h e p u b l i c press. I t is impressively prel in this volume. I T h e great possibilities of t h e Hackensack i«(j have similarly b e e n discussed i n t h e public pre8| were dealt with in t h e preceding voluine lr0,l special point of view of t h e transportation «| ments. T h e Regional P l a n Committee's pr°A which closely resemble those t h a t are now be«1 forward by p u b l i c authorities i n New Jersey summed u p . �Page Seven "''i>S^!5 "igfcwffia r EV«AND V I C I N I T Y \sf. (now under construction) ; (b) an additional coni strip extending from Central Park to the East ndalls Islands for park purposes. In the background, IConnecting Railroad. are also proposals for Jamaica Bay and for jaterfronts on both sides of Manhattan Island, JLong Island shores of the city, and on Staten and sketches suggestive of what might be acihed toward the creation of useful and dignified 'titers for communities of different sizes are y plans for such centers as City Hall Park in tan and others in Brooklyn, in Queens, in .Paterson, N. J., Ossining, N. Y., Islip, L. I., where. e whole these projects impress the reader mines them one by one by their practicality ir worthwhileness. Graham Wallas, who has been quoted, said, "When one looks at the 1 drawings which have been lately prepared 'y of citizens for a new Chicago [he was writ^14], one feels that they are suited to giants nien, or at least only to the gigantic qualities *Htd. It is a good thing that every citizen's would be occasionally stirred by seeing the * a tall municipal office against the skyline, or tog beneath the enormous dome of a museum. parks, which the inhabitants of ten quarters !K i n A, t w enty minutes walk, are better than ten times as large which few can reach withF g a day's work; and if a working man's wife is to buy the family supplies in comfort, shopping streets must be neither too distant for her feet nor too broad for her eyes." It is in this less spectacular and more practical spirit that the Regional Plan Committee has worked. It has evidently thought of the working man's wife. The cost of executing all of the projects proposed would run into enormous figures, but it must be realized that not even the most ardent enthusiast connected with the Regional Plan Committee has ever dreamt that all these projects will be carried out; nor is it proposed that they should all be regarded as immediately executable. The work of the Committee looks many years ahead. During that time—this can never be too often emphasized in connection with these discussions—a great part of the physical structure of the city will be torn down or torn up and rebuilt anyhow. Enormous sums will certainly be spent in the process. The point is that the community will spend what it is going to spend to better purposes if plans are available for study and discussion which have been, made with reference to the larger aspects of the Region's welfare and are also more or less definitely suggestive as to its parts. The report tells us that "as the work has gone on �/'<igc Eight Committee of Architects, Harvey W. Corbctt, Chairman A VERY LIMITED USE OF ELEVATED SIDEWALKS ARCADED WITHIN T H E BUILDINGS. AS ILLUSTRATED ABOVE. IS PROPOSED IN T H E REGIONAL PLAN the aim has become more clearly defined as an attempt to show what is desirable from a social point of view, within the limits of what is ultimately practicable from architectural, engineering and financial points of view. Although our proposals involve difficulties in respect to cost and method of execution, all of them are capable of being carried out in a substantial degree by a gradual process. They do not come within the category of fantastic projects to which we allude elsewhere, and which are described by others as constituting 'impossible turreted Babylons'. The proposals may be called visionary, however, in the sense that applies to all suggestions that are made by a body which has no statutory power to carry them into effect . . . They permit of substantial modification without loss of their real value, which is to guide Photo by Brown Bros. WHERE ELEVATED SIDEWALKS ARE NEEDED AND EXISTING BUILDINGS PROBABLY MAKE ARCADING IMPRACTICABLE. AS IN TIMES SQUARE. THIS TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION MIGHT HAVE TO BE USED. �Page PLAN LOWER SECTION OF HARLEM PROPOSED New Street Areas BY THE OF RIVER VALLEY REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN HEIUC Existing Street Area included in New Street System public opinion and both public and private action toward more order and economy in the building of the citv " * * * But at this point it becomes necessary to distinguish sharply between the recommendations which the Regional Plan Committee makes or adopts, and other projects which it courteously discusses. I can not help thinking that the Committee has given more space to the courteous discussion of impracticable ideas—or ideas addressed wholly "to the gigantic qualities of mankind"—than is, from its own point of view, politic. For one who picks up this large volume and turns its pages over casually, without stopping to read carefully, is in danger of being misled into the impression that divers schemes, some of which are very strikingly presented by architectural drawings, represent the Regional Plan. Multiple-deck streets have been rather a pet theme for "prophecies" by architects and others whose imaginations show a certain cousinship with the imaginations of Jules Verne and H. G. Wells. Such fanciful studies sometimes have a moderate suggestive value and are usually entertaining to consider; but the Regional Plan Committee does not itself propose journeys to the moon. In its report two-level treatment i 8 suggested in a few specific instances where topography is favorable or where there is no other w »y of overcoming intolerable congestion. * * * 1 nomas Adams, the author of the volume under review, has been the Regional Plan Committee's titular Director of Plans and Surveys and has been in lac t the guiding spirit in its work. His personal 'laities color it so strongly that it is impossible to dose without speaking of him. If his tolerant and iVme Proposed Parks :m Drawing by A. J. NOT HEIGHT—BUT BULK IS ATTACKED IN T H E P L A N ' S ZONING STANDARDS Frappier REGIONAL An example of the old box-type building on Fourth Avenue, Manhattan, erected prior to the enactment of the present "set-back" zoning laws. To provide adequate light, air, and street and transit facilities, the Regional Plan would go beyond the present laws. A conception of a building occupying the same plot as the old "box" building, but complying with the proposed standards is shown at the left. Although it is 22 stories higher than the present building, it has -10% less bulk. However, the Regional Plan points out, it would have a much greater total rental value because of the better access of all rooms to light and air. �Arthur C. Holden & Associates, Architects A RAILROAD TERMINAL FOR QUEENS Design for a combined terminal and office building, together with other development of the air rights above Sunnyside Yards. scrupulous fairness to others and to their proposals has been carried almost to the point of endangering the clear view of his own convictions and the ideas of his staff, it is doubtless also the case that his modesty and generosity have contributed largely to the success of a long labor that had to be collaborative and cooperative. It is also easy to see that Mr. Adams is no Baron Haussmann; he not only accepts the fact that he has no power to put designs into effect by executive fiat, but honestly believes that the best community plans are those which become operative in response to public demand and as a result of intelligent discussion and unselfish public leadership. His chief insistence is that public discussion must proceed upon a basis of adequate information and well studied projects, and that it must be guided intelligently. Thus the task of the Regional Plan Committee under his leadership has been that of preparing the information and proposals that are needed tor discussion. Mr. Adams' qualification for this work arises not simply from his openness of mind and wide previous experience of community planning on both sides of the Atlantic, but, and perhaps this is what �-Ji Page Eleven DESIGN FOR A PORTION OF T H E PARK BEING DEVELOPED AT GREAT KILLS, STATEN ISLAND matters most, from a certain statesmanlike quality of his intelligence. To be statesmanlike a man must possess both imagination and an ability to appraise the relative values of entirely different types of fact and argument. His thinking must not be committed to a moral groove, or a financial groove, or a groove of any single realm of consideration. Among these and many others he has the ability to make common sense choices and to effect reconciliations. Although he can not be a specialist in this or that field, he can understand and direct specialists. But he is not an opportunist, for he seeks orderly arrangements and sound policies. In so far as the Plan possesses balance and comprehensiveness, it owes almost everything to its Director of Plans and Surveys. Wherever its good influence is felt, now or hereafter, recognition will be, in great measure, an acknowledgement of what is due to the statesmanlike vision of Mr. Adams. A CONCEPTION FOR T H E CIVIC CENTER OF NEWARK �V. ! <P DESIGN FOR THE ENTRANCE TO THE PROPOSED BUSINESS CENTER IN THE HACKENSACK MEADOWS DEVELOPMENT This would be located at the head of a proposed straightening of the Hackensack River. m fo'Vl' !>' 1 t'i • if.! Ml A CONCEPTION FOR T H E DEVELOPMENT OF PATERSON'S CIVIC CENTER (III �MONTHLY REPORT OF BUILDING INSPECTOR FOR ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y. permits grantedpermits denied— ^ ^ Jan 26th 6 none 1Q, 2 f as . & includeing 1Q<z2 follows f o r W rd l i c a t i o n of - J -?. s e P? 1 - R i . z z l ^ ..5^.L.?°..^ » n ^ „ li o^coa t*e^d aoft E a s t s i d e V a- l l e y S t , about 150 f t -S. of Building Permit g r a n t e d - d w l M i T on----£$?L 26thj. A p p l i c a t i o n of Mr..Bo.ya C h e s-t n u t S t . 1 9 3 ? - - P e r m i t No-39.2 ^emolshing o l d Ward Building l o c a t e d a t 3vo^mj.^M..J)evej3ter_StA Permit granted-TJHirtns'ti on~~?fe£—?&* 193?- A p p l i c a t i o n of .-SM..PQllpcX.and.wife Building l o c a t e d a t ..Ma.ple„.st., _ Permit No Addition. p.lA..Haye.s..feP]A8©.-. Permit g r a n t ed-«ifcyirreTr on.-Eeb.Ath _ No_27.t 193£--~Permit No«323_t. A p p l i c a t i o n of -JI~JRaniola Blo_e&__ajidlkl.Q_n. Building l o c a t e d a t ----42--Clintje.n.--Sfc.* Permit granted-d-en-retf- on...F&fc>...9tlL, A p p l i c a t i o n of John.-Gancr.Q., 193& Permit No--3SA«. &tQr.e._.j£r.Q.ni.,_„ Building located at .-9.4..JfeeJanaJX.AY3.* Permit granted-^etrL-eth on-JBfefe.IZth., 193-?- Application of -Aram.-.Cliillnslr.iam jaefc&;L.ga.rage.., Building Located at -i3e.ekman..ATEe—ajn<l.C.lliit.an...St., Permit granted-*e-»i-e«i- on....-F-e£_-2.6tkr Permit No-355. .GDhn..J?rjape.rt^ 1932 Permit No--356-* �Application of Building located at - :——. Permit granted-denied on Application of -- --..-- - Building located at - - - - — —- Building located at - Building located at - - —- —- — — - Building located at Permit granted-denied on , -- ........193- — - - Permit granted-denied on- - Application of —- 193--' Permit No - —- - - Permit granted-denied on - - - Application of - - - Permit No- - -193- -Permit No - Permit granted-denied on - - - —- 193 - -- Building located at Application of - - - Permit granted-denied on Application of - -- —- ------ Permit No. - -. 193-——-Permit No r;——:- - - --- w - 1 9 3 — — Permit No- ^S Dated: North Tarrytown , N. Y . , J ^ . ^ _ ^ . ^^6^L „-193^ ^ ^ ^ ^ Building I n s p e c t o r of the r i l l a g e of North T a r r y t o w n , N.? Y �^ R E G I O N A L PLAN INFORMATION BULLETIN NO. 7 Issued by the Regional Plan Association, Inc., 4 0 0 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. ^"~ • M A R C H 2 8 , 1 9 3 2 rt osc Bulletins, published from time to time, are intended arily for tne information of news editors, editorial writers, Vrl i?l,ys 0f the Association, and others particularly interested •" the Regional Plan and planning. They permit of the amplifi" lion of Regional Plan proposals beyond what is practical in C Miutper releases; an occasional resume of the history of some and a discussion of planning situations, ecifir development, in which the attitude of the Regional TOjec:s and suggestions plan officially is reflected. • BULLETINS ARE RELEASED TO THE PRESS IN ADVANCE of the private distribution made on the date indicated above. They are distinct from news releases and the text or facts contained may be used in any way desired upon receipt. They are numbered serially for convenience in filing and shotdd be valuable as a reference on planning progress. Subscription price one dollar a year. EDWARD McKERNON, Editor. Present Distribution and Future Growth of Population in the New York Region An Analysis of Trends as Indicated by the Census of 1930—Marked Tendency Toward Decentralization as the Migration Is Predominantly Outward—Adjoining Counties Make Great Cains Compared With the Center—Shift in Highest Density—Population Center of Greater New York. Striking changes in the population map of New York City and the Region during a period of ten years are revealed in the studies of the Regional Plan on the trend of population distribution in Greater New York and the Region as indicated by the United States Census of 1930. These studies, just completed, are presented herewith in the form of comparative maps for 1920 and 1930, diagrams and tables, accompanied by an explanatory text in which some of the influences at work and the significance of the tendencies are pointed out. The outstanding facts and conclusions should prove of great interest not alone to the statistician, the engineer, the architect and the real estate operator, but to every real and potential home owner. In the light of past experience, the present situation and the influencing factors noted, the Regional Plan makes new forecasts of the population of the several boroughs and other counties of the Region in 1940, 1950, 1960 and 1965. The previously estimated total of 21,000,000 is retained. It will be recalled that in 1923 the Regional Plan indicated a probable population of the Region in 1930 which was very closely borne out by the recent census figures. High Spots of the Analysis From the wealth of data afforded by the studies of the engineers, certain findings may be emphasized: The New York Region has the largest population of any urban region in the world, having outstripped a comparable area in the London region by a margin of 1,600,000. Within this area decentralization is occuring more rapidly than had been expected. The tendency of migration is toward the borders of the city and into the suburbs beyond. The point of highest density has shifted from the lower East Side of Manhattan to northeast of Central Park. The center of population of Greater New York is in the Borough of Queens. The Spread of Population The most impressive feature of the growth of population in the Region has been its tendency to spread itself outward. This tendency is readily understood and, it may be added, is most gratifying. If the Regional Survey and Plan has made anything clear, it is that such a trend is desirable. At the same time, the greater the disposition of the population to spread the greater the need for planning. The movement has the effect of leaving slum areas in a condition in which replanning and reconstruction becomes more practical, and simultaneously causing increased demands for more transit facilities in the environs and more subdivision of acreage land. However desirable the spread of population may be in itself, it will not be a permanent benefit if the movement is not preceded by planning of the �Page Two new areas to which it moves. The extensive planning of the Region must be followed by the intensive planning of the counties, the cities, the towns and villages. It is time New York City realized that its financial stability rests on maintaining spacious and well planned residential neighborhoods for persons of means as well as for those in more modest circumstances. However, it has nothing to gain by trying to keep population that can be more healthfully housed elsewhere than in Manhattan except, perhaps, an inflation of land values, which may not in itself be a good thing. It has everything to gain from having planned communities outside its borders—communities that will use Manhattan as a center of much of their social and economic life. The economic basis of the New York Region depends more on the family unity between different communities surrounding New York harbor than on the concentration of wealth, population and industry in one comparatively small unit such as Manhattan Island. Surprising Gains in Rural Counties The spread of population is not strong in the suburbs alone. There is indication of a "back-to-the-land" movement. Whereas the populous county of Hudson increased only 9.8 per cent, the rural counties of Suffolk, Rockland and Putnam, in the ten year period, increased 46.1, 30.8 and 27.2 per cent, respectively. The latter two have moved from the minus to the plus column in an extraordinary way. Nearer in, we have the comparison between the whole of New York City, which increased 23.3 per cent as against increases of 140.3, 73.2, 52.5 and 51.2 per cent, respectively, for Nassau, Bergen, Union and Westchester counties. Decreased Maximum Densities It is shown that the group of districts having populations of from 25,000 to 100,000 per square mile is increasing, compared with the group having less than 25,000 persons per square mile. This is the result of filling in the gaps in partly developed areas, and is all to the good. What is even more encouraging is that the group of districts having over 100,000 persons per square mile, or 156 persons to the acre, has actually decreased in area from 17.6 square miles in 1920 to 12 square miles in 1930. One of the desirable ways to lessen density artificially is to increase public open space, now a little under five per cent of the total area in New York City, to the standard of ten per cent. Area of Highest Density It appears that the area of highest density has moved from the Lower East Side to the district adjacent to the northeast edge of Central Park. The city should attack this remaining area of crowded slums in the same manner as it lessened the density east of City Hall by opening small parks. It should follow the advice of the Regional Plan and cut a park strip through from the upper end of Central Park to the East River, thereby reducing the overcrowding, in- creasing real estate values, and linking Central p a r ^ . Vlt the proposed island parks in the East River. ^ The Hub of the Metropolis It is interesting to note that the center of population " New York City is near to and likely in a few years to b * come actually within area 0n i conic «V.LU»», ,»~ ; the- ~ ~ - suggested --*»—— by -v the «ic Regi R egional le Plan for a central airport for witl " New York City *""combined '" <hvith a civic center for Queens. Why should Queens lose thi1 opportunity to have the focal point of the population of New York City its own civic and most modern transpor tation center? Comparison with London The year 1930 removed all doubts as to whether the NewYork Region had the largest population of any urban region in the world and as to the prevailing tendencies of its growth. New York and London have been running a race for some time in regard to size of population. Actual comparisons are difficult because the areas are different, but if we take New York City and its most densely populated neighbor, the county of Hudson, serving an area which is comparable to the counties of London and Middlesex in which a greater part of the London population resides, we have the following results: Acreage Population New York City and Hudson County.. 218,590 7,621,176 London and Middlesex Counties 223,541 6,036,342 Thus in two areas of about the same size, the population of New York is about 1,600,000 greater than London. This may be thought an unfair comparison for London because it is probably true that the population of the London region spreads itself even more widely in the adjacent counties than is the case in the New York Region. But if we take larger units we get somewhat similar results. In 1839 square miles in the New York Region, the population in 1930 was 10,475,317, whereas in 1846 square miles in the London region, the population in 1931 was 9,101,843. Thus in any form of comparison which ignores the political units and has regard to similarity of area, New York is now well over a million in advance of the London region. ANALYSIS OF 1930 CENSUS Report of Findings in Maps, Diagrams and Tables—Forecasts of Growth The census of 1930 showed a remarkable growth in the population of the Region, considerably greater than that which had occurred in the previous decade both in numbers and in percentage increase. It developed that an additional population of about 2,500,000 had been given to the Region in the preceding ten years. An analysis of the distribution of population has proved even more interesting. Decentralization is taking place not only within New York City but as between the Metropolis and the surround- �Page TABLE I.—1930 Three. POPULATION CENSUS FOR N E W YORK AND ITS ENVIRONS BY GROUPS, AND A COMPARISON WITH REGIONAL PLAN ESTIMATES Population 1930 ^ York C i t y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . jSJyork'and Environs GB Per cent increase 1920-1930 1920 Regional Plan estimate for 1930 Nelson P . Lewis Pearl and Reed 6,930,446 4,527,558 11,458,004 5,620,048 3,359,007 8,979,055 23.3' 34.8 27.6 6,622,000 4,248,000 10,870,000 7,032,000 4,545,000 11,577,000 8,063,513 6,663,726 21.0 7,900,000 8,441,000 2,184,382 1,383,645 57.9 1,860,000 1,990,000 1,210,109 931,684 29.9 1,110,000 1,146,000 °Sew York City Hudson Co., N . J . Newark, N . J . Principal Suburban Areas GROUP 3 • •••-. Balance of Region m" suburban areas at a rate greater than was anticipated in the Regional Plan studies of population published in 1929 in Survey Volume II. As a result, it has been found necessary to revise some of the estimates of future county populations although the estimates for the entire Region have been substantiated by the census figures. Importance of Population Estimates Some definite prediction as to population growth is essential to city or regional planning. The exact date at which any population figure will be reached is of secondary importance. In the Regional Survey four independent population estimates were presented. These led to the conclusion that by the year 1965 the population of the Region might reach a total of 21,000,000. It was stated that the Regional Plan should anticipate such a total and that the date at which it might be reached would have little effect upon the Plan, but would merely dictate the rate at which it should be carried out. Total Population of the Region The total population of the Region in 1930 was 11,458,004. Preliminary figures were published by the Regional Plan in September of that year. Final census figures since that date have resulted in some minor revisions. The figures for New York City, the Environs and the three groups into which the Region was subdivided for purposes of estimates, are given in Table I, which also shows the 1930 figures in the two original estimates upon which the Regional Plan was based. The areas included in each of the three groups are shown in the map in Figure 7. The tremendous increase °f 57.9 per cent in Group 2, which includes the principal suburban areas, as against a growth in the whole Region of 2 7.6 per cent, is an indication of the decentralization from the central part of the Region. In spite of this, New York City increased 23.3 per cent as against an increase of 17.9 Per cent in the decade from 1910 to 1920. Changes in Population Densities A series of population density maps for the years 1850, 1900 and 1920 were published in Survey Volume II. These included maps of both the whole Region showing densities varying from under 200 to over 50,000 persons per square mile, and maps of New York City and contiguous territory showing densities from under 5,000 to over 200,000 persons per square mile. Two 1920 density maps are reproduced herein as Figures 1 and 3 and on opposite pages are corresponding maps based upon the 1930 census. Maps for these two years alone show striking differences, although still greater ones appear by comparison with the earlier maps in the Regional Survey. The densities are based upon net areas obtained after deducting those "open spaces" devoted to parks, municipal watersheds and cemeteries in excess of five per cent of the gross area. This was necessary to get comparable figures, as in many communities large areas are not available for building development due to their being set aside as permanent open spaces in the form of public parks, reservations to protect municipal water supplies, or as cemeteries. In order to have the densities approximately proportional to those on the buildable areas the excess of these open spaces over five per cent was deducted. This is based on the assumption that about five per cent of any area should be set aside as local parks, which should be quite uniformly distributed, although many communities are still far below this standard. Streets are included in the net areas. The areas used in computing densities are in general computed by a planimeter. Tidal waters are excluded and where docks and piers existed the areas are figured to the bulkhead line. In view of the approximate nature of the land areas there was no justification for computing densities beyond three or four digits. Therefore, where densities were 2,000 or more per square mile round figures were given and the calculations were carried out only to the first three digits. �Page Four 1 i is miii m >« FIG. 1 �Page Five NR wYORK AND ENVIRONS ' 5H0WIHG ' , , , l l V E DENSITIES OF POPULATION ACCORDING ACCORDING RU' / U U s. TO TO CENSUS OF 1930 FIG. 2 �Page Six Fig. 3 Densities per square mile Per cent of land area in above map. Square miles Less than 25,000 88.5 560.4 Throughout the Region On the maps for the entire Region (Figures 1 and 2) the areas for which 1920 densities were computed included all incorporated units which had a population of 3,000 or more, but this was not followed strictly as some isolated 25,000 to 100,000 8.7 54.8 100,000 or more 2.8 17.6 communities with smaller populations were computed separately. Densities of unincorporated areas were for the area remaining after the deduction of any incorporated sections for which separate densities were computed. For the 1930 census each political unit was figured separately irrespec- �Page Seven Fig. 4 Densities per square mile Per cent of land area in above map. Square miles tive of its population and the densities for towns in New York and Connecticut are in each case for the unincorporated section of the town. The two maps show the tremendous increases in densities between the ten and thirty •tile circles from New York City Hall. On Long Island Less than 25,000 82.0 518.9 25,000 to 100,000 16.1 101.9 100,000 or more 1.9 12.0 and in Fairfield, Westchester and Rockland counties this growth has extended out to the forty mile circle and in some places beyond. A summary by counties appears in Table IV. The decreases in New York City and the other, central areas are shown much more clearly in Figures 3 and 4. �Page Eight TABLE II.—POPULATIONS AND POPULATION DENSITIES, BY ASSEMBLY DISTRICTS IN N E W YORK CITY, 1920 AND 1930 1930 Area in square miles Assembly District Total area Deduct Open Spaces in excess of 5 % of total area Population p e r s q u a r e d !111| of net e net nr„n area Population Net area 1920 1930 BRONX COUNTY 1.29 3.00 2.76 .82 .87 22.60 .87 9.60 Total. 41.81 "!i8 2.85 5.91 110,315 117,611 83,042 84,195 88,428 70,482 89,123 88,820 101,735 222,084 96,866 86,282 110,560 277,645 113,907 256,179 85,500 39,200 30,100 129,500 101,600 3,550 102,400 12,700 35.9 | 732,016 | 1,265,258 (County density based on total area 20,300 17,500 1.29 2.96 2.76 .64 .87 19.75 .87 6.57 .04 78,900 '5,000 35,100 134,800 127,100 14,060 130,900 39,000 = ~^2Q0 30,300) KINGS COUNTY (BOROUGH OF BROOKLYN) ;l« * 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 in 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 lili It Total. 1.33 21.10 2.12 1.15 .96 .77 1.87 1.06 5.18 1.29 1.50 .18 ,70 ,87 37 50 10 47 85 44 90 03 91 68.65 1.33 20.12 2.12 1.15 .96 .77 1.2 1.06 4.9 1.26 1.5 1.4 1.7 .87 1.37 7.50 1.10 4.47 .85 1.3 2.9 4.9 .91 .98 .67 .28 .03 .'78 .14 .13 2.11 | 86,912 109,104 90,760 82,336 67,808 85,895 77,455 79,658 92,754 75,873 78,062 77,872 83,399 97,344 72,994 97,110 76,186 98,100 83,897 99,357 84,484 122,637 98,359 61,201 300,054 72,644 71,954 64,414 74,474 75,218 63,964 215,477 72,317 89,531 84,367 61,718 71,888 63,006 283,876 73,296 237,870 63,229 92,867 141,109 147,800 78,127 66.54 | 2,018,356 | 2,560,401 (County density based on total area 65,400 5,170 42,800 71,500 70,700 111,500 65,600 75,100 18,500 61,200 52,000 55,200 49,000 111,700 53,700 12,900 69,200 21,900 98,700 76,400 21,000 24,500 108,000 46,000 14,910 34,300 62,600 67,100 96,700 62,700 60,400 44,000 57,400 59,700 60,300 36,300 82,600 46,000 37,900 66,600 53,200 74,400 71,400 48,700 30,200 85,900 29,600 29,400 38,500 37,300) NEW YORK COUNTY (BOROUGH OF MANHATTAN) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 * 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 II Total. 1.89 .69 1.19 .38 .76 .89 137,522 147,115 113,098 94,980 103,166 99,165 85,486 109,522 82,994 79,801 79,314 121,539 76,008 120,879 96,072 108,117 85,663 141,790 78,052 83,156 76,982 74,895 88,789 87,300 86,067 71,408 53,866 67,765 63,915 87,774 70,984 92,819 66,133 78,474 88,122 69,460 81,045 91,299 76,325 71,722 110,063 76,490 67,284 76,205 77,598 155,194 21.93 2,284,103 | 1,867,312 (County density based on total area. Total- 72,700 213,000 95,000 250,000 136,000 111,000 104,000 261,000 163,000 46,300 169,000 113,500 109,000 177,000 81,400 190,000 252,000 143,000 147,000 106,500 135,000 104,000 39,100 46,200 124,700 60,000 141,800 89,200 71,800 111,100 169,000 197,500 38,500 170,600 82,400 108,500 119,200 76,700 133,900 217,300 111,200 141,600 86,300 136,100 104,900 80,400 111,400 104,200 93,100 85.200) •Ward 1.. 'Ward 2.. Ward 3.. Ward 4., Ward 5.. Total. •Net a parks. As fArea {Due tomposed i New Yoi A comj Xew Yor Regional piling u p 1900 the tion not Hudson ated dur and 4 w tricts in in Richr ties are oughs ir The ' esting £ populat square mile grf almost 10'0,00f miles t droppe Inl in the Person �Page — , —-—""" \sscnibly 'District 1930 Area in square miles ' Total area Deduct Open Spaces in excess of 5 % of total area r- o n . . . , - « Population Net area Nine .„:i~ of net area 1920 1930 1920* 1930 Q U E E N S COUNTY 1 ') 3 4 5 6 5.0 9.83 14.95 43.5 28.2t 6.36 107.84 Total. .96 .96 i .si 2.17 5.0 8.87 14.95 42.54 28.2 4.55 78,805 74,441 76,593 83,175 83,228 72,800 151,197 141,625 191,942 297,272 184,293 112,800 15,760 8,380 5,120 1,930 2,940 14,800 105.67 469,042 1,079,129 4,350 10,210 4,350 10,010) (County density based on total area. 30,200 15,970 12,840 6,990 6,540 24,800 R I C H M O N D C O U N T Y (STATEN ISLAND) 1. 2. 3, 4, 5. 5.22 .40 6.45 15.72 12.79 17.02 1.20 .36 Total.... 57.20 1.28 •Ward Ward Ward Ward Ward 4.82 6.45 14.52 12.43 17.02 34,401 21,280 28,720 15,587 16,543 52,782 23,998 31,156 32,961 17,449 7,010 3,300 1,820 1,220 973 10,950 3,720 2,150 2,650 1,025 55.92 116,531 158,346 2,040 2,830 2,040 2,770) (County density based on total area. •Net areas upon which 1920 densities are based are in a few cases different from the 1930 net areas due to recent additions in public narks. As only the present areas are of current interest the earlier ones are not included in the table. fArea remaining after transfer of 0.1 sq. mi. to Lawrence Village in Nassau County in 1928. JDue to the large size of the assembly districts in Richmond, ward areas were used in t h a t borough. Assembly District N o . l is composed of Wards 1 and 2 and Assembly District N o . 2 is composed of Wards 3, 4 and 5. JVew York City and Contiguous Territory A comparison of the density maps for 1850 and 1900 of New York City and contiguous territory, as given in the Regional Survey, shows in a very impressive way the initial piling up of population in the center of the Region. Since 1900 there has been a spreading out of this central population not only in Manhattan but also in Brooklyn and Hudson county. This movement has been greatly accelerated during the last decade, as indicated by Figures 3 and 4 which show population densities by assembly districts in all boroughs of New York City except Richmond; in Richmond and the larger New Jersey communities densities are shown by wards. Detailed figures for the five boroughs in New York City are given in Table II. The figures given beneath the two maps tell an interesting story. The last ten years have seen a shifting of population density from both the less than 25,000 per square mile group and the more than 100,000 per square wile group, to the group with intermediate densities, which almost doubled in area. The areas with densities of over 10O ' jOOO per square mile had increased from 8.3 square wiles to 17.6 square miles between 1900 and 1920 but dropped to 12.0 square miles in 1930. In 1850 the maximum density in New York City was in the Sixth Ward near City Hall, representing 165,000 Persons per square mile. By 1900 a maximum of 400,000 per square mile existed in the Eighth Assembly District on the Lower East Side. By 1920 this same assembly district still had the highest density, but it had dropped to 261,000 per square mile. In 1930 the densest population was found in the 17th Assembly District, at the northeast corner of Central Park, with 217,300 persons per square mile. In Brooklyn the maximum has decreased from 148,800 persons per square mile in the 16th Ward in 1900 to 96,700 per square mile in the Sixth Assembly District in 1930. In Hudson county, New Jersey, the maximum in 1900 was 59,250 per square mile in the Fifth Ward of Jersey City, where it increased to 75,500 in 1920. By 1930 the maximum was found in the Third Ward of Jersey City, with a density of 64,800 per square mile. Manhattan The changes in distribution of population within Manhattan, which lost 18.2 per cent of its population from 1920 to 1930, are shown still more effectively in the dot maps in Figures 5 and 6 than in the density maps. Each dot in these maps represents 100 persons and the decreases on the Lower East Side and northeast of Central Park appear very clearly. It is also obvious that these decreases to a large extent represented reductions in excessive densities and, therefore, are to some extent an improvement over earlier conditions. �30.C 10, Fie. 6 �Page Group 1 v/ New York City Newark City Hudson County Orange ^ /' JJ Groups / Morris Nassau County Westchester County Fairfield County (Part) Bergen County (Part) > 1,170 sq.mi. Passaic County (Part) Essex County (Excluding Newark) Union County fl^'* Urn V Eleven Union J Group 3 T h e Remainder ^^••^M on mouth "5,993 sq.mi. T o t a l Area : 5,5£8 sq.mi. y—i 30,000 30,000 _„. 20,000 — - ' - ' "-" 10,000 N 1 , \& ,«<&^ SsJ%^ \ ^ 5,000 4,000 i-^>i <Hb fCVJ* 2,000 ^-*~ ^ > *"' 1,000 s$ >' 500 <"*r ^- , H _^' " ,» **^ _.,.— — —... "— „_—- """ •»«"*"" --" " > „*- ' ~~~. 310,000 - _^,« • — * . . , yoVv »-«- - * p--—^ - - - - '-"" • „ «• ' „„•*• **"' - »«"*"' ^.**~ 5,000 4,000 ^» *" 3,000 p-"' ^'' sr-*.- .**' 2,000 .*.—" -—-' c*2& „ ** s T-** " i — - - ' **^\ <*<' \^ ^ - H oS ^A ^ V^f ^ ' ' O^ i-c^v%r ^ r~" 3,000 400 ft'6 - |—'-izojooo •.«•"" fir -" - .."5 .1,000 jHi^ ^*' 500 400 300 300 200 200 y ^ 100 100 POPULATION OF NEW YORK 8c ENVIRONS 50 FROM 1850 TO 1930 WITH ESTIMATES TO THE YEAR 1965 40 30 Figures for Different Groups Relate t o Boundaries as Existing in 1930 20 93/ /fe*'/ j e o * / /& 10 1850 I860 1870 1880 1890 1900 1910 FIG. 7 1920 0/7 / 930 1930 us/ 1940 1950 I960 �Page Twelve 1790 1800 10 nm u»n up «M .860 , «*> , iBaO^JggQigOO WO '920 - y o m o j y i960 IQ0O0 uJ h Z O POPULATION OF NEW YO£k CITY PAST £. ESTIMATED GROWTH, BY BOROUGHS, 1790-1965 (BASED O N 1930 QEGIONAL PLAN CF NEW BOUNDARIES) YOPJ£ AND ITS ENVIRONS FIG. 8 Center of Population of New York City Several inquiries have been received by the Regional Plan as to the present center of population of New York City. This spot might be defined as the center of gravity of the resident population, or that point from which the average distance to the home of every person in the city is the minimum. The center has been computed from the 1930 census and its location is indicated by the star in Figure 4. It falls within the Borough of Queens and between Long Island City and Maspeth. The actual point as plotted on the city map lies within Calvary Cemetery, about 1,100 feet south of the intersection of Borden and Greenpoint Avenues and about 2,000 feet from Newtown Creek, which forms the boundary between Queens and Brooklyn. It would fall within the lines of a southerly extension of Moore Street. The center of population, therefore, lies zyA miles from Times Square, almost exactly on the axis of 42nd Street extended, and 4}b miles from the Brooklyn Borough Hall. While its exact location is of no great importance in planning the city, it is of general interest and its movement is indicative of the direction in which the residential development of the city is moving. The forecas were a prepar subdi. Thep and tr of the a rate total some �Page Thirteen ISJO t I860 1870 I860 1B9Q 1900 1910 1920 I9S0 1940 1950 ^--'(960 POPULATION OF ENVIRONS OF NEW YOWZ. PAST a. ESTIMATED GROWTH BY COUNTIES, 1790-1963 REGIONAL 1790 !640 _ I&50 1800 '810 1820 (830 (BASED PLAN 1840 1850 ON 1530 OF NEW I860 1870 YO&K 1880 FIG. Revised Population Estimates The Regional Plan did not attempt to make population forecasts for communities smaller than counties and these were adjusted so as to correspond with the estimates first prepared for the three groups into which the Region was subdivided and to which reference already has been made. The published estimates were based on figures up to 1920 and the 1925 New York State Census established that some of the outlying counties had started to gain population at a rate far beyond their previous rates of growth. While the total figures involved were not great, it was obvious that some revision in the Regional Plan estimates for counties BOUNDARIES) 1890 AND 1900 1910 uJ ITS ENVIRONS 1920 1930 1940 1950 I960 8 9 would be necessary, and the 1930 census made this still more evident. Table I I I gives revised estimates up to the year 1965 for each of the three groups and the counties or parts of counties which are included therein. (This table supersedes Table XV on page 119 of Regional Survey Volume II.) The 1930 figures are also given for comparison. Estimates for the whole Region and the three groups and also for New York City are shown graphically in Figure 7, which, also includes past records back to 1850. (This supersedes Figure 33 on page 89 of Regional Survey Volume II.) The indications are that the suburban areas, or Group 2, will '4 �Page Fourteen TABLE I I I . - P O P U L A T I O N ESTIMATES BY COUNTIES AND GROUPS, 1940, 1950, 1960 AND 1965 (Supersedes Table XV, page 119, Regional Survey, Volume II) Estimated Increa^T 1930-1965 Estimated Population County Census of 1930 1950 1940 1965 1960 Per cent Nu morical GROUP 1 Bronx Kings (Brooklyn) New York (Manhattan).. Queens Richmond 1,265,258 2,560,401 1,867,312 1,079,129 158,346 1,675,000 2,900,000 1,800,000 1,507,000 227,000 1,987,000 3,327,000 1,727,000 1,900,000 335,000 2,346,000 3,790,000 1,706,000 2,423,000 533,000 2,478,000 3,965,000 1,678,000 2,620,000 600,000 Total New York City Hudson Newark (City) 6,930,446 690,730 442,337 8,109,000 735,000 489,000 9,276,000 829,000 568,000 10,798,000 980,000 650,000 11,341,000 1,040,000 686,000 64 51 55 8,063,513 9,333,000 10,673,000 12,428,000 13,067,000 62 Total Group 1 96 55 —ii 143 279 GROUP 2 Nassau Westchester Essex (excluding Newark) Union Passaic (Part) *Fairfield (Part) Bergen (Part) Total Group 2 303,053 520,947 391,176 305,209 256,609 89,877 317,511 453,000 703,000 582,000 425,000 301,000 119,000 483,000 611,000 913,000 798,000 566,000 340,000 146,000 615,000 820,000 1,135,000 1,068,000 740,000 391,000 183,000 770,000 912,000 1,313,000 1,225,000 852,000 432,000 203,000 837,000 201 152 213 179 68 126 164 609,000 792,000 834,000 547,000 175,400 113,100 519,000 2,184,382 3,066,000 3,989,000 5,107,000 5,774,000 164 3,589,500 GROUP 3 Suffolk •Fairfield (Part) •Dutchess (Part) Putnam •Orange (Part) Rockland Bergen (Remainder) Passaic (Remainder) Morris Somerset Middlesex •{••Monmouth (Part) Total Group 3 TOTAL N E W Y O R K REGION 161,055 258,269 20,751 13,744 71,229 59,599 47,466 45,520 110,445 65,132 212,208 144,691 192,000 345,000 21,500 14,500 73,000 63,500 64,000 59,500 126,000 73,000 255,000 177,000 215,000 435,000 22,500 15,000 80,000 68,000 85,000 73,000 142,000 77,500 306,000 198,000 244,000 540,000 24,500 16,000 84,500 74,000 104,000 78,000 169,000 80,000 367,000 222,000 258,000 596,000 25,000 16,500 86,000 76,000 116,000 80,500 174,000 82,000 413,000 236,000 60 131 20 20 21 27 144 77 58 26 95 63 1,210,109 1,464,000 1,717,000 2,003,000 2,159,000 78 11,458,004 13,863,000 16,379,000 19,538,000 21,000,000 83. TOTALS F O R COUNTIES SPLIT BY G R O U P I N G Bergen Passaic •Fairfield (Part) 364,977 302,129 833,513 348,146 547,000 360,500 1,071,000 464,000 700,000 413,000 1,366,000 581,000 874,000 469,000 1,718,000 723,000 953,000 512,500 1,911,000 799,000 161 69 129 130 •All of county not in region. tIncluding estimated population in 3.7 square miles transferred from Monmouth County to Ocean County in 1928. �Page Fifteen TABLE IV.—SUMMARY, BY COUNTIES, OF 1920 AND 1930 POPULATION IN N E W YORK AND ITS ENVIRONS SHOWING DENSITIES AND RATES OF INCREASE County Total area, square miles L , v YORK STATE 1920 Per cent increase in population Population per square mile Population 1930 1920 1930 ' B-°"*'/Brooklyn) Kings , H U , / , Sw York (Manhattan) 41.8 68.7 21.9 107.8* 57.2 732,016 2,018,356 2,284,103 469,042 116,531 1,265,258 2,560,401 1,867,312 1,079,129 158,346 17,510 29,400 104,300 4,350 2,040 30,300 37,300 85,200 10,010 2,770 Total New York City 297.4* 5,620,048 6,930,446 18,890 115.7 273.4* 415.1 241.0 183.0 915.1 446.2 18,502 126,120 65,795 10,802 45,548 110,246 344,436 20,751 303,053 71,229 13,744 59,599 161,055 520,947 2,886.9 6,341,497 235.8 127.4 44.1 308.8 426.7 477.7 198.9 305.1 103.4 Dutchess (part of) rtWrhester I Somerset Union Total New Jersey 1920-1930 70.0 23.5 72.8 26.9 2.0 —18.2 65.1 35.6 130.1 35.9 23,300 17.9 23.3 160 461 159 45 249 120 772 179 1,108 172 57 325 176 1,168 — 7.0 50.3 — 0.5 —26.3 — 2.8 14.7 21.7 12.2 140.3 8.3 27.2 30.8 46.1 51.2 8,080,824 2,200 2,800 17.9 27.4 210,703 652,089 629,154 162,334 102,554 82,694 259,174 47,991 200,157 364,977 833,513 690,730 212,208 144,691 110,445 302,129 65,132 305,209 893 5,120 14,270 526 240 173 1,303 157 1,935 1,548 6,540 15,660 687 339 231 1,519 213 2,950 52.7 27.1 17.1 41.9 11.4 10.7 20.0 23.6 42.8 73.2 27.8 9.8 30.7 41.0 33.6 16.6 35.7 52.5 2,227.9 2,346,850 3,029,034 1,053 1,359 25.9 29.1 413.2 290,708 348,146 704 843 29.1 19.7 5,528.0 8,979,055 11,458,004 1,625 2,073 20.3 27.6 VEW JERSEY Middlesex jMonmouth (part of) 1910-1920 •—• CONNECTICUT Fairfield (part of) TOTAL FOR N E W Y O R K AND E N V I R O N S *1930 areas, after transfer of 0.1 sq. mi. from Queens to Nassau County in 1928. The 1920 densities are based on the previous areas, jlncludes area (3.7 sq. mi.) annexed to Ocean County in 1928, in which the estimated 1930 population was 55. J continue to increase at about the present rate for another ten years, after which a more uniform rate of growth throughout the Region may be expected. face Between The Bronx and Queens Corresponding curves for the five boroughs in New York City are given in Figure 8. The most notable feature on these curves is the great jump in the rate of growth in the Borough of Queens since 1920, undoubtedly largely influenced by the fact that Queens is about to obtain greatly I '^proved rapid transit facilities. Manhattan's loss in population has been more than made up by the rapid growth in tath Queens and The Bronx. It is estimated that by the year I960 these two boroughs will have approximately e qual populations. The spreading of population throughout the city is indicated quite clearly in Figure 10, which shows the changes in the percentage of total city population within each borough from 1790 to date and estimates up to 1965. In 1830 Manhattan reached a maximum of about 83.5 per cent, which had decreased to about 27 per cent in 1930. During the last decade the Borough of Brooklyn has moved into first place and now contains about 37 per cent of the city's population. It is believed that this figure is the maximum and that Brooklyn will begin to decline slightly in its percentage of the city's population. It is indicated that by the year 1965 Manhattan will not have more than 15 per cent of the total population and that The Bronx and Queens will contain 22 and 23 per cent respectively. I II �Page Sixteen POPULATION OF NEW YORK CITY CURVCS S u o W I N G PtRCCNTAGl Or ToT»L F b p U U T I O N IN E l C U &OKOJGM 1 7 9 0 TO 1 9 3 0 • o WITH ESTIMATE.:; TO THE YrA*. I9W — > T i a o r c s for Different borouqhs rclolc r o f c o u n d a r l M at e « l » » i n q In 1930 r t & r . i M R . v 1932 5 / *- in u 3 NA. ! / / '^ 1 o !' 1 ; o -J Nfsv j < 1 o 0 _) 1 \l —Iv ^ \ .*'JP\ ~f~ 2 70 u A f i \ 1 \ ^_ M 1 i « Ce Attns TOTAL 3^2 ?5.l I9.Z :^.i J/1 100.0 rs. I—j_ 0 a to o RtHTiVE L A N D b o e o u G u - °joof QUUNS 6ROOKLYN RICHMOND 6K.ONX MANUATTAN j VI FIG. ; ^-J • ^ >- f-'s L... ^ J =H \. , 1 / ^ s* — • -"^ 10 Counties in the Environs Population curves for the various counties in the environs present a great variety in rates of increase. Separate curves are given for each county and part of county within the environs in Figure 9. On the upper part of this diagram are grouped the nine counties in the State of New Jersey, while on the lower part of the diagram are shown curves for the seven New York State counties and one Connecticut county which fall within the boundaries of the Region. These curves also cover records from 1790 to 1930 and estimates to the year 1965, as tabulated in Table III. In the New Jersey metropolitan area there has been the same shift of population from the central areas to tl rounding communities as has occurred in New Yor^r? As a result, the rates of increase in Hudson Count U the City of Newark in Essex County have decreased \\l same tendencies are carried forward in the populate ^ mates. The race between Bergen and Union counti^ expected to continue, but with Bergen County maintai * the lead acquired during the last ten years. Essex Cou ^ due to the possibilities of growth in its central and west "' sections, is expected to maintain its past rate of increase The striking feature in the population curves for iv New York State counties in the environs is the recev ,.„ • growth in Nassau County, which has been approachin Westchester County in the number of its population. It estimated that during the next 35 years these two countiwill maintain about equal rates of growth and that the will both continue to grow faster than the more clistan counties. Nassau County will probably move ahead of tha part of Fairfield County, Connecticut, within the Regi, during the next ten years. The importance of the environs is indicated by the estimate of a total population increase therein between 193 and 1965 of 5,131,500, or about 113 per cent. This amount to 54 per cent of the estimated total increase within th Region of 9,542,000, or 83 per cent, during the same period Experience has shown the difficulty in making accuraf forecasts for even county areas in a large metropolitan region, such as that with which we are dealing. Undoubt edly there will be some shifts in population growths be tween the various counties which cannot be foreseen fro information now available. The estimates given herein are based on the carrying out of the major improvements included in the Graphic Regional Plan, and such redistribution of population as they will lead to has been taken into consideration in arriving at the present figures. �a$< MONTHLY REPORT OF BUILDING INSPECTOR FOR ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Village of North Tartytown, N. Y. permits g r a n t e d --n-?n~- permits denied prom- .Jfe.lth 1 9 3 _2 as Peller paul A p p l i c a t i o n of jn,. Building l-,o c a t.e d, a t, tO—^F-.-^. 37 -til follows DeVrees Ave,: — ^ _ 193.2.. -Permit No- 397 Mar 7 t h permit -grmrfr&'dr- 193-?- A p p l i c a t i o n of -Ale.x.. feld.rp.n... Building l o c a t e d a t .-8.6...^e.ekmaii.-AYe. Permit granted-jisnLad-on A p p l i c a t i o n of : Majr_._l9th 19 3-?- Permit No~3-9.8 193.2 Permit No-252. P.r..Louis.Berg Building l o c a t e d a t 25.0.Np.rth..Broadway. Permit granted-jiejilejj on~~Mar.26th Application of - Building located at Permit granted-denied on ; 193 Application of Building located at Permit No- Permit grant ed-denied on 193 Permit No- 193 Permit No- Application of Building Located at Permit grant ed-denied on.... - �Application of Building located at „ .. , , , . , ' Permit granted-denied on Application of 193.—.—- ------.—-- : Building located at — ""• - - — - Permit granted-denied on Application of — Building located at "" - ---193 --- •—- - Application of - Building located at .- - -193 -Permit No —— ---—————---- - ------ - 193- < - : —- ~-193 Application of ------ Permit' No------ - Permit granted-denied on Dated: North Tarrytown, N. Y. , Permit NO- .--—: Permit granted-denied on Building located at Permit No - - - Permit granted-denied on ' " :: - ----- Application of --- "" .-—.--— Permit granted-denied on Building located at Permit No- —— - ,-193 Apr--8tii - Permit No- -. 193-2- lding Inspector of the Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_ZONING_1932-02-18 Subject The topic of the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1932 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Village of Sleepy Hollow All Rights Reserved. Type The nature or genre of the resource Text https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/267e61e5bef5d6cb324a1ac2fc1fcd15.pdf 47ed734994dfba0d6d3a5225ad79060a PDF Text Text I At a Regular meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y. held at the Corporation Rooms in said village on the 21st day of April, 1952. Present: Gerald B. Gould, Chairman William C. Schmidt • John K. Mullon David Page, Jr. John J. Lofaro, Secretary Mr. Gould called the meeting to order at 8:35 P.M. The minutes of the regular meeting of February 1932 were read and approved. 18, The Secretary called to the attention of the Board that no reply to Mr. Gould1s letter of February 19th was received either by him or by Mr. Gould from Mr. Sinnott. Mr. Schmidt suggested that the Secretary be instructed to write Mr. Sinnott to turn over all the papers, correspondence and data in connection with "Red Gables" to Mr. Sadofsky, the newly appointed Corporation Counsel. On a motion duly made and seconded, the Secretary was so instructed. Mr. Schmidt further suggested that the Secretary be instructed to send a copy of the letter to Mr. Sinnott to Corporation Counsel Sadofsky and call Mr. Sadofsky*s attention to the open matter on the records of this Board and ask him to be present at the next meeting so that this Board may advise with him regarding a disposition therein. On a motion duly made and seconded, the Secretary was so instructed. The Building Inspector's reports bearing dates February 29th and April 8th respectively, were read and placed on file. There being no further business to transact, the meeting adjourned at 8:45 P.M. to meet again on May 19th, 1932. Chairman �* >t[ ' l > I, I I • >> f jl <l !' , !'' i! ill I I If �1X ' Si » v* K - x ' ' > » » > < 1{ fl J> �«\0' •<.-J:..-.i-.v> J^.J, w< -v y„ ^*S--J ,.... v ;.,,,,, 'X.'.'. •->-< ?••.-, - • - - , p ~ * ; •• ; l •<'?•: v » •"^ii>.y,n:..v.:Oi: ;.! •} V . i1 V i i 11 • •" I V .'. ' T •• ~v '•'••••'i .ar?*j£ 3V^-W. i �V „{ I 4 • > I IJH** 1 10 ^ l U j t f * W/*»***» ^aMS^T*?** -^ .»• "* V \ '•V I «mtt ; ,«i / ; ^ \ ; ^ < t l y* . A - / ^ , -* '" M / ; ^>; * '. 11 * •" �*Y «% i.uzo.':<Ai&2 ctf'&V. 1*c.> ^ . U I V S5.QI ^ i..f.^qA - J - ; ^ Saws wo ka&$$& tio^ Hmi$ :^ea off- , t M a o $ . .&M$-*i0^ &ti$ tij ^ o n s ' ^ j t s i ^ i : V 31.-..W&' \;j:.v*::^ori3 tea era^s . $«.tox<»0flOo aoidiftoq �MONTHLY REPORT OF BUILDING INSPECTOR FOR ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y. permits g r a n t e d permits denied — none - 2 Prom...April..I?, to-'.Apr.iIu..aZ 193 as A p p l i c a t i o n of James F r i e r e 193-2 follows - - - Building l o c a t e d a t ....5.6 .Howard. St.. A4&iti.oja..and...altejcat.ions Permit granted-nfreTTreiJ- on.~AP£il .I&th A p p l i c a t i o n of Clemens _:Mart one.. 1932 . p e r m i t No-AO.0.*. Garage . Building l o c a t e d a t -.3S..5.Unten..st. 1 Permit granted-ffffffrffff on.-AK_il_.I9tti 1932 p e r m i t NoAQI....... 193a Permit NoAQ2. A p p l i c a t i o n of - F . i l l i a m . J o u n c e . . . & l t e r a ^ i o Building l o c a t e d a t .$©.¥.__ BroiaM^^^^ Permit granted-tferriire'a- o n - A p r l l . . I 9 t h Application of -Andr.ew._D.ownie„_£r_*. alte.ra.ti.ojas...and..5tdditjLQii. Building located at ..-HoJ.laJi6L.JV3r.e.,...We-b]Dej?..JBarJL* Permit granted-Mftft* on..Aprll.-27-th.,.Application of . 193~2.-Permit NO-4Q3-. '...' Building located at - Permit granted-denied on—Application of ?._. 193 Permit No 193 Permit No - Building Located at Permit grant ed-denied on.... �0\l Application of - —- Building located at — - —- -——-:-— Permit granted-denied on Application of '...•-.:—•..•:.-,— 19 -- .„.•...„.„„„-..,..•.—.;....,...,..— Building located at - - 3 Permit No- — — Permit grant ed-denied on —- —- -193 Permit No ^o^k V Application of ——- — - ——— Building located at — - Permit granted-denied on— - -—-. —- - — - - —193 — Permit No- ^^^ O &- -_-—..——— — Permit granted-denied onApplication Of — Permit No —- ----- - Building located at 193 — Permit granted-denied on Application of - — Application of Building located at —- ,—r -----: Building located at — - - - - - Permit granted-denied on—-— —193— <y*^\ ^ Permit No —-r::--;----:————-- -'-— 193 —Permit tto- Dated: North Tarrytown, N. Y. ,--4pril..2?M* ias_2. Building Inspector of the Village of North Tarrytown,, N. Y �*\db. �•HHH9T RFF: I*" Application of —Building located at Pi *y A' BPA; ^ B' P A B • i P A B P \ i? ' �w V&CVxA. ^O ^*.vo V< &, ^ 2 ^ ^\r^\<™-X'^ �f- . * • Application of Building located at P. •V <K A; ^ Bp A Jo B P A B F A B I Wo P A i A i 5L E F �^ O M *% t ^2-0.' <\\ d© >^Q_ ^*>-*u^V*«^^-<U)GU^S^ tWacfcS \As^KXSb j ^-\-. ^ *S. "4 A »^ r^r^-^A-^-i^SLci^ vw{. �Application of Building located at P. *y A* A; B' p A B P" A B P A B .. ? F A E F \*V �^ ^ ^ B L J Y - ^ ^ ^ OVA *&-** �, V $K Application of Building located at Pi NV A; B1 oVl V F A ^ • ^ B P A B P A B F 1 1!H A E F ^^JUL �Vj^oov . v S ; \ ^ ^ o ^ ^ \ioA-»3^ V �A Application of Building located at Pi A ** B P A b-O ^ B F / (XwCdu I ] ,i « ^ H't j . c �/» V^-a^A \% "3&c_ 037 ^>- N • s. y\<\-$ * - , ir^V'^^y ^jfcz*Jt ,< n r X ^ �<V * • Application of Building located at F v>V A E P A B. P A. E ^rua. F A • • * • - . E E <3—*-£$ �\»V ^-^-A. *8, \Vi2_ va J ° ^\, ^S-JB~J^SI \A"JBVXJ^ sJfcrO-eKJ ��Si ; � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_ZONING_1932-04-21 Subject The topic of the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1932 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Village of Sleepy Hollow All Rights Reserved. Type The nature or genre of the resource Text https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/22e7a4b73d0d431b3e4b70d3da5b1931.pdf 730d784cd213dd3686e896a5a1eea83c PDF Text Text At a regular meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of North Tarrytown, held at the Corporation Rooms of said Village on the 19th day of May, 1932. Present: Gerald B. Gould, Chairman William C. Schmidt John K. Mull on David Page, Jr. John J. Lofaro, Secretary Abraham N. Saflofsky, Corporation Counsel Mr. Gould called the meeting to order at 8:15 P.M. The minutes of the regular meeting of April 21st, 1932, were read and approved. The Building Inspector's report hearing date April 29th, 1932 was read and placed on:file. Letters of complaint from Victoria Cushman, John Iurato, Joseph Kuzvar, P. M. Plorer, Mrs. A. Canter, and Louis R. Bartolizzi and petition of Lucy Mae London, Mary S. Mann, John Zinka, Andrew Lacskey and Pietro Badalamente, all of which were dated May 18th, 1932, were read. Mr. Raymond D. MacMahon, Attorney for the above named complainants, appeared before the Board and stated that the live poultry market at 102 Cortlandt Street is a public health menace for the reason that of it's very nature, it is disturbing at night, malodorous, unsightly and a haven for rats, mice and flies and that the block in which the market is located is a very crowded one. He said that if chicken markets are a necessity, then some sequestered locality should be chosen. On motion of Mr. Page and duly seconded by Mr. Mullon, it was resolved that a public hearing be held on Tuesday, May 31st, 1932, at 8 o'clock (Daylfcght Savings Time) and that the usual notices be mailed to the owner of the premises and to the owners of the live poultry market. The Secretary was also instructed to obtain the Building Inspector's �\v <:','»« �report of the said premises on which the alleged violation exists. An informal discussion regarding "Red Gables" was held. Mr. Sadofsky informed the Board that no cause of action now exists in favor of the Village eithertoyway of Injunction or action on a Penalty toy reason of the fact that the said actions are barred by the terms of the Statute of Limitations. Mr. Gould suggested to Mr. Sadofsky that he submit to the Board a written memorandum or opinion to that effect so that the Board may act on same and close the case on the record. On motion duly made and seconded, the meeting adjourned at 9 O'clock to meet again on Tuesday, May 31st, 1932, Chairman �\V i i h'i< ; i , 11, �i NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ON COMPLAINTS alleging VIOLATION OF ZONING ORDINANCE TAKE NOTICE that a public hearing will be held by the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y., at the Viilage Hall, 28 Beekman Avenue, on the 31st day . of May, 1932, at 8 o'clock P. M. (Daylight Saving Time) on the complaints of Victoria Cushman, John lurato, Joseph Kuzvar, P. M. Florer, Mrs. A. Canter, Louis R. Bartolizzi, Lucy Mae London, Mary S. Mann, John Zinka, Andrew Lacskey and Pietro Badalamente, alleging that a certain Live Poultry Business located in premises known as and by the No. 102 Cortlandt Street, North Tarrytown, N. Y., and which business is conducted by Jerry Scarano and Salvatore Lasco, co-partners, is noxious, offensive And a menace to the public health and in violation of the provisions of Section 5, Business District Uses, Paragraph B of the Zoning Ordinance of the Village of North Tarrytown, N, Y„ and to hear and decide the question as to wherein such violation exists, and if so, to determine the proper action to be taken therein. ! i •[ £ [ | i j j Dated, North Tarrytown, N. Y., May 21,1932. \ JOHN J. LOFARO, Secretary. Zoning Board of Appeals, j �Zoning B o a r d Calls Hearing Poultry Market To Be Discussed May 31 | The North Tatrytown" Zoning ! Board of Appeals -will hold a public I hearing-May 31 on the question of whether a live poultry m a r k e t shall 1 ' be permitted to operate in t h e former ! Leitner building a t • 102 Oortlandt I ' Street. ' Salvatore Lasco of 51 P a r k Hill i Yorikers, said to he the owner of i;he market, h a s been notified to appear' a t t h e hearing. It'isjbhe contention of the Zoning Board of Appeals, t h a t Lasco opened the m a r k e t without ofeT&himg a permit,' The board h a s received two complaints against t h e place. Tender*the pravision'of the Zoning j Law, a n y ^business that! !£» noxious or offensive and a menace to health ! can be 1 restrained by the l&w-.* The Zoning Board h a s cthe r i g h t 'to j r c t to abate a nuisance- t h a t •may'btej caused by s,uch a ^business or^permit it under certain restriction^-^ ^ ' • ;. Persons residing Immediately * ad-' Joining, contend, according ,to the -zonifcg officials, t h a t tltie business -will be a nuiBance'to them. t :,. - •- • '• • . . . r k „..,.-, '• M,, „••, .V; ,'i Tel. 1734 Terrytown JEWRY'S Up-to-date Live Poultry Market Wholesale ' and B^fitaH ' v j Ail Poultry c Killed and Dressed j Free While You Walt i Scarano & Losco, props. 103 Cortlandt Street J NORTH TARRYTOWN. N . Y. " t*•'' W W * . * m m * iimig>fJWWMJ I^II• i • g•i%• •www i •• w w ^ y jq-M— J �S&y 2Xst, 1932 Salvatore Laeco, Esq. 51 Bark Hill Avenue Yonksrs* 3l«w Yofk Bo: Live Poultry Hartal at 102 CortXandt Street Horth farrytora, H*Y, Pear Sir; Please take notice that a public hearing willhe held by the Soiling Board of Appeals of the Tillage of Horth ffcrrytown, tf.Y. at the Tillage Hall, 28 Beetaan Avenue, on the 31et day of May, 1932, at 8 o'clock p*&. fBeyXlght Savings flaw) on the Complaints of Victoria Cuehman ®d others alleging that a certain l i v e poultry business located in premises known as and by the number 102 Cortlandt Street, and which business i s conducted by you end Jerry Scarano, eo-partnera, i s noxious^ offensive and a menace to the public JnKfc health and in violation of the provisions of Sect Son 6- Business District Uses, paragaph B- of the Zoning Ordinance of the Tillage of Horth Tarrytown, H.Y»; and to hear and decide the question as to wherein such violat Ion e x i s t s , and i f so, to determine the proper action to be taken therein* Very tnnly yours, John J* Lofaro Secretary of the Zoning Board of Appeals, i �5 i, •' • ) r ' I i' I • i < i I t ,;! 1 i ^ W ^ i ^ " ••«.*« i."-.'i..V<;*i-*%^-% �* V" A? (IT i&y 31st, 1932 Jerry Searano, Sect* 102 cortiandt street Sorth farrytown, 31 •T* He: X»lve, Poultry Karket at 108 Oortlan&t Street Berth farrytown, !f.1T# Pear Sir: Please take ootid* that a public hearing will be held by the Zoning Board of appeals of the Village of Forth farrytown* H.Y* at the Tillage Hall, 88 Beeknan Avenue* on the 31st day of Hay, 1932, at 8 o'clock P.M. (Daylight Savings SPifce) on the Complaints of Victoria Cashaast: end others allefiiig that a certain l i v e poultry bulniness located in , premises known as and by the number 108 Cortlandt Street and waieh business i s conducted by you and Salvatore £aseo, oo--partners, i s noxious, offensive and a menace to the public health and in violation of the provisions of Section £~ Business District Uses, paragraph B~ of the Zoning Ordinance of the Village of Worth farrytown, H.Y.; and to hear and decide the question as to wherein such violation " e x i s t s , and i f so, to determine the proper action to be taken therein. Very titty yours, John Zm Lofaro Secretary of the * Zoning. Board of Appeals �y*yy,»$$r*!«"'« 'r'*-. ^ r ^ ^ ^ w ^ ^ ^ II ,' •v I S / *• �|VV' May Elst t 1932 Mrs. Hoafcnthal 88 Pairview Avenue Tuokahos** Haw York Dear Madame; Ha: Premises 102 Cortlandt Street Worth^farrytown, Hew York Please take notioe that a public hearing w i l l he held by the Zoning Board of Appeal s of the Tillage of Horth Tarrytown, it»Y* at the Tillage Hall, 28 Beekman Avenue, on the 31st day of May, 1938, at 8 o'clock P.Me (Baylight Saving fime) on the complaints of Tiotorla Cushman and others alleging that a certain live paltry business located in premises knofn as and by the number 102 Cortlandt Street and which business Is conducted by Jerry Soaran© and Salvatore Lasoo, co-partners, i s noxious, offensive and a menace to the public health and in violation of the proviso ions of Section 6- Business District Uses, paragraph B - of the Zoning Ordinance of the Tillage of Horth Tarrytown, B.Y.; and to hear and decide the question as to wherein such violation exists and i f so, to determine the proper action to be taken there in« Tory truly yours, • ' '•' " ' ' ' I ; : • '• '. .. •' ' ' John J • Lo faro Secretary of the Zoning Board of Appeals* �4 «•/' ? , •?-* •co' r^^j^^ff^^ :r^>#^;^-F; I- \V '-V �yl VILLAGE O F N O R T H T A R R Y T O W N , N . Y. BOARD O F TRUSTEES FRED W . GROSS, MAYOR A R T H U R G. F R E D E R I C K S , A O T I N G M A Y O R A B R A M N. SADOFSKY p, CARNEY VlLLAQE COUN8EL AEU J. COFFEY EDWARD C. V. C A S S E L L VILLAGE CLERK & N C-GRAVE80N ALLACE T A X COLLECTOR M A R I O N A. D E E L Y DEPUTY CLERK HUTCHINSON F R A N K A. M A R A S C O 8 VILLAGE TREASURER F.JOHNSTON JEROME N . L A W L O R VILLAGE ENGINEER TRU8TEE8 MAY 21, 1932, R. JOHN J . LOFARO ECRETARY ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS ILLAGE OF NORTH TARRYTOWN, N . Y . Dear Sir: I have been directed by the Boarfd of Trustees of the Village of orth Tarrytown , to refer the enclosed letter to your Board, VERY^TRULY YOTIRS, c. ^(LJUL. �^^L/% J13*- ^cc^ ^i^e - /0% �W.Tfc&wmr/--^ ' J A 4, May 23d, 1932. 18'Hudson Terrace, North Tarryt6wn,N.Y* john Lofaro % 50ty Board of Appeals' silage of North Tarry town,N«Y. / i V- My Dear S i r : I have inspected building at , 102 Cortland S t r e e t , now used as a live poultry market, and apartments, i,ove the present market along with property a joining on nofcth and south s i d present t h e p r o p r i e t o r has in stock 400 chickens, 12 r a b b i t s , 3doz tgeons, some turkeys and ducks • , •*''..-• ' . ie apartments a t 104 Cortland S t , 10 families., at No $00 Cortland St on t,he outh there i s 4 f a m i l i e s , and over the poultry market, one fatoily, • \, "•t also inquired around the neighborhood and found t h a t some of the r e s i d e n t s is very much opposed t o t h e smell from the market, but would not sigh, a |etition,_4o t o t h e fact t h a t they were in buisness themselves and did not ant t o hurt t h e i r buisness• lith the Boards approval T r u s t i n g t h a t this'Information""" w i l l meet I remain r e s p e c t f u l l y yours, I Building Inspector of Village of North Tarrytown> N»X. -.'... , "} ��Ly £3a, 1932. I6*Hudson T e r r a c e , Morth Tarrytown,N.Y> ~*s ohn Lofaro y Board of Appeals^ . , age of Horth Tarry town,H.X.../ My Dear S i r : . nj . I have inspected building at eons, some turkeys and ducks. families, . at*No 3100 Cortland St on t(he Kara r tSiSr.'K ^ n f SS& -***. *. ^ily, Xeo Q u i r e d a r o u s e ^ g & * ° £ « * J ^ & ' S & ^ s S 1 ^ S ^ t o ^ f a c ^ ? t S y ' w e r e ^ tuisness themselves and did not t to hurt their "buisness* ,v>.* Trusting that this information will meet T •iff h. the.Boards approvalI remain respectfully yours,. I Building Inspector of Village of North Tarryiown, AUx. *. .# , I '.i i, v l , �11 * ! I f « fe^lfe-i^H'*? V*W^•' ' ^ S ^ V A A V ^ ^ £^&«*^W £V*«*V> M ^ ^ * * ^ < * ^ " fe^t^lfe *^; �\>\ MONTHLY REPORT OF BUILDING INSPECTOR FOR ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y. permits granted permits deniedFrom ^1™-..- 2 I 193.2 t o Jl3Irt 1 9 3 .2 as follows Application of ..^Q**.3.??.:. &lterat%om.* ^..?™?A^>. Building located at „ Permit granted-fip,n1 nfl on----l&X--7£*UApplication of -llmo.t.hy.-.N.Qlan.. Building located at -Br.Qadmy an<l..Garag€u.. 193-2--Permit No-AO.4.. .Por.cli..aiid..r.Qom.*. 18LQ..£ZZ.* Permit granted-jlfijiifiiL.on----May„-I9tli,. Application of 193.2 Permit No~4Q5-. —~ Building located at - - Permit granted-denied on Application of —- 193 -- - Permit No - Building located at — Permit grant ed-denied on 193 Application of - Building located at - - -—- Permit grant ed-denied on Application of Permit No- ----- - 193 Permit No- ----- 193 Permit No- • . Building Located at Permit granted-denied on.... �Application of - - - - ----- Building located at '-- Permit granted-denied on u I Application of — - ' , I 193- —~ Building located at — - -.—— -• - - —- Permit grant ed-denied on - Application of - —-- Permit No- —- •- - — - -". — 1 9 3 .—--. Permit No —- ! \ Building located at — - — - Permit granted-dehied on • ii Application of -— — 193- — - Building located at - Permit granted-denied on- - — — - 193 - Building located at - Permit granted-denied on - -- Building located at Permit No - - - — - ----- -Permit No - Application of Application of — -193- Permit No - -- Permit granted-denied on — 193 Permit No H il! ill lb { Dated: North Tarrytown, N. Y. ,-Mav.3Ist,. 193.? I 'I 3 I' ' ^ ;i< t t . '1 BuTtaing inspector of the Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y T'ti '" """Silfel -»**• •wwafiwyni spap � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_ZONING_1932-05-19 Subject The topic of the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1932 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Village of Sleepy Hollow All Rights Reserved. Type The nature or genre of the resource Text https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/c23e9c1c85aa3619b5b1772d0ee6e8f9.pdf d41f30ec76f384a9ccedf67e5b8422d7 PDF Text Text n Minittes of Z 0 ning Board of Appeals May 3 1 , 1932 �•*?*« > '.t'l.W, •I'4 li'W ! httiMi if ill �At a Public Hearing of the toning Board of Appeals, neld on the 31st day of May** 1932.' P r e s e n t : &e*Uld'B, »Goul4, Chairman ,-* C ^ J c f W & J . tf*S»*d, S e c t a r y /* '/ - ' ; ^r^am^.'.'Oa^Qfslcy; Village C 0 uhsel • ; ;^ ' ' : >• ^iifc?iiO Hearing on the complaints of Victoria ' qtt»&ta*t; J o t o S, teato, Joseph, Kttzvar, P . M, Fixer, Mrs. A. Vafc*e&VI&^-^w Ba,r:tb?.i2ZiV Liko^Kae London, Mary S. Mann, •: ^ ; ^ a ^ % ^ i # # ^ "«A » i e t * ° Badaiamente, a l l e g i n g that '*«"««£*&&kvAto&titfftiiW^rtf^*64 i*> emtB ? s , to0Wl aB ^ ^ ^ ' W W ^ ^ f 8 t r i i ' t / y a r t h TaWytoim,' ! . " * ' . , and '••• ""•'•'* "' ' "•'•"--' • -; ""•''•" •"''-• • "jer:ry Sc'ar'atio .and- Sal.vatore lassoo,,£#& a l ^ j i o e . t O ' the public *. : X ^ L ^ L T * ' *ti>u£XRA&i> the" m e e t i M tf orrery- *»n<™ u �Ijil '* t • Si "'I •; t ' ; i-M "' 7] P . X mloT, . *.f.T. < ^ A - ' i LJ:v.?.C' 'A-OIII/V '{'1..'" "T3 '.l 0 :-; <.'• '.'»..r! r.n r -3."--. i \\'-.: ..-^ *.-* , (i ;-,Z :.>.:(..• ,;• ., i i .A r :• c- > -, i.qi*ie 0 eft J" n o . b 17(10 L ;o.; > ;. :J\BOo. 0 U.'jL'S. . ^\:.Y , 'voTl r -. . X . cl .X8vsu2i f!!'..;.Jc;oXi ^CJ^'J-UJI li' mioL tmr.v?.'-; if /.M ':,;- t O'Lf.i.i(vi . ;;':le'io.::•'••: . 7 ivLndaicJA . c vx^f • ^!;^e.ii.o , rioAooJ 3.t-;H TfOt^I , 3^fi^fnlnI^i:j3H , .!"'•, iloi c n.8 fiiii a JTS. C- x.c& . H ^ i x r o J o ' i ^ i f i IjfLB ' - . ^ B O S J w s t b n A ^lod'ii^C (lG^aiS s« ip'or..>: 3;:'2i.:;;:.: -xc; id: .OO;O;QOI a a o n i a u d ^ t d l i j o g s v i l ni,Su'i6S -. <,Y . Y . nvfOw dj'rYl .;j---o:i8 d-ftriMoXoO tlQ.t . oT'I ya .bio;;; :.UJ- VI'XKT At ,001 i l ^'.„ccv; L?c bn.o o.u.sX3oY ^TiaL vd b s o v r i i o o s i assnisifcf jila;:].;, yn.: o.t ^ojMfow £ bns mw ndo-L .IY-URI svi^fie'rio c iiria'D^a 'io -UiOi8.n.ro"t:q srfj . aueixon si doid 1 " as:-md,rx.flq--co 'io n o i d ' s l o i v u i arts •id'lBsd' L.i:V ;;.;:'* i o ^oi::^r;;.OiO ;bi iixoS arij- 'Io ti nq.s'igBi.sq <93u Joi'xd-axQ . Y . Y trvwoo Y'-'-XGA1 rid*io[T l o % . r;i ,'q 0 £ : 8 d.p. T^b'io ed" hsf.L&o rxddoj--H ir30!Jj.!oni:B ^I'vY-io od- K'idv-sru biio onil.Leo ax III: a- o'i 3>toi^Iq^o^ oilcu;o do ^ i u ^ o ' i ^dd" s..:. r.oIx.foC' ftsIJlso n.snrii.sdC' ?,i d i d\nd;! •••;:* 3 J .,MV^.rj'-:o0 SOX d\s do-dxfi^ n^^oxrlo B 'IO gninacro sad- ^ n i d x : ^ iiiSif-J- do m O;:K-O i o adro:^: ioJYrriOo sad" Sfidj tosvollsd" sri jjnid'.sus ;; 0'i;; .bf,i;,ij:::i3,:r.q nn,o .iiOiLS^.Rl'i. . iM , iDamjoo \rci' Iv^rns^eTqs'i si':* •••;; • ••yiqo'. "i.to:-.'^ TO ^v.:;..ci o'lx^ ,to^«xBM 3iiu l o Siai<:x x s sioir?ro srid- M 1) oo'n. A r.!:;(.•.?• jj'i^Ou ofi;; ;j,o:icr iTod^^'o."- . i!'. ijamio'ifii iLBK»ii.fifiO ^rfT !•;.•• i-:vd-•:•.•! rr-.-/'j no Ou I)^*!?> qe 'iq, 3BW s d a.i?. Ynoiiii;d"a9d- doua G^JCCT bns �2 if*> *aQH&hon said ne was. not prepared to o£fear* testimony toiiight, J\« \\&\ the' ooAiplaiiianis 'ate' simply residents of the d i s t r i c t and W # !00^1ainfe4 ag&instr the opening .of a. new chicken market -„ in l "the neiljl&orfeo.odi on the.ground i t i s tmhealthy. The chicken market .has Wen there .pniy^houtjawbek, and he could not bring ; a n^ te^timpiir Up $<J whether there, was an'odor from i t .yet or fiot. U x \ r ^ ^ m ^ ^ ^ ^ a ^ ^ fast/hearing on August £8, 193*, . ^ o ' ^ c a i ^ ^ ^ o n ' i t f a w d in thp* minute's, of, that meeting* that ther^'fouI r d ir beno mose/ojicken markets, opened in the ; esp4!fiial:ly in t#e conge stedidi s t r i c t s , '•#j|^V^^ % and village , that if he was in *we t h * minutes ,read.. • ,' \. '*\ ^" j*/- ' i f ' . t ^ ^ ' s I ^ u g h t =tiat this'was ir|retqhing ,the^r eoor.d a l i t t l e ; - ', —1 A 'aid %^md^^[ .Maoll^on.that he ha# hlopfcd he^ould have some ; >v • -/ v v •. '<;« i , , » >)T<f •",*" ,« * A ' • i'i^, ^V % ;M^^de t ; kiSJ r e p o r t • 1^ W t t ^ V / ^ �Art. 4 :t;. J U • * r •? •..•:•: i a ., '~» :!•:-•...;• u i •;:•:..;:,:;.! v ' S l l /', ;:o ,:fi^:ftCC ••-a'2 . v;i>.r. >saxi,j BY ;;d m u ^ ' i ^ -.'. .b.Ci,oo -3::1 drYY ,T.(. UYTJ.. 'rt.'jo n."*. * iY/Y.:;;ijA no r';i;.i"ix>eii :L-:,r.ULoeiv: " Y ^ Y YY7 f?..c:r'" OTYdu ii J S iiv b/r> >: •Y OTOO'Y ZMMOCI .0 <i;sood'Yccdid;£OiT, Yidt ^X/YO -.''rend- n e e d ' a.^r:- cre:i :> Yn;to.d,~r ci" a.3 ^ n o ^ i ^ s o u .OT3"^ gnYdlii/S ,a''oii:3iI) d^jas^noo i S'tl:" ^jr;.t.;lo-'8Titc? ^ v ^ d OJ 5x.d+ xxi Q i; ydo ii od'fs:odu . i ? ; ^'.j D8i"ri6a9iq-3^: io .bluofj °^ a -^ sonai'j noxioiYOSM Esa&a&M %$&$ $sd$ edt 8~SCL&C:J:&LOLIGO t , :c;T. i ^ n ^ T o ' i n i di'YS cr.sri""f w s u t dsdai, xo y!.:oq6>%i exij DVY^d bLuow vd-L^ioY sdxX DII/OV-J sxi 3YYr a i d ? ui.cdu u s d,Yd jb.7.a ibir*. oH e d t sdS ' Qv $'}['?. ZH l\ej~J.O£iO SlOui OfX 3 d b LUOW !l T v,-d Y Ir.ro^ ^ d .b^qod lx:v«d 9.d o'.j;fid" ffcd.;-$HO:oA ;Y'i;t3 s v f i i /'<e;.ul .'Y.iqi-OO i?' :;dr ;-.;j J Y I O O ^ T XY- J n s " . ?.i u:oi$ibir;.o aod.iL.DBd ad:*" xrc ,J acdMiosd . jb^^'i 3o3"j.rx'.tm $b$ ll :1-r."v n r r»v, < oBBr.<Z^'> . j. J. cde d\adu Jb 3 o\3tf^ YYIJ i.:, ?. Y^dj;i\^c ?*dc J.Z.V. bS£iSCO 3i- s d vasi ;V;:B smnfi.;: 3d.,)' . d o BY1 .•:; juocls J.i.1. \-. hiBS Zsdi ch/d bLuoi) .'ill <iOoGSG3£iI ft1 tfxul-j .bfi." , oij •••oV; .ixi^Iqiiioo < jjj^cf.?; n i ^ X q w o o Co 11'iiosc.s> ^ x a c r ^ o s r,ed& 3'ddTT ojt a.-..:- d'axidi b^d jj.x;ii av.fid s d ddxrods viro^icr-ascr 'i i s rid" $a <tn&?,:-riG 3d od" /ri^n"a* i o SIY;OS Jbsd'osqpjia Ivsri .--jxi MXSY, rroxisdo^H mixi no .bed^c-c.e.a .^.^i -^d? xaiijvd"^ .taurc *.yon/; -jorc -di:L b u s .gnlXB^d . iH ^iri^ i! i •.•.•n'iiijLhici edJ ev^d o$ X1&-' 3d bDscx di wflgj/oiid" iiXuoO . iH .^IDCG'X ft * '10^0^^3X11 t ^ i i ; d ; ' i " " rxi: uxOqO'i a i d .h^:LirLz>^,,ir-::> ;Y .[' $ bli'l-m an d'u^dY: ^x-^: :^L-dT •4 1. vb^j Sdo o.id s d ;r'Vd:jxO dfT5 ,90.BXO bbSsie. ^'X^Jl'XXSS 6 d u vX"ISfxni^' 8/J zofoso/jcn "IJSI 8X5 d \ S d £ r)XTB 3dcr wio'ii ' i c d o vrx.c XXems ton Jb.il;oo exi �3 1 $$#& Aa/l a li&l^' of sawdust on t h e floor and he thought there x **d{*&W* $&n%f&extant. Iim f a c t he would s a t I t was muck more adnita&y^ tfraaa so&ie other* ohiokeft markers he has been in^ 'flif'tfi-'pb' oompiaintsVteoji'^iy one and w^s surprised to hear . t ^ f M$fl *JfrtT^P* .$*£ " ^ ^ ^ p l a i n t s / ( S # >4fotil& .'ftfttfl £f *flfc$re *iwUr an# Objectionable n o i s e . ' f ^ < # ^ ^ ^ ' e ^ i i ' M ^ ^ J ^ ^ ^ ^ # a#£t^O<^^^^ a<# • ' * « * ; ! * w a * *h e * e * He &id' t a totaJcMcken. ' He had i n u r e d ' - 1 <» t h e ^ 6 u t h and thsy s a i d i t asked them if they that as she- was in �a'Oijri; '- "'v' ;rx xon .i1..!'. ir::;., :" \d T.;.;-.V:J 4 . Xx;/'^cv/Xai::a a:- 611102 ?..Rvr X.i Xox'X rrX ..XX.'JO' T...,II;IO .'1 r.Jivi'i.'i.' n o x o h i o ^fvri^ ftsiix v-t^Xinx-a <vxoi;i "o i;.;^r...crAJ.;o p.x>u ;.n'i.-•'•, 3i',.o v/i.0 ffio'xi eXxxL<v.Xqmoo on .b:»ri el : . >^1 .ex.--,}'.cmoo .o.'iu bxui . ;.txx'"u eXO.,:;noii)-r;.:..j;cl'o ^rxs X..*..b y;i. . D'xorii n.ivv xxi n;:>;iw u;pxix i'>.-•',rl oI-T :J-OJ:». ^.H^1" X r:uiit .•::••• X.sri'X OXG'IOJ c oxuiX 'ix xieolRB bXxxo-D XKJOXXX3 YX'X--:u';r.xM t; TOXOOC;3£»7 . n;-:j:.-io.tuo srxarl® x> Xo Ino jfTr.rti.yp3 .•.•* a/scui nsvc-j tfoxi Xi J'.)i; s'-i Y3.ciu oi/x:; iioXiOB jri.X lix^ 6'X'oXx; '^'louoi^ t;xjxj Xxs 100..! o x s n ^oilJ- ' i i r.JSfi;]" j'.'o':ji?i.« X.xd on . frrf&ixi Y£ii>rxxjd\s8 no oJ"d.n:'xX'X H..-iv; rd 8J.V.7 :-:£[<•: sx; XxxtX < on; Jix.-s-3 variX inm Xrxix^Xqmoo orfd* Jbertgxs £>>.:• rf ocivjij:; ;.'!5nl'.G; .n Xxiixutjioo --3 e^xon* oX ^nicp) Xon axv;r 9ria XxiUiix y-V- ;.r i: n •J:V;L ^aesni^ucf Xxoxiax; axiw YXienfiiM . *•£?' .3S9Xix«x/a nx sals . 3 .-'XllMft". 0T'<rX 9'Il'iW 8T6uIX XJf.^JSJTfi 1)0.(3 3'I.t.GX BQir ^flXVXi 3iT-r>j;J-.tj,X9Ci"X.~ vru} :.>'i::;\v ;vn<!ix 'ii ^.Lienaxil . nl' belies blvoD . i*' axidd" oioi?i "•ruld'ofi ^ i v y X s i f ^ s n i r i i o n M.33 YXisnnxT/. . iM bfis ,:Ist).b n sxx do us froxX^o/Xqqx*. x>}ixiiT! o;i £jnxrfu Yns esu i)ix/- ton xvrt'fiu li b.toa Y ^ ^ n i . * * . x^ bn'- *xox 'xod"09c;af;T 3i'i'X Xxsdu t^ni'dX'M.\ eX'TirXxil STOP'S beife^ JbXxroO . I H iLxxi:Mxxx£ ortS oX a"ror.;I sri J)rre v'tGu inxss arid" ax; xe.X S.R XxulX . XxulX Xo s i ^ o aoxix^X i c r j o s q a r u fxoXov-.cax... ;;;KlbXxxitl crfX xo d"roqe>'i &dX ixss'x Y^a'io.b£;8 yxsdxtfies XSHUXLOO . 8 £ £ I < S S T&B M 3C-S^^3[ .V" .VL (iJ"-.Mvj---.r. ..u^r dXxXl, c aos-x^9T fioabu-K 8 1 , s i , - J oA Xo .b'liioa srJ d- Xo v/i^'^s^oeQ . i .la tiiTr:^^'X-i.3X ad"xoH Xo toij8loJ nrioL . ill Ji^ILiV :TX8 IBSX) ^M tfX.iKU'.a-'xnO SOX .oil X.;i yxixJDlijjci &d& Jby^oaqanX ovisrf I ^drf- ovfjui; •^newX'x^H .B fen^i d-^Ixsm Y^d-Xnoq svxX a exx Xtaau Xsso.d-8 �prrtWti ina&feet a l o ^ wilih property adjdining on north and soutfe. '* ' • ^ ' i 4t present/the proprietor/has lxi« atpok, 400 chickens, 13 r a b b i t s , • 3 dofcesi pigeons, an<i some turkeys,,and ducks, the apartments a t l O i O o t t l a n d t Street 10 families, at 100 Cortlandt Street l o n t h e . south ther#>,is 4* families and over the poultry market , i s one family/ yl'-alio inquired1,around the neighborhood and found thai^dme^e^ldeii^e w^svery^mtaeh opposed to the smell fvott^'ito ik«ifo%"iwJ»^ouid riot I M ^ ' ,/ petition' due to the fact tfra't .t^ey'^Ve in "business-,themselves and did not want to hurt < , , , . ' ' : . their^ bfc$i&es&v '< .. J . — .trusting that t h i s information will meet with , the-Board1.© a^^bvai^Ireiriainv v s% - v, • •' 't",4i->"J\lEle^bt^ully..yioTjaps, ^ x >: ^ / - i v . v . ^ • / • / < f/w< l ^': 'i V-v", ^I'r'1"/' *• "\'\, n"^'\^Per<3iy,0, Minnerly * , .,' ' ••. ' * ^::i ^ . . -J ^ > .,/ ">/'V \ H V - / \ K J ^ ' r^BuJiiiing^n's'peotox^, Tillage' 6$ north Tarrytown." .. �<,oio7 "ilooo, I:.' ; . o o o o ; i"••.; .rovooj n'A'i ,t ;...•:.•• i , : ^ J .'.n.voJM T-.O K ) i /': -! I'i "'H ,i ...••.•, '•',,• I, . •' ;i '. i/vi. • . ^,7! •.,.••',' '' '! .'),..: o,/ '.:. 70 I o o •'• i: ! :: o ":,'l. •''•• o ; ''' T • •'•.r ''J.:.or :>•,.; ;7't!!'"'''.!'", o .-OCA i , o iioi'ii :.'•;,;'.;. :!•••;!• ••"•;, \>oo j7 » jo) o \ . i.. ! .'/.; v •. ;'OJ;* .j • • oyr a l r i ^ b I o o ' t . 1 •:< . V I. .!. (J'.'•'. .1 ,: o70o t. i.w ii, »i, J 0!\'J : •• : o o o i ' •.•r.'.ltf ^oi. V'OOJUT i , 1 .1 . 0 1 ! ! ' . - .•. O 0 oo u ;ilii" 7iO": >'ioo"r \OoiO :» oo . OP^MOLU.; r . . - . . * • , •- / 7..' -.j;k' ' ' ,., ,. 17., 1/ •••> .i ; .., v j O I J J.0/0 ^ ',0.7 -''•;• b.O'O.v • I07 3'o'>!'.':oo .... r 0T-'. f .J.1 o.<vo •. . ••], ' j , , .,.;• orooio.oo! o ; ! o;o o,: osv •."• ,!(-•, M o ./.''•• i :"-' ;!,-••[••; "••':'"(' 1! !• i'lti.! J c! itia . 7 i. ' . i'.'iii , O'llO ' .• V. • I; !l Y.!".-.» ju. t;:.' ',• M o ' i i ;'i 7. C.|''•'. 0., i ,o .^O'OJM; ,oT o M " ' ' ?io .»v;-;''.!'.! V .'.ioor ;>«<o oo'f ;--r, .f h .L llf-.-.l voSoo io <vl.i ;.;o7iJ o? no o y\s -j'l ;.,ro.O! J.O ch.uW Moopi OJOO,* blxjoO . M 71 III' O,. ',iiii.' 'i..'- d,Ou7 j-.....i*;' !" fool uU'.C'i oM'7 0 00 .'..tar, t l i O C O TC) 0 X 0 J' f f 3MJ XOOOU «.vo'0 '.to Mo..:. Mild M r.v; xM.Ifnio.l li ;M.i.O;]! M: or.j>,r r;tM;]' . .'.'j.jj.Cjj.i-Ht od f.'X;;.i;..*;vr j .'• F>oob ^dxxioo o i , : iwrsi" t 7.7,1 dnoi'Mxo.t:oo ii;l" X.rjr»i".: ^ M o . M ?.-.•. .U \7 ,oo' i!'ji.!:i':>C{.»,'}/jj7,.i ti.ioUoii oj: i.''.:(£.'q "<.M WL"\ 11 7-7; i •' noi'iJ:«i.! .'Li'.! :v&im x o i M . V 7 ooj.ro :-.->iiJ 1.0M.M hi7M,oo.o -.i-r. -j[•.•.' ;oi ..;•;:,. Mv .ij d\i*,rid' < &i'.I:od'j7.:o.o;» o o.l.'0o VT.i\ J !o,,o,-: # Vo 'i't)7'o 7; o';uo)'oi OJOOM g.oM J:v.;,t.M,?. ! oiui .ui ,0: [)i/Ioj'i.i' y;i.^Ii;or;; 'io 7tvT"(i .'"uo- , iDo.r.r.t;:! .r.;.,ii7 i.od ''oioom iioi'". o'/U'-l;5" r.^;,..bJf.vo,£(.j ylox-iw r v l . .twos I ..;( i ! i."'' . •:'' '' .•.!;,!': 'JJ-'T.^ 77.1 ; :- ', 1 :r '.i.o Of .^'iMivcvrr; ,uU^'':o,o :.il)'hr/ ^XqiuC'O Xf.oiin . V • v! ,, •::•.(.••,!" !•.(•').+ ' i O 3rU.,J',:)i.'L0 0'C0 Olio' f:»Oar.i)"?:fi f ' O; .o! 7 /:.,.• r;;po , :r :.»aa n-li". .V-'AIcj'hoo o^o-oi i»r.-rf; 07U;ii7H1 '.o' i ri'io ;;•:.;,..) or o\i%o nv,vo; •.'V,o!j \o.uiil\ nn -aVI. o,o xuoo rU.r--«' o M o i ' u ,, iMOi'j T::^;ou (.oi'iai: J.oo a i J ,-.>:[ MO ut odu ifVi ! * ] • raboo 7'jdd" J; *IRR f •' I IIOUE ^".LO,J i:rv.a ^'loJttoyqaior. ",j;ci �i atandpoint and represents as good praotloe as Is possible la handling Hve poultry or In slaughtering for sale. It Is obvious of course that wherever you have poultry you have odors of poultry, and it is largely a question wbether those ottbrs. are augmented by, improper o u t of the building or cleaning.the 'premises in the .course of business, and i t i s our ' attempt through inspection to see that those premises are kWt in a.''Masonry clean condition' to do business and that they do not beopme unduly offensive, particularly in view 6 ! f , t h e W W .location in a business or industrial zone. I O o S s i o ^ - c f * • * * doe* not exempt, the,holder. from any T'.ti*r'l*^AV^~&: U.^•&&&:** *+* *«'v oolloe regulations ot any build'***« Waccate, 4 ^ P ^ ' - * i * " - ^ ^ " ' 'H'ffE>'.1!,j'v|.'.!7'>( • M A »< ' I ' W i f - . , . JW-P^t speolfioally M^t^xempV'from'any of those , '', •, <>• . • ., ,::«m^^%?$^^"^^,'-"V "' v <& 'maffcet here or •,,:'^:' .iiii^i-JA. .«i«h», ,of«.the, owner,*,of t h e , ^ * ) , W •, . . M* * ?M' i^g i»,o,onneo*io;ii;,*ith the case? - ^ .'-j!;; "' ' • • ' '• B,W»out two jtears^; �'""•"1-M - >.:•; e..'V; l''',^0'." oi s* ooioooric; Ooo;x ox-' ' ;,, XOS-O?^C : ^O ooo jiixooxuxyj o. . ~. i'.-: - o :d> • :x:r a: •..;:• '^ x;..ou: oi: xo VTO loox' o v i l •£.LixS&i\zn •• r :;I ••>••"••••:; UOV O'Oi J J J O C \*V- ii. JXO"-',' XOO' : >XOd""* riT>[{d' OO'XiXOO XO ? U 0 XOOlO :KI-;-:I^ x..f.l;; ;xrx oox;o:;;voo ,s \;; I ;•;;//,;•;! -;.i: xl ;i/!.;:; , v^xxx/oo 'to ••vxo£>o -...•.•;:. U- xo> o^loxix..^ ^:'o 'xo oooo T^qox:q:;.iX \:<J Loxxxornxuxo oxx; -xmbo 00 x ox j i J.:>r.r-3 . 00 oxiv.oJ "xo osoxrco Qtit nx oooxxooxq end' :oai; S'xx- 3 0-;:i:ffiS'.{;'; : ^ -; ,;^». - cr xodx s e r oJ roxxxoscaxxx a^ooTi'd'' ;}'C''i3g7s oxrx .•••-';•.[•:is.'.;-• 0.0 o:;' XOO'XXOPOO oooxo o'loxu>oxx:ox: o n i ;!'C6X' '••••••.:.! •>• ATJ v l x o .UiD..U'x">q ..&•:• xexoii 10 -vfixoxixx orxoox J ;ton 0.0 o o a t xxoix 1 . eoo:y. J,ii'i.*^;.b!'ii 'xo aaoxuGxo.; 0 .0:1 o n x l o o o l IOOXBXJ l i s da 10 orix VQ .ooir : '-.t xiorxoq ooxx xxoxd- fr/o J n x c q ox s x x l jjjoxow 0000 rjjo'ix 'xoiDlou dil;j- xx,in9X6 j on aooxx djJoioH do xxnoJixoxmnxoO -ijIXOG VXX3 XO 'OOOXiXXoIXJ^O^ iiOilOO "X ' TK 10 aXXXOiTlSTXX/pO'X ^fliiXOS onx xa TO ^ul.LJj-icrriOO orix a.f. ci'sxxo ^GK xooix snoixxox'xxoai: J.]'.30 1 •'xioivs \M UXOTOG odT . Suv'ool ooo; J8};T;;I;I s d o doxdio fix xicixtoos osodx' do vxxo xxoxx ck/maxs d ' o n a i : xs.bIo-1 oxlx d"x>fix JxJt JXO aodxoxa IlV- r 00 ax 0 rxixoix oncUjxoq ad? sorxGxaxii: s i rid" n l \i\ W Ifil'Ei' xjiii JVx'o x l .acto&iSTixxps'i . o g o l l x v edo xo^ axexlooiu sorLi'o sdxi' a,-; xifiMd" I .DOXOOX:O ovod Jbsdxsool adoixoxx 'xodxo oxix nxsiid' eoxixxaxxxn STOUT v;rrG 9XRSXQ xon 7 , snoxxxologsx: gxur-.os oxlci" ::;• xvr aoxLSilqjiioo a:ix axi x « i 3A . V-OUT*ro sect- TO xioxaxjloxioo i b i ' i o Jonxx.so xo 6X&D x^ix.i^i1 6xio *io S'lairs-o oxid" xo •x^rluxa s'xA :.blx.(oC; .TM Mm "asxso arid' il'd"±',v n o x d x ^ n n o o ai grxi.fid"\rn.?> yx*a ox ssLtl Y^rfd" .blxiow ) ••V3V;XJOOOC! *xo'x rj:worf-v;*:i:*i.^T o^ OuiXiO I . bvXIGXV-'U? "ig I os : o:>./\) ox gr.xvx^ .:.-fn I f t trii' cxi\*'xx 3? t a^oro',.x;ct :ooo,s^ . iJ••• nx Y - ' ^ ^ Y - ' ^ S d"09c;ao'x I Sris . vxi:jriX;Oo a x d j xi.!: ai.o:.^ v;d-riow£ xxjoa\s nrx; I axx-ov o"'Vo xxz-XJO s.ow I fell I j \y& od- s ^ x l I .aio-v^ V H n i n i s s O nx 00 w I . ghivil s nx o^ ox xi;o om b-Dcrfsx-f iwnd'T.iXT YM .IL'IOJJ i o Xxio �Vti1 - 6' >~. ,A m&<a&d Mm, t o g e t h e r . Mr>lk3^tdi Y0u wei'e two years out of work preceding t h i s . Mr. Las60S YeeufrSo he* t r i e i i to put me in business, me and him 1 together, Mr* jSouid ; Hfcirqte you had complaints from neighbors? Mr.^*»ft^oo:JU;^ one, t o l d me anything, t t r y t h e beBt I could. . iro^ o ^ e ^ . ' a n y t y i n ^ ^ no word to : me at a l l . " mo^e t i l e a ^ tban u aay other*, chicken market. I, keep my plade ' They say put sor^e^^dx^ynd'W'ft^dld. They cannot find nothing against it. , If you.watft,,to'S;.endM;an! inspector t o , inspect i t and they can see^^t'^^lq^k\li;|^.', * '}'* 1,keep very sanitary p l a c e . ir^^#teakbi..(^lid'i^vSfeWli iarwhat we understand from tie Health Be$a^$aent,-'ifi : |d>|# e t i y clean s o ' f a r . I--tinderstand there 1 ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ t i ^ ^ ' ^ ^ u *SpS ,to * *fay • any;thi?ag. ''Ijlr^vWarW^^ K I "was i n Washington . t t l ^ ^ ^ u w ^ " i ^ ; ^ a w v T. «*v.£«u^**' na ^ ^ g i n Jthe poultry 'good.-cohdition, ? »." complaint, mo �HI i 1 I1 . Terlj .-.-• jctf nu:ri tns A\ ;. u;.' o so.G.Cq I rj'-JivjCi f l W >"'•; 4--.':-:oI I Vli I /^Xlidd""^; Of:: M o t : JOJGJO€ . x.' . "-'Y : ou••:•:"•.\ . ; r : ;n.;r "-t- "c.-^iz ;t 3il c^ .I;."?I:G .]j.Lr.r.;;c -J v,o #•£ OT'*;: o iL-; ""•• JU -Y sn: 0f ; O Oil ! 008.3". . T7 ' .11;? .';v'» un OJ M'ov-- on ,§n.n{yvi;iR ^.BS sno o'K ji !'! 1? I .i. :;•:-:.L'.";;,.;, ;-.::..\ckro/y .Dull ~0: n.eo '7,eiirP .M.o Q^ Jjn* ibm/o'ia n/-S':ro& i.:;--o ji-.} ^;:ij ':;fi.s d'i: :"oyc:si>i: o-t 'xotosqani: r;# . OO^Iq TTr' o X HJ3 -' 71SY 'J5 9S1 I 3I! si rfcr J.r.sH ; T d rro'x'i hiisiv^hnu .0' s a Cu jn.8'v UOY I I . 9:'iC 8 2ICO.C tf I '•J.PJ.W ::<o8 sw $.•$:{-* a i iv;r<? :1JILOO ./:l2£r3£! . sK 5 jii V.TSCIO hivri8'.:o.D:iir 1 . x n Y o a xinelo vj-j-s x; a i d'i . JTL^HIJ TSCOG j-.lu^iu :• v;.;;.*^ -^3 ^naw i/ov oG . a TV: n • •'TC q ov/d- s x s ;io^^i"r;i::-.:-/5 ;.i ?f?jT.' I . q u itsqe 07 s i s r l e.rsr;o r ronsT-oS . i*. f i tr.o.ccr.rr.inno Jbc-o£; r:i oo:>Iq srfer c q e i I .'3ie;:r:oY n i cj-a^i^m o.c , d'nx.vlc^oo on bn-3 a x a e ^ S I si32li : oY n i nsecf SV-.Q I l)n.s MR, I ll,i .boc*:: ^'jor'ic ^niuJ-vieYY li .xlii $.:•:> aId;jo^d- .3 I O C ea:••:•.Iv ,3 i'"^ r:-:i.':ir j-^/iri" 'J ir> i o i q ft! Mi Hi''IJH ]!f'"li «i i d-^iio esuso-id urrC'i"i'r:vi.':oo u i ev-od o j BV,srf i.;oY . a a o r i i s i r d ^iroy oib yio-:.!1 Mi ob u z"{ o'l^ri*1/ og uoY V&vil s l q o a q 9 i 9 d ^ moTi u o ^ eisdw ei ^Oil'l a x i l vsi-ld. SO^AC vu-: •:;mor; -n err r>:: en;oo ocr softBvr ; ^i '±1 fooR.sf^ . i ! ' ' �Mr., ,Gould; I t doe'snot, mate?, any difference t o you, j j r . &&#0e: I am on the t o a d . People do not have, t o come to mj place to* get s t u f f , lie they feel l i k e going they go. I want t o make a l i v i n g . ' Mr* Mullon: t)$ you sell, more wholesale than r e t a i l ? •Mr. 3*sw&w: Ho* ,®#ch wholesale'., Mr . > t u i l o n : TQU^depend' on people,here to s e l l tq> Mrir ^ # e « T * S ^ 1 never s e l l much put s i d e . , Mr. Mullon: You s e l l more to the community around. Mr, Qouldr.Mo^t 'of- your customers-live r i g h t around t h a t s e c t l d n . .jfc 4 ^ S ? Fol ,l'^ave'customers in Ossining, a i l around. ' »rV M^llbtt: ^° y o ^ ' s e l l ' W t c h ' e r markets,-take, an order for , ,. * a couple, of h u n t e d ^ c f c i c k e n ^ o h e ' d e l i v e r e d t p a butcher s t o r e * l \r J i >rVmeat^ market t ' buy 50 6r 25 s e l l ipt.1 Sous : - ( f - ^ J » ^ , y ^ e ^ ^ b a i 4 s : ' W l i k t ' we- use-. ie to?%iie^<Joun,tyr i a i k ^ f i i an^'operate �1 00 don oil olcooY . .0. o I' Ji ODlUOY no -li U,'cS 30. S 05' 3 00J..0 ( ' •[ Co vix'-,' GToSii .r.r''c' i/on oCi : no YUnl Lisd-oT 1! :•) LaaoIoYn oonn ;l\ViI ;0'On;.oY . x r i d u iJ.j.L, 00 c no b;.;ro;o x;oY :noITnoY .!:'••' .SjoioOijo oourft I I O O U: ^-..oi I . 0u :onn-,n~> 01':. . .i..'J ;d Iox.o::0;Oo foic'" o:?- li'.r-M-r IIo.p. oroY : :..o!L"..'!.I . 0" .ao'Y too 50? •' . 1 . rtoiU'Osa dnonl- Jbnuoxo •iifci'i svJLC anoracorouo -ifJCY "io u3oM :.bD.o%.: . i n , .briinono, l i s < gaioY on;:, ni: &i.oiio;toi:o 9 v ^ a I .oil rcoaonY . iY o o i ico/'To no 9:00 j ,Bv Oyinno; 'lonlocj-jju Y I o s u o v oQ : n o I o n o .iVfoovo;o -i/Yooio; n od" h s ' i . v i : I s b oa 00 aaeYoicio .ooi.fcriiJfl 'xo s l q n o o ..3 '< f ;| Vns^h:.on: ooem 10 68 TO Oo 'j;ua o£ jn,otTf ^srit YX . BBX .xsjoa^o s.sof 11,3 Y r 63 I rms sooYnoY ax s.onr I .metis nfeod'YnA : e o - s s - . i n Ilea O J ci'Og 3n.0:l 1 . 1 erfa o:l 31 •- no JJJ0 TsxinY 3 ncrx- XX±:i uox oQ tnoXXuK . T'Y • A - . . • • • - • . - • n . , , c ' t , •• . onu en- d-^rl^T ox d'j3.dT ein6 t-iO03.>X- . iY i:)'x.ooS (YYC^oY V3TIJJOC od;t moix d-inrii-q o n o ^ $0% noy avnH : I;|uoO .-xY . e'xod d"i ev.srl I . aeY r-ocra^- . iYr :Ji)ioorfT sricj- no cr^dt ffu'-l ihluoO . iM . do.Osuh xo a iis m^XB'j 9 CI vrtfnuoO ^cejBoriGuesY" .Y . Y tZizlal* . i b n o i ^ a i n n o O t .-xL c XXooxn 9d'idW 3sirf:rd\sM TlLnYYY YYIOTAoYA oYu oii" sbm: v.Jjj.b nosci" ^ n i v M n o i ^ a o i l q q A 6x.o-i :.>no .Di.o ni:joun..coin 0+ j xraxaq .« 'lo'i i.loX,soH 10 n - n o x::-3x;oi:;O0 :.OH:JO'0 �TV ' fv 1 o - - ' ^ m t a f t o i ^ ' a g required/by' Section 3 A r t i c l e I I I , of the ^©Btehester: .Ocfttttty Sanitary 0ode.» permission i s hereby given $© Jifry)a-Xiive Poultry Mar&et ( J . Scarano and S. I*asco, propfV)' t V maintain tod o p h i t e a n x a abbatoir at 10S Gortlandt a t r e e t , t Hotftfc Tarrytowi, H . T . , for the purpose of slaughtering ' an# marketing jpfit; p o u l t r y . ,TMe permit i s issued subject t o -^itfiiSri-iiiiftpWt"qpig^io*|<f^/^i*^ *^e local ordinances, and with tiie b u i l d i n g f ^ d zoningrequ:ixement&.; \ Date& May 13, 1932. ' Tfci^ permit e&p|res July' 1, 1932. ; ./'" , ,• V, -, f a t t h i a s H i c o l l , J r . , Commissioner. ' Hfifes ihi'S 'iTe%tei%" *>•« issued subject to -suspension or - . �% • -^ !.'"»J; -"J" •"I'.iw ' <•'• o x x x o - O v;d' Jxo'xxxoo;- x a x Txo-'xq^dn rxx .r;^-.t-r-, OxxxvX . rxDM) ,oCXo:;.:. jivjq '!.J IO'O . L 0 1 J'. . '.c.;:''.'1':•'•:.c:'d>, s;n xx^ t I JO;H.X:L YbTax'-'".--0 ' l y ' - a e a c " xxd" •r.v. oxi,r;. T':•• c (: . 0 '; J' ••-. r-i' *x. »••, ,"-r ^'/. :>• .CTJ o S:. 3 ' v i i r^v-xxoO OJ" • j ••T.VJ-I":-;- .:;.; 0- Xo x-xqxox <;;:•!' X'XXJXJXX^O oxX xod , . Y' . 0 •:??: X&XOOOI XXOX.K:. brx SODX/CO ytdT f xxxol rxtj-xi ox^xx o x ( . s g o x VXXXXO rfuT;0.i . YxdxDxoo :£©&" iyxoixodxrxax dn.s rifri™ Xix; aoox r xx.':b-xo l o o o l o d e dxix^ o y n a i l q m o o ' Ml .0000 , 0 1 vxad iv?Xo(,I . ^o moi'oaxiJpxx ^nxdjos t 'in x x x x o r r o r ^ j s brxo xxiixbidtijd o r u •XLiX)f<\xr.LiOrxx- iKMmiu;z sixOT CIXIXXTOO . xL ^OCoox-O axiaXXBxi ox x o o q . i ; ^ xxxxioax ex d-xrxxeq x i d T . 9 -:XXOO T.ol i'lO t IIux XJXEQS . 0 0 0 1 . 1 -ir.roL ao-xlqx-3 .x,, U oi:::.x;xixixrO; tj-o^id-8 i x v v i o o o x rxxd s a x,a(Id" .bc;0/:uonrxs X-! o:}&-r xox O.nei 3d. x i Ixxlx ixo;xo^xiO M x / o € :x;toX IOBOOVOI . O'XB'IOJ . xsOl b n s TM cix;iX9l '. rlo'iow S B W ssex ,91 'vxOi r it! Li- . xr^oxv'X'i.tOr -UrioO to e;xx;If xV odxi xo assxBixiT xo Jj-isoH :BII8 iii V Xxx'r u.ulx xeOTxxx XXMIJXOC; sroj- xxroox xxiOax^Iqwoo ms I aixxx fxxrt x,odx oleroxc yd? If m 1 3'JL,->X!; XSSG . tfsaici-O xxiixsIxioQ SOI x.^ bxneqo Do xronq -aiu xox xxxder d o y l l . xv ;d ,fan« BT3>;noY xix s v x l 310X8 axx-oL.oY nx &.• i:0 Xx^dx xo o R o n i a a d .o naqo ox, xx^ixxx >sv,ad YsdT rixii OH'.O xxdT . xxi^x^q & OOGOOO uon Jbl/xoo fouf Y'--;5rji a d d o ^ -bos ad;/ r - , i i nox^::-.nxxx(, xmxdax^ xxxodxx> xs:Ix:xxrn yitLuoci - ! K i H.i n s qu n s q o xx-x. j ; : 0 -xo'i .viori J:--.-vii orrx rix3r.i rrxcj' x> og.n slirf^r A XXXY x:, xi:d ixxx:. oo-.-i.Gj .'.q.; in?* x^nj OHB'I£:O8 XO ,TK x3ax;ia^d 4s aeqo ocJ- bsrit xl . rxsqo ot ..bri.?3o8. 8XS-Y 0^ noxsaian-i-q r)aau"'ie*i :n.;rxixO-.oo ox Ox-oxOx XT;5 a-xo«e xs3*xu8 x]ja.sXX'xoO SOI s a x LJ# ot xo �9 running t h e i r atOTi,-'!' am„4uite "sure Mr. Tornelli 'ta^P^tt "before will again figh't to open. who tried Mr. Scarano and « . &as>P do not vote in No* th' Tarry town. Any money, they make doesnot fcenref.it'this town,/ The money they make is deposited in a Yonkers.fcank and I t Ifi also spent in tonkers. ~„ r v " *' *'' '\ ' ' * Three poultry 4 ' ' marskerb^In'Horth Tarrytown are .enough. Please try to sto|> '' '^]$ij^tipkT& 'tootftts'd tney are' reported to have said that 1 1119 toTO without a n trouble d that '•^W/V^^P^^/ ^** ? ^ \ mp oneVpan stop them: , I won't sign my name because I am '*" V r l e M l F ' W n ttee people of \ 0 o xtteridt Street, and they might f n#^'%ike':. i r ^ttHude-toward ,them^. * V:^ ; -\i l V-V r ; ( ; ^ Tours truly, . * ^\'( % - v v ^ ' V ' A ' ^ i t i ^ e n , of- I,-Tarrytqwn, ' , % ^ & a r : ' » r, * *^ • \ •• . ' ^ U i | ; anyone,else had anything to; say. ^y?itf^i&&hkiAM.MI CAapperf t V W t h e pwnex and • X i l ^ S l ^ ^ ^ ' i ^ ^ i ^ t - # i q % n ' . ^ W t , . a n d f i s h n e t '- .,• : : ^ w ^ S j l i ^ ^ 3 i : ^ ^ ^ ^ B v , J ^ fa*Iva^tne condition; of;t �•V ' ».;'''• ' <. i ' I -r3.:../-. i:. 3:: 7 Y ai jfif!,?, -i i ri t t " 1 ^ nb • : t -•!'3 . m n- t •:::•:.lis " ; i . t i .on. ; 'in r vi <r.r \.::,1 ..•;];•:i.;M.iO si.«; :n'ot7 f r.'./7T 7 ^ " : " " n i of;;;": O'l* ';;.>f:c ..: , i;^oe ; o • i: -1;';j i"? ':.:• • c', ? J. - '.!'.' ri. is '\:'i u st^lT/-,!;: 3V;:Jiatuo ^p.'nio ^ i : l J- rri : u: :i': •" o •:;I;.:•"• o v: /.';• ."- i-'i.o"" T . r^iio vsrit . : o J c ILBC BHC oil , fiTT-, :.[-7 ••XZ:'0-S 3.UJJJ id'J 6 Vfif 9 . 1 1 • -j .v. :£ " i '•< "L j . . h i </T.I . T': itO r/gsi-j-i-O A :!&••:. q.sri. I A t '7vr" -d.t I.r.o 'raLfoI.se t cT'r:ioT':{ ••: rid' r;i ..bstxr-it 3 ^ffii-^a •.'0,±q orft Sils/ii? 7*»?:- n-.o I •J i. a :"f;. .•- *t:'.f?p':T X ; ai fi r v, si'^it od s i si ti dvsrfd" s a o u g aeiota xia ic <X.A£ vZoLjoq Ai:.Ait I srit n t a i £.\d j o i ; AiA evil ^ ° **3it : 'm £ t&L-f .:?-;Si.'.-, I An~: iiispvfrr ^ i ' f e j r vJij-fioxH'CA I bnovsd . t ".^•r.--,{u da i t An:: t e A ' i - n ! !*I.;j o i '.Lr J b s v H S V T Q v s d t :!'j;i A o o l . iM sm o t ;At nX n o s t T ^ q c r o o o n ?,i: S ' l e r i t bius 3dt-'.:; 'c^-i aA . v a j j o l s e f ; -);ij- t/vdt : l:u-> :•?: t idT no.t ti\f.-r:oo - : . ' . ] Ti : l a d t r i e £r,ji neiidTsk 10 T s t t ^ n ; .3 t a u t - J A ;.)::.;> . t e i i ^ n fiO^oirio :•'> a i It toil :,r;.i:-:i-;;-r::.y o.'ui ssXe; -uio 7,173 ' i i bo^-Ias 7 .Duo*) . T H 'i:-A77c: -.<at 9d od 7 -y si so^lq Jb9?Iooi* I UU o :JbIf/o£> .'i,? .^jfii. from iK • . torr i ) i b I 1:.' i ' l i i i -rn.ri -;/I t o n i)ib .ol! ilBfloiiesoH f ; i . . : i t i . i o i l VST/B . 1^ 3'ioob �10 Mr. Gould* I say for your benefit and any others that you do not want to draw conclusions for your own sake like that, for the reason that the existence of a certain type of business may be what we c a l l non-conforming use, that i s use established before the zoning law went into e f f e c t , and the law aoes not prohibit any business that was established prior t0 that time, so I just caution yoa now not to draw that kind'of conclusion because you run a r i s k . It i s far better to bring t h i s question up and get i t s e t t l e d if t h e r e ' i s a question 1 . . » . feosentba; I*' seems that' i s the only question as far as I k n o * , the jealousy question. '. MW Gould: This'Boar&is. no,t .'interested in that. fa. Koaenthaiv-rhat is-my a t t i t u d e toward the case because ' ; r s p e n t - s ^ W a i W r * t o » ^ . i l e they w e r e f i x i n g . i t up and • ' d i f i W e a V ' p e ^ l e ^ a m e .in to. me and asked me/wbat; i s i t going ' «.vto"lbe ^ x V a n d . I t o l d them. •' ;Wl>4^dV'«oW abcut^yovff cithe^ tenants? .. •;' W; ; 'aosinth4a:;,I W ; , o n e tenant above/: /: '• " -'.-'•-' „.i"-? »•' •' •-. 1 i:-';'"'?-;'_„wi,Q^ +;: fVinu'ir.ed of-them" abd'they •:• • ^ • ' ' U / ^ i i ' - ' , > ' V , . i ' ' - > " : 5 W - : > .".<'•''""'"' ' " : - , ; • ffi];ia*i&?&« :*&, Mab^'c^iidren has t<5»r .Va Ai ,r >•.•,'..' ^ , �,^ •s.*:S3J8SaiH**M«a*S<«**«. AH**"* « <*• «>**- ti1 s "x.UOV vfliTG ~?L ••y;;::v X '.! :&JdsoO . TV $•;.••O.KZIJ Co-'-'C :,MrT.b o'J' d";£.;';"" .'?on oP.> i 1 :>.:;G.~:-': .iTrr,:::o.£o:oo O '"i .(.'. , ! dx.^ 3d;f yxvd;'" xrov:.,yc.T 6il;i' *iVx 9 " T .J .'' i i"V ':• i". X J>> O ;I ^ffrfrr.^: 3 ".v '•'.' f f j 71 rJ d 3C" V& f: 1 9 d ; j - 9'X 0 1 . ' 3 d d a d r : i I'd",Brf"?. 3 | •^.'••^ :dv:d' R3 9n.r-r-j.fJ •y;.i:?.'o 3 Mirlo'ic o°.rf s e o d "Ml i j'oa "!,*o.-i .u v rrxti/.';o .!r,.yj, I c s tsi:f!i.t t.'ulc1' o t 'J Li 1 ! , * '! i • ! ;id" dl .baXJ'o :>• r:-, :M u h •s.r/.r.o'.-d n o i ^ / I o n c o CJJ do &:':.n:I .a- -X t"'', L- r> 3 x • id 3 •. i 'i-- j' o •;! ill . r.voi*j'".oi.rp h ?. nc-ioci^up vXiio a d t iii ja\t a(:i3^s 31 ;s/icT:9 3oH . dd . rrox:'.?o.rjp YS^OI.3S[; 3d "J" ^ ' o n d I .;j.o,;t ifj- .byotiO'xaj-ni 3on si h x n c c ai;lT :.ddjoO .!.:' i !i • &8L', r >':^o ^:it r,x;-r'cd" a.bj:j :t 111 .-^ Yfrf ®j: ^fi'T : I . s n t a 3 3 o ^ . -iM gfiixxiii 3*i->w ;e:ij' s l i d ? / aiadJ- 3VX5.b Is^bVi-s drisqa I . :r.r-dv; sir; dad-;,f.> dn:.3 ^m o t n.t s l q o a q t n s s e i x.£d S^LGO . ai&dd* .blou I Jbn.B OTzd$ so cut •'8 £ a s rrs ^ i-.dt o '.a/o\r :s:<rods "roH : b J!uoO . Lid'' . rr Yod B t n.^. na it s r j• :> o v..••:!. I : I B.rf d* i i e- B aB TT-I iuedt moTt Boiily'Icmoo v a s5 JJJ J C 7 vftri'.t cr'r S V ?:: T-T • f"> JJOTJ .-id d- do .bc;iixjnrii I iDytno-i I 9-io'i eS. :Isri^neao)i . 1' . iI.C I .YT'iscx'xr 5?,i7:xrcior II iljj • I1. • , ^ Jill .oft . 1 :lj3dJa9?3o£ . TM I ii •'Jalo woK t o x ^ i o J . . ' i d .3^.-3 ;:,-iuGv LrffjO'ii; yfiigx3;:Lf: I :I,3ffcrn3ao)'{ . -x\I �11 4 , M^v^ofat^s.Do; you/knotr; about hofc many children are next door $o the nbrth? ttt.'Hb^e^fcty&i;"tJFo. I do, not. W - ^ ? ^ ! v , f b e ^ l ^ i n g adjoining yours i s used entirely , for/ r e s i d e n t i a l pur&oses,s i s i t ? Mr:.;ftos^nthaXi. $oV entirely. I think a l l along there i s a l l ^frfirr^tovth^.g^fiimd filter.'"*** . * " ; Mr:;t*ouidrWhat feind*of s t o r e i s next? ; .Mr. Rosenthal:, tbere is grocery to the south and I think B ' "\a/!bPiior to ,the nortiu I ' l *•< 1 » «rtr< 4 . -" #3?;/J*&1k^ in, back of, the tailor shop ,^&£L %e*agroundlioor? , \s: •. . M,.i< ' * ' ' .v v - '^-fei^Qoiaids Anything "else?' , ^ jj|$JB$4#^^ [ ' 1 ^ A ^ r ^ i b s e n t h ^ f a ^ t b n : 1 ^ 1&ow; r, ^ '-• aB & * he u \ . > •4 \«'.'.,' :•& county ';$eelth I&Bpe&toz. '^,:^'M>.11 leiolSLing.ei': '' ' . t e e t I^went.- the^e'^ t i r s t , ^fchere was?duite a, ' -^i^mm^adk '^M^M^X!^^%'\^(m%P^tltmpi, s'.report itStteet tttfere 'are. ' ; :; "• �TO IOd Ih-io \ooon TdOOO.: .CO! CO < .01 o d i ' 0 3" 'K'O.b CLOOCOO &(.:ii :u-v .:,oooicc.oo ; c c o £ C / d jr.iT . 0. :.bXi;oX; .%',: V o.:. H i: , a o o oo OUT: r,~: j - r - c > i ^ ^ x -io 1 13 :>;ir.c:Iri- 1 c f l o c o / w «v,H :X.odrna8oH . i :> .;.: y u o t o or ?i: ooOuO Xo Xici:*! ood'" : oX.ooO .'id I .boo i!.o;:^8 od oo VTS0013 0' -.-lotfT : dod;; 0:33o,-i. c d ' . dei'ion s;I:!' GO* a:odX^d S CO'.'19 'LOLiS'S OCKf dood .ni o v l o BuvnoooX C>CI :ooasdo.sd . iM YoooXX bm;o'ij;. :;oio no , ooofoi cf'fcob I :l,Q.duo:3BoH .•£>•' ^'3Bio ;:;oiid£"roA :oX.tro£} . . *x"t: <\t . ooXo •-Tiiifd*oT'I i l o r i u i i e s o ^ ciM TOo 0 V 9 3 l s s u e vrxA : oI;;o€ .ill 0 Xfjoll vjiijjoD od^ dao cd" 3ifX X-Xiow X c^rds'IorM^ . iM . so.oXo sild" de-tQsqoni ed won ft w. i! # 3 OTIUO 3 S l " 3'XOild" ^BlX'l S'l^flu oTi9W X a^iff ' T6£f? >.:fO X s d . iM odd .qi/ l"/.-:.-rilr>3lo dor i^od' X I>n.o e"Xo:U onoXocf coa X,xX) ogrcniu H O I .Xodioo1; Xodoui .0 "^ILsjuifos e i uov M o * iioiT.eS ed/ so 30-Blq .won orcioi: *i: oaob-: g n o r ; gfridX^no; Xcodi 0-000,30 I o i uT003'r a'ood-o^oooX £.ai.bi".£xra. .;olo o; Si'?1, g n i X) T o 0 0 A. ;o T.O 'i o J . -iLi 6*r_o .-.ocfu" do^o'cjc; ^ b r ^ I X i 0 C dOX us X/iomXI.SC/J edit a i doodd* avroria •oia;d; oiotouyoA .no'ioXiiio on^it: wcof o-oioi don ob X . B.8iXid\i,si OX 0000 TX-SX: td^X'i: O O I M O S T aelX.co3'i OX saodsr al .ooocMirfo OS ox$ hapj :Io..".ci nx is jr. ^0X0; ooxhXioo odd y ood.w cfe^o.a: ^•i-j'lx/ocr odJ- 00 OT:,dir Tooooi: j'oiio- 'io sons*J"3.CX3 arid" Y-ss ^ o ^ X>Xi/ow t a h i . o o drio'ii Vaoo/tXido 9aodo "to do Is 3d ;xlX 00 d-ool'is ^rtjs avjsd XiXxjow �v„,' .'I' l ^ ^ ^ l l e i e l i i i g ^ J fefy$W4fr | . e & h ' s e e . S?he only thing the '"oblidr^kilrl^i -tteaxC f $ l i , M^p^dbabl^ a oackle of a- rooster, or hefc> otits^de of, g e t t i n g t h e odor of ohickens which you catmot > - eliiftinBl^Jid ^ a t t e ^ h o w am^h' d i s i n f e c t a n t you use* ^^jor*. ',ifcftia,^V-Cli^A^*^if01 OlftlaGpi&jatjanls. > b u l d you use? vd<5 Jyou make "for "reraoVal of refuse? ;ij*V'4^. I'-beMe^ I ' ; b e ^ e ^ you.t you.have", garbage <c611ected \{n^.Skkit^l^W'A ' r ^wi^;a'^wee^ o^/jhtle'ibiia^s £,week. 8fci Paget'.fou: ' i d ' ^ o t allow; i ^ V t o . b e abound there twice a week. ',V^f :S i|^iill:i|^r , * , '. #V,^@mjaja<.gfigLVaxii2iecl garbage can with t i g h t l y - cans with cw �.:,.•;...'• ;;,r:i,{j- Y-.rc.-o ;-;dT . ooa n.GO 1 -t^xicf ooti : a;3§iii:dQ.L9M .-x7-: -v lio 3.r:-lo.r,o .3 vro^do'K T/j:;• xoX d'o, xi,-o IJCV x'.oy.i'sr g.a-3;.;oiu"o TO ed LCxv/ x;>ori 111x7 noxbXmo xobc ?rid- ;gxtx:kdX: 'io .oMalrxo .3'Xu i J / v •J-u.yoO^lii.rsi.f.' xion'fiT 770 a i8d d\BK\ oa Suxuixntxfs V^r.x; u:--v Mx/ovr JIX/SSTIS xxi.tsx.fc CKH^ d?o dV" . H ,0 trioXXuM . iM :TOgriidoIsM . TK ?:uij?.: i o .Drv-omi)'3. i o ' i a;xGfa ix'^r oh rioxaxvoxq 3 JSclw : . 9 § s H ,'JseT w .?. i;oi•••••j 5 ' i r u t ijiiuo'i.^ yd o-i . il£ .Q sernxd" a&irio" TO ieevv B soxwd" j i ^ollo xon ob uoY : 9g.^rl . tM '.ii-;..i^i7 i"l;jjc:.jr rxso e^.30T3g XJSSXKSVXSXJ Jbn.r!ifi?eJD eF ^xrgfiXfioXsd . 3'X*)VOO , 1"" sui^il III '-,• rid- !• inxo b-:>sxa.KvIs£ ,-> 1T ?.->.f>:?:Xo j'\f-:i tdrigit 9 c *sad" i xiA iisgxxxxioXsM xxsgniscCaM uoeqani I .iM . Tavoo BXixdXxi drlgicr V *xormvu.'B fii a s x X i "io 9 3-RO xrx oij X/OY OIJ tedF :xxoXIxxM . iM .;. Ixx/ti x l x ix.:. ^iilxiaoo v i s v S .OIJV:3 . .banes I O S s i s ^erlT i i s g n i d o l s ^ - . iM .n.^o-io* YY.O3:1 ,E <arie&'X03 owj- ii^±^ x j s n s s i o a Yltfrijsxd" ax -gal n\r~ jjoxlqi-ioo xt9 ed ax:i d".t £mx5 s.boo *xx;o fii ax d\sxIT . n s o i o s s v x l -:o XIJOX eiorlu xxnta d"x i i yjaa Q$ its SKI XXOY OQ : .rtoLasrl od" si/ox Tutrix ton sxrxa: B 9'<§X3ci' . TM ax d"i 3Y.sb . ecf JonfiBO d"I :iognxriol9M ,'i'* !l IV -• v:.t saxx'is'i ~xxu dxrq od" i ^ v o o 9xicr svofflsa: x/oY .tagx^ . xK ft:. I'll t .YXsiixS : isgnxrioXsL! . xl'i .10-bo i o drixjcxis nx£;ta:so . s a x sxexiT f , 5 r"'.'i m\ c. u ox TIT (lax 9iom -3d ibXi/ov-r xBdd" s v s i X a d j-on' oJb I 3;jo^9'£;x:cJ"j 9'iom ax XBX'IO »XIT '.noXIuM . I'M : are^nxxlolsM . iM . a n s ^ o i i l o 9xij- mox'i a i o b o arid" xxsxid- .fioexoc; ax d~x X n l l o scid" xio ad-jg Y X I S 11 .aaxj'iS'X sxid" rxrjxid- �$ r \ Mulloxu I t IS m MS^kelqMnge'r'jt ,')tt; MUIIOB: odor/ The^e i s an odor if i t i s exposed. demoting the cover you get a c e r t a i n amount of odor accumulated i n t h e "barrel. &r. Melehingetff There i s where the-C. H. corses i n . Mr.'*Mullotv: t h e r e w i l l be a c e r t a i n 'amount of' A odor? J r . Melchinger}; Je e ; A c e r t ain - amount,. *J, . ' l i l r . ^ U l d i :H0w >a&o'ut;the attrac^ioibi of vermin from these things? AreVthey apt to bring r a t s ' and mice and, bugs? Mr.'Mei'cingerVlo, riot unless the market i s absolutely f i l t h y . ' If ; the ritar&i ; i s clSan and nothing, lying around, no o f f a l lying to death 1 if i t should get into.' , v p x i * ^ ^ ^ s V ^ a : . ' f : Wh^te there' i s . a Hole* we e i t h e r have ' , : 7'ak t ^ ^ kind * ^ > j ^ i g b i & e r : , | f t & 'twice,.a" we*',.or twi.be"a month." -", ! ^ ^ i W t o e . a:;week'. o? ; twice l,a montb? ,. ^ 4 ^ < ^ ^ M B % ' ' . t t A ^ R i f c k . i M , ;/dro^.,linv : ".'t ", ** ,V /*., ;i a m ^ t e - n e i g h ^ a r h o o d I may ' » / ; ' ' ' ' * . <•< - '' , . _ _ /' . , ' j r , + ' I R simnlv •'' M>.'-*i 3 ?&'>£r,£L': r ^ W ^> |,*\^a>-'?^*saii-*i. ^ r ^ A ^ ;.^ *XJ aa-'i^ w ? - I ti«« , i s• .T simply «,« f a matter px> ( f -W* 4 ' /""it ) 'ft- ' , \ l \ 4 * i i -r t . *• j»c> # *: %^ .'* * ^ ' *"" -h live ' :• , ' .-"J" * r i* M �si: !f I' . i.o.ho n.G ax cixT : i:ox.Cc"' . xx; ,i;;v..oo:,.:: x '•. .;.;: i i x~ :'H:> xx; ••! oi.;n]T : x q ^ i i i o X a i ! . X' 1 u , ll • ;--•;- \ p oXfxrxxx.x ^Xxx •::•'•• o x; ^ ;. r x v xxvoo 3d-t xx ivonxjR :noLCxril . x ' . Xe'xxxd xd;r x:i Ibste Xurnxxoxx . o:x .?,9jv-;oo . x . 0 arid- --a: ±' x.i sx:v Me^xxicIoXsM . iV '•xo.xo is xo Jiujorv". /•xi.oiT.r.-o s C-JU XXivr 3'ieriT ;xioIXxix , x'x" . iJ- ex/o rvf,;? J. ' i x> x Xi o A • ax Y : i s 30 £ ;x o X s M .. 1 1 •'. 0'•• 9.'iJ' L;OA) xxiraxx/ 10 r/oiioxn,; ::x5 su3 xuocx; 'r*oR :x>Xi.ro-D . xli -"axixci .bxxx ooixi iinr, aixrx ^ I X T O .03 0 q,s veiii s i A > s>";i 1..trf«")" , <>xxxxii ',^sc;-..uXo';u>> PJ: OZJIIW, II' sad* aaaXm/ "ion <o!i i-iX'gaioXexi . T l '^f-.-'VX x , x ~ x o o n rIi£iJjo:cj^ oni^X %xxiu;jox Lutx-. roxxXo a i oeoriBHi xriu- ii oJarx J-e,•_-. .bixfxda rj-JL i i .cit.se .b otf ^vxjsJrs nnoa XXrx ixsxc .s tib^x-oxs 18 ;y ax^iixxx.0 Xxo .bnx> doxxd bus x x x x i loti^ 3 0 - SY-STrXs S>W . ao.xXq s i d i e v - u -iaaD-.ro :•:••••' -Xod x> ex xx:xi:i- ~-£3xlW . b s n i e i o 3 YXidxji;j' a i s : o SOJX.XXXO oXciaaoc-; oxx a i o i 5 d i oa qss I ; s x i i TO Xairx^neo I Fit jjxxxi TXX xo x - b 'xo d'.oo JS uX;xx;c i o n oJb sYJ •A .rxi gniudoig nirxx:v . YJxtxxxriOO o d i ic di.Ls^d oiij i o e x o i q o i so xXq tuli rxi • LsniiiLR 10 \* Tsnoiiosqeixx a:x:,rx JJOY oi) x i s i i o WQK "rioXXxxxl . xH •14 S H1 < . iid'i..ou." s o o i x x 10 xxixxr 3 o o i w i scfY^M :'legaixioXsM • rfoj-xor:; .3 s a r x ! ' xo doaw ,6 eoi'^d' j*i a i eiwz ! 7 xsx! I Loo:!'!: f i . i ^ i i r -xri:r n i rns I i i abxiscoh i i s aA :.uOXixiK .ry--v I i N ' Si ii 1 8X'XXIipi;X: 7TZL ?a'j t SCI Co fISCjGiJxi ijOY T.VSISri^ 'xo •x^Jux>ni ;J. ^Xqr-iic ?,i j-J .v/^I en a i eixrfT . TM TM : is^ixinoXaH . TM . r.z HI! ii IfXOiXi/H co'ih . xx: :TagniiloXeH . a:M . xv=vo o i ^.rxi>IooX bxi.s siurid' gxxiujsg "sviX x'xxi,.i:oxr> •.-,.id' uioi'x xei'iix; i a ^ i ^ x i ^XJ'XUOCAB asoi) WQH ibluoi) '.ill TarioiXBXxixjo*! tiilstd ad"i n i d"92fix5Hi O-XJ^CS io}I'X.;3i]i loeni xx.-xx,xx)xo e-cfj x:i sv^ii u x ^ Y X X B I U X ^ T : isxjnixioXaM . x'/. wf; •3fio ^d ijx^o.a, JXII.6 X3IJ:S^XO Y-o^&'.rXx* no:Ioiric boXIirio x} s v ^ d ;JOV �.meat pagke^ tofc^oMdfccta packer. » e only tiling you would gefW^lo-f thlfe >#Pul& be-, t h e odor of i n t e s t i n e s when the o h i o ^ i s ' ^ ^ 1 ' " ih6se i n t e s t i n e s are j u s t as dangerous a s , t A i n t e s t i n e s Q? > & l ^ e chicken. The aid at' market uses - , ^ ' t t & ' t M r p i » B M J l T a ^ by oui cide With the l i v e chicken market, ' -an&'&ou Kave-tW:>#^ odor'aV you would have in a l i v e chicken' maxMtV W on% J ^ f e f e n c * t^^oix,hkve the odor of refuse of the Mr.Vfld?4£t f h e r ^ l r " s u b s t a n t i a l l y the same 4he.,te<iina3?y;meat, market. ' '^<i\,trt#ic^ng^;l^^"bly. j ^ ' * ~ /""•'' ^wf1 w i* ***'< <'"( ? ~ * '^ i"^ the same as • ; . (< . :i '/last ^ o ^ < 3 # ' * # - > r : ^ " b o W under your. Jurisdiction,., ' " S ^ ^ ? ^ - ^ f f i - > ^ > r a b b i t s and' chickens, and putting in' the p n e - b a r r e l . before the Venues pf the chicken pt" t h e chicken If the aro$»d v .' �XI to.uo :;Ti« aci" bJL;;;0'V .t.'">iio" 'io i x o .toj? xxs.'nxr .-r xxn xx,.;. J x-xxti: •:.>••?etiT ..•nT -:;.'ij xtoxoiuo ji? XXDO . jxxxxx x i ua^oiao xxnl ,••; 'io x-xxrxx;?-:• r xi.x s/j 'xxc ^:i 53U.XXDXXX: -.:•.'. n.ec s.rlit xui .'.}Jx:.;;v; X'"X x.~ *xxo yix«B ^s* -mxi XJXY JXJX ixxxxxViiii; 'l~±.no eaT . rhxl'Tx;:: . 5v i Ix 91 ..£ii?T n3 ;xotiio xx:xT -ihL'JoD xiM x x x x x x J'.f-'.:s rr; vxxxxxaio edu . v Itfo .Q z E i x 6 xx i rI c 13;,: ,xT ~ xicx^oxbxrxx;!; uxox ixb.au adxd ex-' voriT . 83Y :LJifoO .'ix :T6g.Qi£L0lG::L .11' ^ n i j o x c .-ofr.fi ^xxxcxxr:; .brio a x i j c l x x t t s f e i ^ f i i l l i : ^ Y& : S&.S^ . I M . IsTXocf 9xo oiler ax Korid' xo o^o moiiu 'io e x i / I s T 3d$ naxioic'o 3:xx xo sxrxxxr xid-' a i o x x f . u i ^ s I aA . o l "ii nExoixlo earl- xo .fex'io ^dJ mixxxo. gw.'-'Yl tfxsl '"X::Oo b.nx ^'t^rij 3X;Ojx?3X':>.b n ; ; v si* 2X;OT asilx xia .^x,xr; s s ILsii 3" on 31 rissa" a.-irl 10 nus odd"- o.l 9cf 0$ aeqqsci risgnirfoIeM. ftosoqxs xl BX LBIXO . jo^: "oj-d-ral bris ed M'.ov? j-j: I&'J; io' nsd-tcvi srid- acix^ t o s j n o o ni ,:lfx^ a'vaViCf .5 10 s s ^ l g .3 no 3-0& v l i x &rtt 11 •OKIXO JXLOO VIOYS tisxxx^ BA6'ii.3d ed:)' bxiX ;^od 3'xixpOT sW .-5odX:3w SIR BTA rnoIIx/M xilu vo-jT : • l a g n i u o l e ^ . 1"" 7 Ou i x c x o rJ. dx^X'X; -xxd'ljjoq a v i l \rax73 n i ia;J,sw Qriif.ifixrx -ixijx ix-xxx -^LJI'ML'S. x x : s u e Li;riT' t j"i a-3.nl!. teu'i ~,-fU" r.i; -loetxr-' uxr: ^Id'su o*ioti$ o i s.io- 3':iix;p3'i r.;ov o.b £ n o £ v.r0H ttfC.xixrM xxM VBi^S^O-BCf XIi;3f ^ n o l nA. ,j3.ii':Jo^d ^d;i" I X x i Hi.?/ *xscr.sw ^ori Y ^ oj :<XQ§nicloIoM . iM �• 15 ' ( Mir* Mullon: I© I t t r u e some w i l l l i v e 15 minutes? Ht; MeXcbingers; I have t o have, a s c i e n t i s t . Hot water w i l l destroy immediately a few m i l l i o n . 1 do not believe you w i l l f i n d many madteria i n the o f i a l of fresh k i l l e d chickens, u n l e s s i t i s ex#o.sed t o t h e sun. Ur. - liuiiori: I s t h e r e a c e r t a i n amount of vermin and l i c e ? . Mr. lUelbhiiiger:, A ^chicken w i i r carry l i c e . ^ f i V ^ l i o n r V ^ i l l ' i t carry germs and g e t on a young child or sWethiiig?'" *): " s , • •' . i r . ^ e l o h i a g e t i ' ^ h i . c k e n l i c e has never been known t o stay on '^ a^hvtmaxi: beitig,. * ^ '.,. . , ' .'..jfe'^.MblcSitiieri'^lka-chilli plays with a chicken l i c e , w i l l ,.;. ( Hi.^Mliiip^ 4 | ^ : A : * , ^ a n s m i t disease? (4 '," * , "'''^ifatt^ b e l i e y e ' : l i c e w i l l stay on a diseased / •*.*'-> .', / * / . '"V' ' ' J* ^M «-' i ' .'*• " ' V * ' ^ * ' " , . ' O , '< '• • V ^ . ^ ^ o - ^ ^ ' ^ f i ^ *i*i%e sanW oode of We.t<fc«*tta . ^ , ''•. '''!^::^J'^-^f'^^^ 1 ^<^i^:r±V^rihaD. a main tnorougnfare> in' . ' : ^ S ^ i ^ £ ; ^ ^ ^ ^ d ; ^ , ^ r . ^ t a i n , ,..*<» or. side', . -" .: �v:.r XX rv a fives Xi a I :noXIj..'M . " 1 , SUT-T .; o . ;•. •:v.n •.; o.t =*-7/>ii I :T3; ; r,J:aole!'i . i d 7. , r••••••) 1 i i.r;i; r V i .•;.; v.;.rc-r/'.>..:':::.-rfrrP .;..!.••:'.;.'. .. Vc X.rdir ?..-/{o ni: niic-to/;!!- (iiGf;- Xirddi . > i" r ;- -v." ,v..' , xar?. :• a X oX X> o a cq *:. 3 I- ! X'X . O i L - ;;'/:'!;•;£'•'•V \TO7.X^3,J y;f: ::.-r:^ n i ^ d i ^ o ^ oz:,ti<t al X< soil '/-.c yy-.o [.Ci:v X:,c.; d>.:a ar.'toi fi^jcirio p i X i a••? s Xi'.;ir I'TOdidd/ . xd A iiegnidoXcdl .'id' v'fino X1 XXrW in.olXuyl v i 1 •VM: K/.J -soil rraj-Ioi.-fO :'sy'idv ^eoe :'is^KidoX^X . iv , Xi no j-iigxi v;3dX i.c :• tj& :noLLull OI.L .ri'£0.;.C J.T'C .::• dvd- ?,\M"J:g- XXido .3 XI . "\^?frr?? efoix XXxw . T';: . rcV :^MiMo.CsM . iM XIJU o i ao Xrisil i .&'6,v.:'?;.ih Xl!^rxv;'x;t J- i: .f XJCV?" rnoXXx/K .'f M L* i:.r:±T- c c i i :i:H' ay•>i.uci .ion ob I iie^aidolsli .-zY. :u • O r=.-;O0 ;i.sXl:.;r:^ 'jfiw d;j-xw XG£Xif,;BX s x s iroY j o x s ' i o d . 3?.-'. iYXiiLfoO . aeY : i••:>^ai£f o X a M . iM >i.i.i; r-i'iclv.s'j: \J OX e-3 3Lr r'lo'i/xx • :? a^.j:.: se^jf.Xiv X:J«'0 . ai".,-JEd"oi:'io5aa :»'! ••-/!. if,;. -;;-j ni^m ^ f£oqjj Xi I/OY .^XJJOO XO :OT.S'IOJ . IM 3Xe>di^m vlj-Ix/oc. ervil OXB STCMIT : itgnxdoXsM .-xM Xiiniac vsrlX oQ. :oi.Giod . *xM c ' sxi-1 .BI^C s X i n F • o';::.').(.i-y UX>;;T( io jbJ::.; ow <;ydX yvsIXecT Xon oJb I : ' l e g n x d o l a ^ . I ' d 11 . tf3S'xXa iX'::0:i'X rW; SoOtfu" d'Xfvi'c't' 8'.i.'XXo TO S i ' g . F ' X X i V 'larfXo o Q : 0*13 IO«I . l i t �16 t0 open'Up .in congested neighboxhoods whexe there are many families and obildren? ,. Mr. i e i c h i n | e i : - - *e 5OT9. Pleasaatville, very proud of Itself, baBa.Very fine'neighborhood, tfrey have a chicken . oJ1 market the mai» thoroughfare, and I'Relieve there is a buil&ing, - t f , W 8 e , / i . l g n t . p t e t , t h e chicken market. Permit hae been .grante*'• t o ^ l a ' i » n ; W ' t o e : > i l i a ? e boardjon Marble Avenue, PleasantTtile, ' t & V ' l s ' a ' o h i o k e n ' market abdut ^.half block;off,the main t h b r o ^ a x e V / t h e . o m e r and-three other t e n a n t l i v e right ' • ,, *bo*e! t h a t ' i 9 ' P l e 4 ^ ^ i l l e - '* C O t t l d m e n ^ o n 0 l * e " , ^ W i 0 h ^ i ^ i ' S e u i n g a.petmit;do ; yau 3 usi issue I t with-., • ' ^ ^ - / • ^ C h ' i n g e x J ^ V d o . n o t inqui^fxom,the zoning board • ^ f a ^ V own&r i % : 0 *%% « - » *°%go ^ e a a . l t J i , » to • t h e ^ .;-#^W*te/app4^Vwheth^necanopen;brn6t:.. P».... ^ • ^ . j K ^ ^ V l ' l ' ^ - ^ - w ^ * , ^ k . • the-zoning boa,rd."and health; board,. *** i '& �1 ""f rrj.;. r ri;Mi'sr- .oo;ix;oox"o fo: q.f." ixo; o XOOOL 3 V.r;*y'•:.•:• J.cu'.') err," ae.LCl; •-, f ;• - r,< j \:P i • o a :: { %V::£f.£0 I OfO> rci."::'! t i'.'.' r-o , 3 £ 3 i d ^ J J C XOiio o .•;•;{v.. -.Mi noo o i d o a dil" i •, vo urf£• i: X ' ,. s 3 .uoii o CiSeo 7 v .1 r.-5 :i .:• •.';.!. °. ".r D 0 O ;i"I • 0 n o X 0J.'.. -J :>. . 'Xr.i'0)V A £•' .L.C X 3 l . ••i n o ; o< :< '-AT- .'• r .10' 70 n.3hi rii.^r... x.;v i i o :£:>•-. j."o "il-'Vi o u.a.'xi'o X;o/xoo r.:e;'o.I':io o oi oxoud' i .yr.vvii" OY.LI ?.*?:: }L\t>? v rf-to x x x i x .oxo \ x x f o --IT . ex;'-ldoxo voriu" .aioiir:^ rj"o.r:;'/ie;: i x x o o I .e .riivu rii>a,r-'.3f':1 ai. xxaT . evr.-o,c t !;• -;:i\t.(;••• ;i'"^ aox-.x. iixxr x o o oh ;f i x m x ,«:, ^.;.c:iir-^.i: n l V:^I,J:J;IO3! id ID 9c>n/.:x:J:Jb'.:o o^iilliv rnoLLc-Al . iM i>d& oxxtliooxoo ra;o .bxxoo ^.iiixioa - r x uo'.i;'i sxixroixi. ;rox oh sV? : x..x : xi.dofoK I . ill i f ! XXJXO {( ) vxxi? 1 i' if'> jfl 0:.iu o;) qu ai: u I . x x o u B O^ or usd? i c l X 0 a i ai i~doed\7 If . o cui r x c o :!>:' ox oxruorr-f TO fs5ilqcx onxr ITBIO ^ri^ ic 1,! ooxf rixr.xsrl fmo jjl ! !"' * JXCSOO' ofxrios edii SaiOO X'X 3 HO 7XX :IXXX WF'IJ :[f-M, + n Oh -JOY 'JUO i:;i n'sxoiflo ja nec-o rues SJUB L JCL^ ::O drrs'isi'iiJo oxi' ea's £iXEX:T 0$ 2-.nJ.X1o ifiS I HI n.r,.r ih'::.o t xxxru>3oi rroi^ot-'-a vno ai : ii $i-6Ldoio :i70lIX/H . Y-(-;Q^ OJ ^n^s W,BI S:> 9i.I(v;^oo ^ri a.;; ^ n o l a,;; :!•./; Si.'8£i d"ax/(; ;j"oY . n o i c r q l i o s s l i • 1 -'>,:;-.^'.•;•; .rV-^lxiv ; c »a'J" o« ^.D,Q3 o^ ov.stl vsaT LTJV C^ si aiorfrf- YHJS :'ii-;^xiia'oIs-^ 'io ,iv .. i"f»2tii:ifa a qx; xrsqo HBO ^ U ? 'it tits tin 1 1 l OLI.-! | . 70£. -TX) -?r.:)0i) &d ±z -isn$slim i :1-J^ t o n oh uoY :-ioII"i.fM . -xM ocr .;.•;..; oj' ai.« }ic^ \;tiriD". s&iiiicr,v*:;oS .o.b avr ac/K'iiu^iacc; :noIIirM . xM i £f rrr I 7,-d:.i:ua^Viii X3li%i:r .3 JOLGK QX! .dxo .bnxl Jbrr.G JJX>OQ .o\^iicr oij s^ u i b-xijjpe'o: Y i ! 11 r I. 6 grrinos srf^ ^ 'ii ..o3'.ril 'i3a.«o e i a j - x.i' oi;:;x1;i e^w noxf^gju 3t»vni of! :noIIx/I\) . xF .9>J33lv;or£;:' ynr od" dx>!^ : ^ 6 ; s n i d o I t ) ^ . 1 : ' < �A 17 • m^::i^i!Ai.yM^4 you anything to say, Mf. MacHahon? IlirV Maila^^x;,, If ycu ifeat some of the residents to come here • ' > ' w u i ^ l i k e to„ttfc« an adjourned hearing to get them here - i f - i t ' l i ^ c ^ ^ y , to tave them t e s t i f y / I cannot see what thfeyUsa testify, to .except they live in the neighborhood • Qf : ' & e ' i i w ^ l f W * * & t and they do not want i t . That i s el} • , /*.%t||Kwiil^|V ; Tliey are,very; f loath to cpm<e> some of them,, , , ' ' $ ^ 8 6 t l ^ ; s & r t e n a a t e , 1 " B W ;O* .them, i i ! ' . ' s ^ w f ^ » e f e m a ' to'me that' if, the matter , is really important t o ^ ' t h e y f ^ t ' , ^ *» f i l i n g to come here and appear in :. t h ^ l ^ ' ^ ^ V ^ , 8 * ?..-', •'":,-' ' '"."'' \ ' ^ i i & h ^ ^ | t ' ^ " ^ . i 8 , ''" , ^ t h e aelghT?arh<x,d gets r <% and taking Kfc& ^ L •' J ** �ml VV U A0* 3PNEY SOB"! J. 1 II B'l I' i i # HfeM tt �A0f?AM NEY N. SADOFSKY l'» AND COUNSELLOR AT LAW NATIONAL BANK BUILDING "NORTH TARRYTOWN. N. Y. TELEPHONE 1219 June 4th, 1933. To the Zoning Board of Appeals, Village of North Tarrytown, Hew York. Pursuant to a communication from Mr. John J. Lofaro, your Secretary, under date of April 36, 1932, which letter in substance refers to the matter of wRed Gables" being an open matter and also requesting my attendance at your next meeting on May 19, 1933, and further to advise your Board as to the disposition of same and with reference to the enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance. I have examined into the Minutes of the meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals of North Tarrytown, held on the 24th day of September, 1931, at which meeting all the members of the Zoning Board were present. In 1925 the property known as "Red Gable8* was purchased by Mrs. Ula Bass. Subsequent thereto and in February, 1928 without submitting any plans showing probable changes, a building permit was requested from the building inspector in office at that time. A permit was issued by said building inspect- or and three or four days thereafter the building inspector discovered that he was in error, revoked the permit and demanded its return. Thereafter in March, 1928, the building inspector wrote the owner, Mrs. Ula Bass that the proposed changes were contrary to the Law and again requested the return of the permit* The permit has never been returned. Several months later in �A'ti) 'n > 'if ' n— to*** Mill' I ." I 1 bi !l 9 it I s ! Hi \\ ;ER, 1 I I ;! II j § \i i m if 'iiii Mil �AgRAM N. SADOFSKY ;>3' Ey AND COUNSELLOR AT LAW ° St NATIONAL BANK BUILDING ' MORTH TARRYTOWN. N . Y . TELEPHONE 1218 -2~ To the Zoning Board of Appeals June 4, 1932. July, 1928, the same owner, Mrs. Ula Bass, made a building and loan agreement with the Railroad Cooperative Building & Loan Association for the purpose of financing changes which were started that month and which altered the house into an eight family apartment house—a type of construction and use prohibited in residence District A. Subsequently the property was used as an eight family apartment. On September 15th, 1931, a Public Hearing with re- spect to this violation was held after the new owners, the Railroad Cooperative Building & Loan Association were duly notified that a Hearing would be held on said date. Said new owners did not appear at said Public Hearing held on September 15th, 1931. Under Section 10 of the Zoning Ordinance it is provided as follows: "••...The Inspector of buildings shall enforce this ordinance under the Rules and Regulations of the Board of Appeals. * Under Section 11 it is provided as follows: "•....The Building Inspector, Board of Appeals and the Board of Trustees of the Village, or either, shall have the right to enforce the provisions of this ordinance by injunction and for other equitable relief." Under Section 17 of the Zoning Ordinance, it is provided as follows: « VIOLATIONS and PENALTIES For any and every violation of the provisions of this �^ » M I i !!'!: U .tV m i,m i •II * •:IK-; 'Far If If u 'I 0(1 A0 F �A0RAM NEY 0T N. SADOFSKY A N D COUNSELLOR AT /*?• LAW RATIONAL B A N K B U I L D I N G ' (SJORTH T A R R Y T O W N , N . Y. TELEPHONE 1 2 1 8 •JeTo the Zoning Board of Appeals june 4, 1933, Ordinance, the owner, agent, contractor, or other person interested as lessee, tenant or otherwise in any building or premises where such violation has been committed or shall exist, and who refuses to abate said violation within five days after written notice has been served upon him, either by mail or personal service, shall for each and every day that such violation continues be subject to a fine of twenty-five dollars and the collection thereof shall be prosecuted in the manner prescribed by Law or Ordinance effective in the Village of North Tarrytown." I am of the opinion that the injunction referred to would not be granted unless the act sought to be restrained is a nuisance. There is abundant authority for this opinion. The mere prohibition against the use of HRed Gables0 premises as an eight family apartment house does not make that a nuisance, which otherwise is not a nuisance* Courts will not undertake to restrain an act which violates a municipal ordinance unless the act is a nuisanoe. The remedies for enforcement of ordinances and penalties in case of violation thereof are exclusive and are to be strictly construed. In order to obtain an injunction as contem- plated by the Ordinance, it would be necessary for the Village of North Tarrytown to establish by a fair preponderance of evidence that a nuisance per se exists, and that in the case of a private individual, it would be necessary for him to show that damage or injury has been done or will done to his person or property. I am �k> T N A J HOB™ TE 11 \fa m M �A0RAM m N. SADOFSKY NEy AND COUNSELLOR AT LAW „ST NATIONAL BANK BUILDING ' floRTH TARRYTOWN, N . Y . TELEPHONE 1219 *4"~ therefore of the opinion that an injunction could not be obtained if application were made in the "Red Gables" case. Under Section 17 of the Zoning Ordinance, the remedy prescribed therein is a Civil remedy by action to recover the penalty prescribed. Under Section 49, Civil Practice Act, it is provided that an action upon a statute for a penalty where the action is given to the person aggrieved or to that person and the people of the State, it must be commenced within three years after the cause of action has accrued. I am therefore of the opinion that the time within which to act to enforce the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance in relation to nRed Gables11 has expired, and that under the Zoning Ordinance of the Village of North Tarrytown, the remedies provided therein were not availed of by the Village within the three year limitation prescribed under the Civil Practice ActJ Respectfully submitted,/\ Village Attorney. \J \s �EPHO I Tei-1 toWN W . ~J l" i;1 1! i. i t . : ! :;, :|-:l,'l >'j $ il ill |1 1i1 If MM wPKliI ,^ J^ �£f FOR THIRTY YEARS FOREMOST «N PURITY AND EXCELLENCE MOUNT PLEASANT BOTTLING WORKS CHAS. LUBERGER & SONS 101 VALLEY STREET NO. T A R R Y T O W N , N. Y. TELEPHONE 1285 gBYTOWN J*^ ^ -<Pc^er Z^c^f * \ * �© o m a T3 t3 •¥> S3 0 a c *0 © G3 3 3 fcO S3 «H P. (D CD AS © s © *3 to c o 3 O 03 1-1 £ 3 .Q P« © a o d to s « 9 s r-l H d o O o o m © © >» H •rl e « 3 o _*_ 1 �/•«• �,«# ,-M O J*i u o r>-t !=•> CD »=-< r-l U •5 CD SI <M tJ •H cd CO r-H 0) rH 73 -p«\ CD bO Pi •H CD CD U -P CO o PJ i^M ?> CD r^i +3 o CD • £ Pi O >> -P rM & 5M 5M CD Cd E-t o P^ 5M P-. T* fl CN2 LO >> -P 5M CD P. -P CO H •2 •S E-i CO M CT> IT) CO o -P Cd g H CO «*> CO •• CO P fe O o t>» cr) CO Xj f -Hi 1*1 o > • » cd* CO Q) CO O PJ o o -----rrr^^.- •H CO' t O L-H CO © ••a £ 9\ u o Pi ^ CD CD O 5M cd • UD cd CO C7> rH <+H O r*. rH CD rH Crf CD >> CD > Pi o CD rS CO -p * o CO H Pi T3 CD ^CO PM J-M TJ •H CM CO CD 13 •H to CD CD to -p c5 r<3 -p • «\ • r~* • H3» CO p< •H rH •H ^5 PM •P ecS CD o -P 3 o ,a cd <H O a •H -P 5M CD r^i o HP -P t> 5M -P o cd CD cd rH rH •«d *H CD TJ •H CS PH CD •Ti CD r-^i H J >•> id ® •H r\ CD hO U CD ,Q 3 •3 ?-. CD -p rH cd O o o •n c cd 'Cf CD CO 73 « ^ En •H S cd • u rO CD CD •H cd -p CO CO •H CD ^j -P H°. cd ^ -P • r» tSJ CD 2 a' •H TJ o • ^ 1^3 Cu u PH 'd •H (rf CO fn CD fcxO U • CD P^ & Q) £3 T5 !M rt p.. cd « o >> CD Si •P £j Co rQ CO 7i ,C u CD rH "XJ •H ^ -P CD ,-<M -P to $M CD TJ ?H cd o ,o o c cd o tn p to ?M o o rH «H C TJ CD ?M CD •H ^ tSJ CD 73 O4 «H XJ O CM .^1 • 5H ^ -P TJ fl cd cd •H Cu CO i HJ cd s\ - p ^ -p • H •' Pt I 3-:| ;«*^ 4* (D hO •«* s Pi B •H ; ! -P •5-i i> •H , 'cd rH P-. cd CD r•P.' cd. U ti? o< a) CO Pi ^ o u CO t3 CD CO 5M 73 •H ^i cd'; ^* FJ p CD t-, B hO Pi •H 5M 73 •r) T3 CD 5M .3- PM cd -P Pi TS C; CD rP T5 (0 CD 3 *A « cd U )?\ ^ ^•= H c5 CD s Pi. Pi •£'«• f3 P s- cd CD CO 5"" •p o o CD -P Cd rG CO •H •S'' Pi 73 S 0 T3 '. 01 -p •H •H s p O Pi CO ^i P! •H CD ' uo •H •H cd CD CO >> rO CD & CJ to CO Pi cd tJ r?» -P ' 4V > ' O-, •n 1 -* s cd Li 1 p ' £5 -P •D i-< P< CD f-i O O o ' •n o cd •H « cd W) J> tn Q) nrj-^ .3 •-cJ rQ ) i u r^"4 73 -p T* ' ! CO CO ?-. •xi ' PM •H ^P CO cd cd 'Tl CD CO •n s p O CD to cd J-. CO CD CO •rl r-t r -) .3 O is CD 1 CD DM Pi !>> pj -P o T3 to CD c; •H hO CD ' r-t •Tl ^d •H CD S o «\ !>» •P ^ Pi 2 •-a CO 3 £ < •n u n b 73 <3 o tt p-t ^ g ^ Wfp^ •p Pi 5M 'd CD CO 3 CD to PS O r3 >4 rH PJ •H CD CD ,Q «w 3 CO �m ,*• '"H ilOHAEL ijtlAH C Ik**8 F« A' �M3> VILLAGE OF NORTH TARRYTOWN, N. Y. BOARD OF TRUSTEES FRED W. G R O S S , MAYOR A R T H U R Q. F R E D E R I C K S , A C T I N G MAYOR ABRAM N. SADOFSKY HN EDWARD C V. CASSELL lOHAEL U A VILLAGE COUNSEL p. CARNEY J . COFFEY N C Q R A WAULAOE ME8 VILLAGE CLERK & T A X COLLECTOR MARION A. DEELY DEPUTY CLERK V E 8 0 N HUTCHINSON FRANK A. MARASOO VILLAGE TREASURER F . JOHNSTON JEROME N.LAWLOR VILLAGE ENGINEER TBU8TEE8 May 2 6 t h , 1932. Mr Walter Luberger Philpse Manor, N • X • My Dear Sir: I made an Inspection of your ^ e as revested, and . « £ t £ s ^ t c > » ^ ^ S ^ ! ^ ^ ^obits the enlargement ^ ^ ^ f ^ a n c e . W p l t e J o t o n ^ r o Secty fe^a^o^pSaxf W - ? P - s e n t the conditions. Very respectfully yours, V Building Inspector �^ 1., ;«• if � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_ZONING_1932-05-31 Subject The topic of the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1932 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Village of Sleepy Hollow All Rights Reserved. Type The nature or genre of the resource Text https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/3642b4c11077d3b3097ec0583277fa9c.pdf 3253cc115301fa283d273b47739c3eff PDF Text Text J*! & a ?ublio Hearing of the Zoning Beard of Appeals, 'held on the 7th i,' 1 day of June, 1932. h 1 K * '-presents CWraid f. GotilA, Chairraa^ pr John I . - % H o n David £age, J r . , , . . - •- Jonn *.• X*crfat<>, Secretary ^ _ ; i ^ x a ^ t . A'.* Saddfsky, t i l l a g e C 0 unsei >( ;;; .; s - " f • , ' " ' ';' \ f M e e i i n g was .called to 'order, a t 8 : 3 0 . ' ^ r • • • " " • " • - * - • ; ' fi„t he would Inquire whether • ',«**«» •*•*. *.., v,, , , .' +~ -h-ri-ne witnesses, • ' . " ^ ™ ^ k ^ i ^ ^ a « e s e n t to t e s t i f y , i n the c a s e . Ho ' .'???TT""- x,;. -\„ > - i " " -* * • ••: vJ * .-.wtr+ftW further to.say •;{•.-'• �[;j:n> H ' t > ' .d'J-V a-iu . £.\£X 9.:J.;L X'/ V-;: iXf* n; v: .to110 ! : ! . i 1 f b l a o £ . a .b I,nioO : .7115: j f j i;l i; oO 3^ •»i"xs d~ •:•< xo e c t o%n .L o J . L r i d e L . C x ;z \r f y jip, T 0Jb.'>8 .11 Hi xufo 'icf A i J ; [)'£:£ JY*. t^irxo i i. t-1 U!. 11 i/ofc.b.rs rx/v 3.o\7 s i d d ' : . J ! .!...,,; ;JC ..u- .'iju:j:u: J:.sIcntO0 ii o cis^- vir:ic r 5Ciii o 3ilu \toi cr^d;]- b9on«. onx;.r> aGmT.x^riO s d T v9n'iod"j\o add" i o d"3ox/pa'i s d i ,Be8. : ::Miui 7 ; ;^rtjj-xa' od v;d-iuu JTOC,qo n~ rrrid s v i ^ h 'ivriZeiV'' eiiifpi'.:!: MIJOY ad d-noss'ic 3".?. £>on;iL'o^r..r, od" o ? " o a i . : i j .toil" 3,oW vsrrxcv;*.?. arid" a.s jbnx? 9T3dd" VldTIy1.3C.;CiS d\Sdd" £)£ QDJ OHfLS 119 dd" riSffi'XJLSrfO SrfT X'sa od" rie :i$tsj"i nw ^rixcfd^aa ft.sd o n e ^ m ; ' i i .Jbsaolo -bsd"^d"a "1 c a 9 8 J;!;ISTC: h-:'d oxd"i.dM s d 8SJ$VHJ:]0 aCI . XIVL escort srld- 'io "xeiwo lIsrid - -^d n a e a u . s u v&uoii x? ^ffi^ffl bjsrt d"nr>fl6u bsT/x'-^'K.: a i X'i.^o3 add" ' i i iiTuo^b.B i o o o n o d".s J b ^ a o o i q a I'! 1 ?0X cfs ir^iXBCii n o ^ o x d o soiooH m b'sttnl ^sdT .BJi'iixjXqmcjO :i« t od" "-ri-j od" oid"o,^M sdT ^efid" Tscrd".srfi sidd" n o ifros od" svijuoexo ni &i isbiaaoo Jbns X'L^OQ'LOBC sdvs'isqo od" i}sd"d"j:i-fii£'q eci ^ a e i j " 8 d"i>nj3lj i o O n6jox-:tw sdd" n^dd - i a d d - o adrxiBlqciOo o n .T^acrc-.?. od- air^s.ux^Iqfiioo .^nxTRsci riftniuotJOB a i d ^ ! JJIJJCO add^ d'.'^id" l^avom oiBiod 9T..-dd" e,B dou;.^.Giix ?! . i!.-- d"vSrid" . a 9 3 3 5 n d " i w d~5g od" od- Iiiirf j s g nerlj" nBrnii.BriC .noissoa a1M s'loiso .1*1 d'aufc Jb..od o n s i , s o 8 a J .Cociu n a e o H . iM d".orfd" hisi% s ax ^ u i T s s d 3ii;i eie^ oSsid-B d,£>n..'3ld"*roO n o ri^oi3 n s s d .9G00 ;H .9?fiOQ391 ,bs:ie,n ions, ^ o n o n f i a a 0 H rxBdcr^i <3iio u.sdo aiM . b o r a i o i n x cj ni d\G c a l a IOHB sdi noqxj i b s v i s a vXi;I) need s n i - i s s d d-atxi: odd" UJS erm b^ci oa oiD od- �9 l noe they were given a l l the opportunity to present testimony on'.*&e, R a t i o n ^ n o x i o u s n e s s and offensivenees of the . . huslne.ss and failed to do so, 1 therefore move that the obtekW market be permitted to operate under the rules and regulations,: ae'pxesoriVed.W 4 e ,sanita,ry code of Westchester County. •'. " \ , ' • -, Seconded /by, Mr. < Eage. " " "H''": ' the Shaman, aske'd if there w&s^aay discussion. '••>?:-:K ' ^ ^ 8 e h t h a 3 / a s k e d if the unsigned, complaint received ; , •" ' ; ' ; : " : S ^^VSeoretaxy'stated.thaf i t i s 'taken for that it is wo*,*, •• ' ,-: "V'-J;- ' Tka-Ofcaiima* asKed, if > e Board-was ready to vote. ",< •.''''','"'/-;•&•!& :&«$mk taken and the ftotion was carried - ^ • C ^ i ^ l ^ ^ ' B a i d - ^ thought- i t :might he well for the. . . • ' • i ^ ^ ^ i A - * S ( t t i - i *0 pa*s.; te..W general question of 1 ' v, • ^. • ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ * . ^ % ^ r < ' '.* < «* ' - ." -* ; ^ ^ « ftwav a f i r t ' m a r k e t ^mA^UK ^,- '^i*;^&HM^WAVA* *»a only * a- t&W dQpr^^ away a J. J-* " • . �.v/i;^>".:. . :-/u 'v-7 ;v' cLx.nn: ::,^XTX>;O 1 ^BT\- . O ^ O L ej.ut xx h3:,.ss ac.-.T ncxxorf; Slid" IKX; '•qSJi ii>: £X ; i 3 3 " ' c"8.^.:.. aere-ii^dO erlT n s ^ i j asr? s t o v sriT .Yls^ronii:r.m.a.L' srij - lo'i: Xiw^ -a--:;' :xi;-iiu ;?x I m i o a j e.d M s a rxx^TlSffO sriT iTji:?,iQZ.h '"i;1.o- ,::J JxloaoX r.i.-.' fecii' aschxriici 9tic1' no siron o;t isri'qB'i^oriad"?. 1 l o £iOicrj;y.up L:'X3iX9;s s i ? u.: .s no a s e e - n x ^ d •fii HToaw '3 rid- K:;.SO O^ gHi^c.n's-to'.R oon ax frxsoS sdj unodguoiritr a u 3 }nfc rc nsaoxiiO "io " i x i l i d s ' i x s e . b •'hi pis I! .IS! iVj.QjOXy-x?-:q sncr 'in x e r ' o s m d o edt .j"'.-".^-:..^!" rlsx'i. ./;•' \y.vz .beieibxanoo JVXSOS. 2100b Tiis'i ft v i n o aai&$a^o srio" ee&o "id$ riI rioifi"? Jboouxod'rigisa ^n,-,3 ::v.dri" x'«:x ae"coj"a .aoi:3xvciG x?.n«; Jooo'i xs-CtKixa xo Tear-xin >s ?.<iti b.& hivi hseoj'.c I' r ? j i pi- in < i 3d" ^ r r x i s s a o x l a u q aJi^ jsiio jb^vor* o t a ' i o J . rxM �J#t* At a Special meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of North Tarrytown, N. Y., held at the Corporation Rooms in said Village on the 7th day of June, 1932. Presents Gerald B. Gould, Chairman William C. Schmidt John K. Mull on David Page, Jr. John J. Lofaro, Secretary Abraham N. Sadofsky, Corporation Counsel At the close of the Public Hearing in the matter of Scarano and Lasco, Mr. Gould called this Special meeting at 8:45 P.M. for the purpose of taking up and disposing of other matters now before the Board. The Secretary read an undated letter from Mr. Walter Luberger, addressed to this Board, which letter was received on June 6, 1952, asking permission to enlarge the present two car garage to a three car garage on premises owned by him at 139 Millard Avenue. With his application, Mr. Luberger enclosed copies of the minutes of a meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals held on April 25,1928 at which meeting the Board decided that the premises owned by him were nonconforming and that the building on said premises be permitted to be used as a two family dwelling. After due deliberation in the matter, the Board unanimously granted Mr. Lubergerfs application provided he comply with the requirements of the Building Inspector. In,theMatter of "Red Gables", a letter from Abraham N. Sadofsky, Corporation Counsel, dated June 4th, 1953, w a s read and acted upon. It was an opinion to the effect that any and all legal action by this Board or by the Board of Trustees against the owners of "Red Gables" �if. i Us ill Mill, I �to prohibit the existing violation, was now barred by the Statute of Limitations. Mr. i'ofaro moved that the opinion of Counsel be placed on file and that the case of "Red Gables" be closed. The motion was duly seconded and on the roll call was unanimously carried. Mr. Gould suggested that a copy of the Corporation Counsel's opinion be mailed to the Philipse Manor Improvement Association and a copy sent to the Tarry town Daily News for publication. Such a motion was made by Mr. Page, duly seconded, and carried. There being no further business, meeting adjourned at 9:30 P.M. to meet again on June 28th, 1932. Chairman �H? * M > .H i- m �* I. ^'W^ / <2 farriayiC /%s Jt^n-T^^^y ^^r!^^^^ /^t^ /z^c^C^s^^ �I fJl *5 $%**is Phone Tarrytown 1496 MRS. MARY SPENO Frigidine Permanent Waves $S.OO Manicure "j Finger Wave j %3*S~ Uc.BacH Shampoo J Saturdays and Holidays SOc. 207 Gordon Ave. N. TARRYTOWN, N. Y. i �4*' I ? ill ftffl 11 •mm �M . . .. S na I$5- 'i^PllflW : ^s K^-i w^^m&^m^ ^^SM^^^^^ :iS&'^;fev^'^ A v, �I ,\ ii. .1 '5 s m PI R> !;! I ii si *\ Si! ii ' pi ft.'! 1 1 III Slil �</* VILLAGE OF NORTH TARRYTOWN, N. Y. BOARD OF TRUSTEES FRED W. GROSS, MAYOR A R T H U R G. F R E D E R I C K S , A C T I N G M A Y O R 00 F- ^ R N E Y ABRAM N . SAD0F8KY ,(0HAEL J . COFFEY EDWARD C. V. C A S S E L L VILLAGE COUNSEL VILLAGE C L E R K & UL|AN T A X COLLECTOR C- GBAVESON M A R I O N A. DEELY WALLAOE DEPUTY CLERK HUTOHINBON F R A N K A. M A R A S C O AMES VILLAGE TREASURER F. JOHN8TON J E R O M E N. L A W L O R VILLAGE ENGINEER TRU8TEE8 June 20th, 1932 joard of Appeals, illage of § o r t h Tarrytown,N»x. Gentlemen: Information has come t o me that ^yor lahman ead Master of Highland Manor School, and property owned by him located on iroadway and College Ave, i n t h e Village of North Tarrytown, N . Y . has isplayed signs o r allowed signs t o "be displayed advertiseing lunches, inners and b r e a k f a s t , a l s o a sign reading t o u r i s t entrance, and one reading ighland Manor I n n . This property i s i n residence B. D i s t . Very respectfully yours, Build Building Inspector. �r m IUIFI �I^f 1 1 1 0 IITAVIST X* J M A l S T O I^t COUNTRY BOARDING S C H O O L AND JUNIOR COLLEGE TARRYTOWN-ON-HUDSON,N.Y. -TELEPHONE TARRYTOWN EUGENE ISOS SUMMER SCHOOL AND CAMP SOUTH NAPLES, ME. NEW YORK CITY OFFICE TEL. REGENT 4-7419 H.LEHMAN,DIRECTOR June 1 9 20th 3 2 Secretary John Lafaro, Zoning Board of Appeals, North Tarrytown, N.Y. Dear Mr Lafaro;May I ask the Zoning Board of Appeals through you to grant me a variance permitting me to conduct a tea room on the Highland Manor property during the school vacation months terminating early in September? I have been conducting a tea room during those months ever since I acquired the property in 1920. For several years the tea room was located in Cottage No, 4 located on Broadway and College Ave., North Tarrytown. Later, however, it was moved to Cottage No, 1 in Tarrytown. This year it is our desire to move the tea room back \ to Cottage 4. Assuring you that I would appreciate _Jyour co-operation in this matter, I am Faithfully yours, �:•;«; ik \ i |; • J'l \ V< ~::i 1' --.••A 1% II >v>' � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_ZONING_1932-06-07 Subject The topic of the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1932 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Village of Sleepy Hollow All Rights Reserved. Type The nature or genre of the resource Text https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/b41ce60576e06c530f23dccf3b40f872.pdf bfa79d927c5fc7858cc42ac074aeda1b PDF Text Text At a regular meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of North Tarrytovm, II.Y., held at the Corporation Rooms in said Village on the 28th day of June, 1932. Present: Gerald B. Gould, Chariman John K. Mull on David Page, Jr. John J. Lofaro, Secretary The meeting was called to order by Chairman Gould at 8:05 P.M. The minutes of the regular meeting of May 19th, 1932 and the minutes of the Special Meeting held on June 7th, 1932, were respectively read,and approved. An undated and unsiged letter, received by mail on June 9th, 1932, addressed to Secretary Lofaro complaining of certain alledged violations in Webber Park was read and placed on filed. In- connection with the matter, Mr. Lofaro informed the members of the Board that on June 11, 1932, he caused the following notice to appear in the Tarrytown Daily Hews: NOTICE ! Residents and Taxpayers of North Tarrytown The Zoning Board of Appeals from time to time receives unsiged complaints. This is to notify that any and all complaints unsigned will not be honered or in•vestigated by this Board. ' Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of North Tarry tovm. John J. Lofaro, Secretary. �••»••«! �lift The Board thereupon unaminously confirmed the acts of Secretary Lofaro and suggested that since no formal action could be taken by the Board, the complaint souldtoebrought to the Building Inspector's attention for investigation. A letter from Building Inspector, Percy G. Minnerly dated June 20, 1932, was read. Mr. Lofaro said that upon receipt of this letter, he communicated by telephone with Dr. Eugene H. Lehman, who said that he would immediately apply to this Board for a variance. An application from Dr. Eugene H. Lehman, dated June 20, 1932, to grant him a variance permitting him to conduct a tea room on the Highland Manor School property during vacation months terminating early in September, was read. Dr. Lehman appeared before the Board and testified in substance as follows: 1. That during the past twelve years, he had conducted and is still conducting the business of a tea room and inn during the vacation months on premises known as the Highland Manor School. 2. That this was and is done to cut down the overhead expenses in the operation and maintenance of the said school. 3. That Cottage number 4 on College Avenue and Broadway is now adopted for a tea room Inasmuch as the school equipped the said cottage for its Domestic Science Classes. That Cottage number 1, situated in Tarry town was formerly used for that purpose. 4. That very little income is derived from the tea room business, averaging two or three customers daily. 5. That the accomodation of over night guests is by far the biggest item. Some nights there may be a considerable number of guests and other nights a few . That these guests are distributed throughout the campus and are more apt to be lodged in Tarry town than in North Tarry town. After careful consideration and deliberation by the Board, Mr. Lofaro moved that Dr. Eugene H. Lehman be granted permission to continue the operation of the tea room business and inn upon the following grounds: �A5" r i i il i iffill!!8«| I �/*$' 1. That the Highland Manor School is located in Tarry town and partly in Worth Tarrytown. 2. That premises in question are located in Residence "Bn district. 3. That Private Schools and Boarding or Lodging houses not primarily for transient guests are a permitted use in Residence M B" district. 4. That Dr. Lehman has been conducting a tea room business and inn on school premises during the vaction months for the past twelve years. 5. That although the business is not a continuous one throughout the entire year, it may be considered so in these particular circumstances to spell out a non-conforming use. 6. That in this particular case the strict letter of the Zoning Ordinance as applied to the specific premises could not be applied and that unneccessary hardship would result to Dr. Lehman. The motion was duly seconded by Mr. Mull on and on the roll call was unaminously carried. There being no further business to transact, the meeting adjourned at 8:45 P.M. Chairman �If): •'» u �lite Plains irk t h e r e , a Plains, i Saturday inspector In charge I upon rehis newai * of the > himself "experijstlgators Igei' valuail of the e in this >N < FERED ^—An edu>rk State's before t h e amniission Irison conMi.. . , . 'as woven illiteracy contained ; "sufficient ftmates to il, t'o write j>6 able to arithmetic D ARADE 1 (UP)—A |s assigned >le disorder and demonlast Side in ting in the •n t a x p a y e r alleged- exjv York EdiI ,fiye ser,e, of m a r c h p - t h e State ional police!er two sej> Ing.wae oil a fton Heighta &EAD .'.'.' rThebody of 'hermit, was ack h e had he iived>of£} city durno,' 3 to natural ivestigatlng. «unai will be in the old Butch Church yard in Sleepy Hollow Cemetery. Four sons survive; they are, Fred Conklin, Augustus Conklln a n d Webser Conklin-'of Glenvllle and George Conklin of White I J lains. TJF.'NolanAsks Filling Station Permit In N. T. Claims Business Can Be Conducted At Broadway, Piejrson Avenue A gasoline station is planned for the corner of Broadway and Pierson Avenue by Timothy F . Nolan, who filed a request for permission to establish one with the • North • Tarrytpwn Board of Trustees Friday n i g h t r The board referred it to the Street and Sidewalk Committee for report. Mr. Nolan is awaiting a reply from the board following the comrnlttee's report next Friday night. He said- today that he is certain of his r i g h t ' to establish the gasoline station there. In the deed to his property he is not prohibited from running a business on it. , He has conducted business there for approximately 15 years. The property is more desirable for business t h a n residence. Broadway is actually a "railroad" and should not be zoned under Residence A which applies to high class residence property, he stated today. •*• He contends t h a t his is the only unrestricted property in the manor section.- The cemetery, he contends, is a business and adjoining the cemetery is a tombstone cutting plant and a gasoline station. South of that it is zoned entirely for business to Bedford Road. North of Belle wood Avenue on t h e / west side of the. street there is busy ness in" operation. , He feels that he IS entitled:'.-to conduct business on his property and will fight for the right to establish a- gasoline station if 'the.' village does not approve it. W i t h huge trucks and other traffic running over Broadway now, residents along the Philipse Manor frontage on the hill cannot sleep, a t night with the noise and they a r e disturbed in the daytime also, He awaits the report of the board's committee. � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_ZONING_1932-06-28 Subject The topic of the resource Zoning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1932 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1932 Rights Information about rights held in and over the resource Village of Sleepy Hollow All Rights Reserved. Type The nature or genre of the resource Text