https://sleepyhollow.localarchives.org/files/original/6aa559ecf4d1b6eadfdf74ac0815b1a4.pdf fb3d961b5203282de069383c959c7081 PDF Text Text A regular meeting of the Planning Board was held on Thursday, October 18, 1990 at 8:25 PM in Village Hall, North Tarrytown, New York. Members Present: Also Present: Ellen Tsangaris, Chairperson Allan Kaplan James Galgano Richard Ayers Ray Windas John O'Leary James Margotta, John J. Hughes, Joseph Gulino, Thomas Gissen, Building Inspector Village Attorney Consultant/CAMCE Consultant/F.P. CLARK ASSOC. A motion to approve the August 9, 1990 minutes as written was made by John O'Leary and the motion was seconded by Richard Ayers and was passed unanimously. IN THE MATTER OF SABASTIAN AMENTA, 23 9 NORTH BROADWAY. NORTH TARRYTOWN. NEW YORK. Mr. Amenta has requested a six month extension of the resolution of site plan approval which was granted by the Planning Board eighteen months ago. A motion was made by Richard Ayers to grant the approval for the extension of the resolution for a six (6) month period, ending April 18, 1991. The motion was seconded by John O'Leary and passed unanimously by the board. IN THE MATTER OF LEONARD RUTILGAN LESSEE OF 9 7 COLLEGE AVENUE. NORTH TARRYTOWN. NEW YORK AND OWNED BY TORRES AND SON CONTRACTORS. INC.. 17 SCHUDY PLACE. NEW ROCHELLE. NEW YORK. A Public Hearing was held by the Planning Board to hear and consider an application of Leonard Rutilgan as above, for final site approval plans to convert the existing storage building into an automotive repair shop at 97 College Avenue. �Mr. Julius Twyne, an architect representing Leonard Rutilgan, explained that the plans would show six repair bases,an office space, a bathroom facility and storage space. Mr. Rutliglan will also add drainage that will take residue from the workers area that is washed out. A new trench drain will be installed, connecting to the same line. In addition to these changes, an exhaust system will be installed through the roof towards the east side of the auto body shop. They will also have a general exhaust fan that will exhaust materials from cars that are being worked on during the day. There are also two skylights that will be left in place. There is a concern about the fumes in a residential area. There are also three vents, which will ventilate the fumes. Mr. Margotta stated that there have been no complaints in the past about the paint fumes. Mr. Gissen mentioned that their main concern was the parking in this residential area. Mr. Rutilgan stated that he will have approximately 12 cars in and out in one day. Employee parking will be in the building. Mr. Margotta recommends that they should put in a sprinkler system because the state code may require one in the future. PUBLIC COMMENT: Mr. Frank Paolontonio, 158 Depeyster Street stated that he was in favor of granting a permit for the automotive repair shop. A motion was made by John O'Leary to grant site plan approval and seconded by Richard Ayers and was passed unanimously by the the board. Comments submitted by Village engineer and consultants are attached hereto and incorporated in this resolution of site plan approval. IN THE MATTER OF SLEEPY HOLLOW CEMETERY. NORTH TARRYTOWN, NEW YORK. A Public Hearing was held by the Planning Board to hear and consider the development of Sleepy Hollow Cemetery. Mr. Larry Narccheia, P.E., who is representing Sleepy Hollow Cemetery, discussed the site plan review. In reviewing the site plan, Mr. Narccheia points out that there is a ravine which is approximately .71 acres in area. The applicability of the wetlands/watercourse legislation was discussed in detail by the consultant. �Mr. Donald Stever addressed the Board. He indicated that the question of whether there were wetlands on the site, as defined by the ordinance, was not as yet adequately clarified. A motion to close the public hearing was made by John O'Leary and Seconded by James Galgano. The motion was passed unanimously. BUSINESS MEETING: After a long discussion it was decided to table the matter until the next meeting. In the interim, a wetlands investigation will be performed by Frederick P. Clarks Associates. A report will be submitted to the Board prior to the next meeting. Being no further business, a motion was made by John O'Leary, seconded by James Galgano to adjourn the meeting at 9:25 PM. The following Planning Board meeting will be held on Thursday, November 15, 1990. Respectfully submitted, Christine A. Y&rkovic Recording Secretary �P H A P I P<5 A M A M H A M A R O t n M H L C D M ' „.?J1" CONSULTING ENGINEERS COURT PLAZA NORTH. 25 MAIN ST. HACKENSACK.NJ 07601-7032 120 EAST 75TH STREET SUITE 8C NEW YORK. NEW YORK 10021 201342-4200 212-683-7712 FAX. 201-342-0790 TABLE OF CONTENTS MEMORANDUMS - PROPOSED SUBDIVISION/SITE PLAN UPDATES VILLAGE OF NORTH TARRYTOWN, NEW YORK (OCTOBER, 1990) MEMORANDUM DESCRIPTION CAMCE REF. NO 1. Sleepy Hollow Cemetery - Proposed subdrain near Route 9 1368R 2. Automotive Repair Shop 97 College Avenue 1384R �CHARLES A. MANGANARO M E M O R A N D U M TO: Village of North Tarrytown Planning Board FROM: Joseph A. Gulino, Project Engineer Charles A. Manganaro Consulting Engineers DATE: October 12, 1990 RE: Sleepy Hollow Cemetery - Proposed Subdrain Near Route 9 CAMCE #1368R As of this date, our comments concerning the hydraulic aspects of the above referenced project have been substantially addressed. Accordingly, we have no other significant objections to the proposed plan. We trust this information satisfies any inquiries you may have. If you require any additional information, please let us know. JAG:ab:958 enc. cc: Mr. William T. Regan, Village Administrator Mr. James T. Margotta, Building Inspector John J. Hughes, Jr., Village Attorney Mr. Thomas Gissen, Assoc. Cons. - Frederick P. Clark Associates (via Facsimile) Mr. Larry Nardecchia, P.E. �CHARLES A. MANGANARO M E M O R A N D U M TO: Village of North Tarrytown Planning Board FROM: Joseph A. Gulino, Project Engineer Charles A. Manganaro Consulting Engineers DATE: October 12, 1990 RE: Lenny's Auto Repair 97 College Avenue CAMCE #1384R Per our review of the site plan dated August 27, 1990, prepared by Mr. Charles Riley, Land Surveyor; our comments concerning potable water, sewage, and storm drainage, are as follows: A. The location of all existing structures a,nd other man-made features of the site, as well as those o n adjacent properties, including existing utility lines (gas & electric). B. The location and design of the proposed water supply, sewage disposal and storm water drainage systems, including the locations, sizes, invert, and rim elevations to the existing water supply, sewage disposal, and storm water drainage systems. C. Existing and proposed topography map of the subdivision, extending at least twenty (20) ft. beyond the site boundaries with contour intervals not greater than rive (5) ft. and referenced to USGS or other approved bench mark and scale. D. The nature and location of all other existing site features, including wetlands, water courses, wooded areas, and rock outcrops. E. The plan shall clearly indicate which site features are existing and proposed, and which will be removed. F. Owner's endorsement. G. Planning Board Chairman's endorsement per subdivision regulations, Part IV, Page 7817 (14C). H. The locations of nearest fire hydrants. I. The widths of streets and avenues encompassing the site. �CHARLES A. MANGANARO Page 2 Memorandum Lenny's Auto Repair CAMCE #1384R J. An area map showing all streets and property within one thousand (1,000) ft. of the applicant's property, at a scale of one (1) inch to four hundred (400) ft. All property owned by the applicant shall be clearly identified. K. Flow and pressure requirements for the fire sprinkler system and backflow preventers, if required. The above-mentioned comments should either be shown or noted on the drawings. Final recommendations will be made to the Planning Board once these comments are addressed. If you require any additional information, please let us know. JAG/gsb.962 cc: Mr. William T. Regan, Village Administrator Mr. James T. Margotta, Building Inspector John J. Hughes, Jr., Esq. Thomas Gissen, Assoc. Cons. - Frederick P. Clark Assoc. (Via Facsimile) Leonard A. Rutiglan �MEMORANDUM To: Village of North Tarrytown Planning Board From: Frederick P. Clark Associates Date: October 18, 1990 Subject: Sleepy Hollow Mitigation Planting Plan. I- INTRODUCTION. On October 17, 1990, Jim Donovan, ASIA and Thomas Gissen, AICP of Frederick P. Clark Associates met with representatives of the Sleepy Hollow Cemetery in order to attempt to develop a mitigation planting plan that would be satisfactory to the applicants and to the Village Planning Board. At the Planning Board meeting of September 27, 1990, the Planning Board and the applicant had agreed that such a meeting of consultants might prove beneficial in developing a satisfactory planting plan. II. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND. Through the course of this application there has been much concern expressed by both the Village Planning Board and the applicant regarding the issue of providing a planting plan as mitigation for the visual and vegetative losses that would be necessitated by the proposed action. The applicant's original two submissions (plans dated April 10, 1990 and May 21, 1990) contained no references to a mitigation planting plan. At the request of the Planning Board, the applicant did prepare a mitigation planting plan on June 16, 1990. However, this plan carried a note that stated, "Exact type of tree and location to be determined by the Cemetery Authorities." This effectively rendered the plan non-binding and unenforceable. Later the applicant proposed to plant several trees along North Broadway (Route 9) instead of providing any required new plantings within the subject site itself. However, at the Planning Board meeting of September 27, 1990, a view was expressed by some members of the Planning Board that mitigation plantings should be provided within the site as well as on North Broadway in order to compensate for the vegetative and aesthetic loss the proposed action would entail. III. PROPOSED PLAN. At the meeting of October 18, 1990 between Clark Associates and the applicant's representatives, the applicant agreed to provide nine American Sycamore trees along North Broadway and to provide five Red Oak trees and five Littleleaf Linden trees within the subject site. All of the trees are to maintain a minimum 3.5 inch caliper �* when planted (this means that the tree trunks will be at least 3.5 inches in diameter at their base). No specific placement for the ten trees that are to be planted in the affected area has been determined. It was agreed that the placement of the trees would be determined after the final grade is set but before the final seeding is performed. The actual placement of the trees shall be subject to approval by either the Village Building Inspector or the Village's Planning Consultants or both, as determined by the Planning Board. The applicant has indicated that they will seek to gain some assistance from the Town in paying for the instillation of the American Sycamore trees along North Broadway. We informed the applicant that while we do not feel it is important that the Planning Board concern itself with who pays for the trees, we recommend that all of the trees be required as a condition of site plan approval. In other words, we recommend that the planting of the trees be a requirement of site plan approval, regardless of whether the applicant can persuade an outside party to assist in paying for the trees. The site plan that the applicant and Clark Associates have agreed to recommend also requires that 20 trees in the affected area be preserved for their natural lifetime and to provide compensatory plantings when those trees die. Furthermore, the applicant agreed that the buffer row of pines along the northern end of the affected area shall be maintained in perpetuity. III. CONCLUSION. There is no doubt that the visual aesthetic of this area will be affected by the proposed action. However, we believe that if the planting plan agreed to by the applicants is implemented in its entirety, then this will constitute suitable mitigation for losses associated with the proposed action. Thomas Gissen, AICP Associate Consultant cc: Mayor Janet Gondalfo William Regan John Hughes, Jr. James Margotta Larry Nardecchia 500\not0-020.tg 2 � Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource Planning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1990 Text A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text. Dublin Core The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/. Title A name given to the resource MINS_PLAN_1990-10-18 Subject The topic of the resource Planning Board Minutes & Resolutions-1990 Date A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource 1990